Home : Replacement Windows Reviews : Majic
Majic Window And Doors
Page Sections
Get Our Recommended Window List
Also please consider filling out the free form on our site for 3 quality window price quotes — it’s how we afford to provide free consumer information. We’re not incentivized by ANY company and will help you with ANY questions you might have, and help you navigate ANY bids you receive. That’s our guarantee to you!
What They Sell
The company manufactures their own line of fiberglass windows (as opposed to buying them elsewhere and relabeling them). Majic makes several claims about themselves. One: that they sell more fiberglass windows than any company on the planet - which may be true but I think I might stick with Marvin fiberglass windows for now.
Their second claim is that they manufacture the most energy-efficient fiberglass window on the market. (Click for our picks on the best fiberglass windows on the market.) I can’t image in that Majic beats out Alpen HPP or Inline, but again I can’t be sure of this.
Majic Window Warranty
Majic fiberglass windows come with a 50 year warranty on the mainframe, hardware and components. Specifically, the company warrants against manufacturing defects. My assumption is that the labor warranty also extends to the original buyer, but this is not specifically stated. As to its transferability, this is still an open question for me. Unfortunately, he website does not contain much information on the warranty specifics. When (and if) I get this information, I will be sure to update this section of the site detailing Majic windows reviews.
Homeowner Majic Window Reviews
Our Majic homeowner question and answer section has it all - accolades, complaints, bids, installation questions - it runs the gamut. I hope it's helpful and we're always here to help you out in your quest to find quality windows at an affordable price....as best as we are able :)
Dane - Site Editor
Michigan Replacement Window Options
Hi fellas. Curious what your experience has been with Majic Windows. We just moved to Michigan and these guys are everywhere here. I really like the idea of fiberglass windows vs vinyl so that seems to be a big plus. What is your opinion on the differences betweeen these two materials. Thank you in advance and have a great holiday season.
- Homeowner - from 2025
Editor Reply
Lana, while I certainly know of Majic, I’m not completely certain that that’s the fiberglass window brand I would recommend. However, I do have a list of top fiberglass windows that I can send to you for your consideration. Regardless, I would recommend getting a bid from Majic to see how their pricing compares to brands like Inline, Marvin, and Alpen - all of which are on my list.
Additionally, I would say that top tier vinyl windows are going to go toe to toe with top fiberglass windows on performance and so if you go with a top tier vinyl, you’re going to be well served (assuming good installation). Fiberglass windows are generally nicer looking, although I might say this is on a window by window basis. The other big factor is cost ~ fiberglass can be as much as 50% more so often this factors into the final equation. Bottom line ~ collect your bid from Majic Windows, along with your others and let’s go from there.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2025
Fiberglass Or Vinyl Question
Hi Dane, we have 34 wood windows 35 years old that need to be replaced and are open to fiberglass or vinyl windows. We are looking for more narrow lines enjoying more glass and are still energy efficient. Also, we have looked at Sunrise, Majic, Marvin and Simonton. However, we decided against Sunrise as we did not care for the new black spacers in their windows and Majic's windows did not impress compare with the Marvin fiberglass windows. So now we are looking at Marvin Essential and the Simonton 6500. The prices are huge difference.
Prices for our final two options as follows: Marvin Essential fiberglass windows - $48,000. Simonton 6500 - Vinyl -$26,000 at WW. As you can see big difference. Could you please share your thoughts on these windows….quality etc. Is Marvin worth paying almost double….and not sure of the quality of the Simonton window. We will appreciate your input!
Wendy - Homeowner - from 2025
[Site Editor's Answer]
Wendy, I definitely like the Marvin Essential series, but not at 2x over the Simonton windows prices. The Simonton 6500 is a good vinyl window. Not a great one, but a solid performer overall. Honestly, I would love to see another bid in between those two as a counterweight, but I guess that was what the Sunrise was. Frankly, Sunrise would be my pick - is there a way around the spacer issue? Can you order a non black spacer? Or upgrade to a spacer that is not black?
If not, I think the Simonton option is decent, but I'm not sure I'd give it the thumbs up if you're staying in your home long term...you still might want to consider another bid...
Dane - Site Editor - from 2025
Does Majic Window Stand Behind Their Work?
Had some Majic fiberglass windows go in several years ago and we've had issues with them from the start. I think it's less the window itself and more than crappy install they did. I'm just so disappointed with the whole thing as I thought that fiberglass windows were supposed to be so great. Not happy.
Rebecca - Homeowner - from 2024
Related Topic: Majic Windows Lawsuit
Majic Windows vs Wallside
Hi what windows would you recommend for Michigan winters? Anlin or Wallside, Majic or Pella Imperial or Anderson fibrex? All the best
Arjun - Homeowner - from 2024
[Site Editor's Answer]
Arjun, Anlin will not be available your state so that option is out. Wallside ought to be considered, at least for a bid - I'm not the biggest fan, but you will want to collect a series of quotes for the sake of price comparisons. Majic is still a bit of a mystery to me in terms of overall quality - they sell a fiberglass window, which is going to be considerably more expensive than vinyl so get the bid, but expect it to be expensive.
Pella sells an Impervia, not an Imperial - the Pella Impervia is in my opinion a low quality fiberglass window that I would pass on. Renewal By Andersen is worth a bid, but it will probably be long and the bid will be very expensive. I'm going to send you a list of recommended windows that should provide some additional options and brands.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2024
Majic vs Castle Windows
We are in the process of collecting bids and we got one from Castle. Ended up being roughly $825 a window. The other quote was from Majic at $890 a window, but Majic is fiberglass so it makes sense that it costs more money, right? Which is better for the money?
Deb - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Deb, I'm still in my "infant" stages in terms of Majic reviews. I don't love United vinyl windows though. I think you should continue looking for bids. I'm going to send you my list of recommendations.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Experience With This Company
Hi Dane. I was curious what your experience with majic window has been. It doesn’t seem as if you have a lot of reviews on your site, but I thought maybe you have some insight into the overall quality. Also looking at Sunrise, but they are probably out of my price range based on your reviews. Thanks so much - your other reviews had so much information that I thought maybe you were holding out on me. Ha ha.
Dennis - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Dennis, I have to admit my reviews on this company are pretty thread bare I have been working to improve them for several months now, but thus far I have not had much success. I am happy to send you my list of recommended window options, which I think should serve you very well.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Customer Complaint
Recently stumbled over your reviews on this company and wanted to chime in on my experience with Majic. In 2021 we purchased a patio door from them and I think we paid like six grand and did so (we thought it was expensive at the time) because the slider carried a 20 or 25 year warranty (can't remember which now). Regardless, we had an issue two years later and we called and they said that the door manufacturer and therefore we were SOL.
The problem with their argument was that they were the manufacturer of the door. When we finally got through that rigamarole, then they told us that they charge $125 for a service call. I was so confused -- why did their product carry a warranty if they were going to then charge me when something happened to the darn thing. Very frustrating company to work with -- buyer beware.
Jocelyn - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Jocelyn, definitely a buyer beware case in point. I will post this on our Majic review page so that others can check out your experience and decide from there whether they want to get a project bid from the company.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Majic Window Reviews
I’ve been reading reviews on this company Magic (sp?) and they are genuinely bizarre! It’s either 1 star or 5 star - almost to a tee. I kinda believe the 1 stars because those are p-o'ed customers. Right? That makes sense. But how can there be such disjointed reviews on a single company? No one thinks they are just okay and gives them 2, 3, or 4 stars. I’m confused. Would you consider them?
Jessica - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Jessica, so I did some searching and you’re right…they are all either 1 star or 5 stars. I read a handful of the 5 star reviews and they seemed very generic, although it could also simply be that Majic Windows incentivizes their customers to write a favorable review and in exchange they will knock of $100 or something to this. This is relatively common and isn't necessarily a bad practice. I’m assuming that these are satisfied customers, because no one would endorse a company that did crappy work. I just think that these reviews on the whole can’t really be trusted.
I also wouldn’t use a company for my house that had that many 1 star reviews. What is the point of taking a chance when you can go with a tried and true company that has nearly all 5 star reviews. I’ll send you my list of trusted brands and window series.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Majic Window Company Price Quote
Hi Dane, first of all, thank you for the incrdible information on your website. So I live in Michigan 48745 zip code. This proerty has been part of our family for more than 120 years. The place is small with an even smaller upstairs attic area that now has the windows all boarded up. Also the roof and siding needs some patch work and I'd like to find a single company to do this work if possible.
One company gave me a bid for $29K for Alliance Windows and Certainteed vinyl siding. When I asked him if he'd break down the quote he was not very happy and kind of did it, but not well. He seemed like he was kind of winging the bid.
Another company called A Window and Siding Warehouse gave me a bid for $39K, but they carry Andersen windows and doors, which I know is much better than Alliance.
Finally, we got a bid from Majic on their fiberglass windows and the roof repair for $28K -- this did not include any siding work, but they said they had a company who would do that work. Anyway, I'd love to hear what you think my best option is.
Marilyn - Homeowner - from 2023
Editor Reply
Marilyn, I think you might want to get a couple more bids just to see what else is out there - take a look at our Majic window reviews site for our company write up. Of the three bids you have, I think I like the Andersen 100 series window. Curious about the Majic bid if the siding bid is $6K or less. I'm gonna send you my recommended list for you to take a look at and perhaps expand your search.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Majic Window Review
We had Majic window install Windows and doors a number of years ago and we thought they did a very good job. The windows have had no issues and the patio doors are doing great. The installer team was clean and respectful and cleaned up after the job. Couldn’t have gone better from our perspective.
Just wanted to drop this quick line as I saw on your Majic window reviews page that several others were not happy with their service. I will add that I’m not an expert or anything, but our experience was good. Thanks for all that you do for consumers out there who have no idea how to figure out this very odd world of windows.
Marjorie - Homeowner - from 2022
Editor Reply
Marjorie, thanks for the information. I will be sure to post in on our page to let our homeowners see your experience with the company and make their own judgement about the quality of the service. The more information the better as far as I'm concerned. Thanks again and enjoy the holiday season with your awesome windows and doors :)
Dane - Site Editor - from 2022
Related Topics: Champion Windows Reviews
New South Windows Reviews