Composite Windows Reviews

Replacement Windows Reviews Header

Home : Frame & Material : Composite Windows Reviews

Composite Windows Reviews

Explore composite windows reviews to see what brands and models homeowners and contractors recommend. For additional information, see our page on composite window prices.

Get Our Recommended Window List

Also please consider filling out the free form on our site for 3 quality window price quotes — it’s how we afford to provide free consumer information. We’re not incentivized by ANY company and will help you with ANY questions you might have, and help you navigate ANY bids you receive. That’s our guarantee to you!

Composite Windows In Auburn California

We are looking to replace our windows in our home. We live in Colfax-Auburn CA area. I'm thinking we would like to go with Composite windows. We have 3 sliding doors and lots of windows.

Debbie - Homeowner - from 2022

[Website Editor Answers]

Debbie, here are my recommendations:

[Email for his recommendations]

Dane - Website Editor - from 2022

Renewal Composite Window Alternatives

We are interested in replacing our 30 plus windows. We think we would like composite windows. We have met with a Renewal by Anderson rep, but we really don’t want to spend $50,000 on windows! We like the 20-year warranty and the maintenance-free aspects. Do your windows compare?

Janet - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Janet, we don't sell windows, but I can give you some alternatives to the Renewals, which tend to be very expensive. The Andersen 100 is similar in construction to the Renewals, both of them are made from the fibrex material (both made by Andersen). The Andersen 100 window will be quite a bit less expensive.

The best composite window in my opinion is the Okna Starmark Series. It's a bit beefy for some consumer's taste, but it's a great window that will easily outperform the Renewal and Andersen 100. The Sunrise Restorations window is a vinyl window that uses some nice composite materials in the reinforced sash and frame. This too will blow the doors off the Renewals in terms of energy efficiency and price.

If these aren't available in your area, I would suggest getting a top tier vinyl window (the Sunrise Restorations window is often considered a vinyl window). Visually, it's pretty tough to distinguish a composite and vinyl window. High quality vinyl windows often are available in interior laminates that look like wood, but don't require the maintenance of wood, carry better warranties, and offer better energy efficiency. These give you the best of both worlds (assuming you like the look of them) -- good looks, great energy efficiency, and a price tag that won't break the bank.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

Composite Windows vs Vinyl

How reliable are composite windows? Some composite siding have had some pretty big issues.

William - Homeowner - from 2015

[Site Editor's Response]

William, you bring up an excellent subject and one that doesn't necessarily have any a single answer. Even the word composite is a bit all over the board because every window company that manufactures and markets a composite window uses a proprietary mix of materials. As a general rule of thumb, composite windows are made from a mixture of vinyl and wood (often time essentially saw dust, although they rarely use this word in their marketing because it hardly sounds like the stuff of strength).

Composite window manufacturers often tout their composite windows as stronger and more durable than all vinyl windows out there. This is rarely the case. Are top composite windows better than low quality and mid range vinyl windows, yes. But certainly the opposite could be said as well.

Composite windows must be judged on a case by case basis. I would say that the top composite windows are going to be just as strong and durable as top vinyl windows, perhaps even a bit more durable. However, I would say that the performance numbers (and here I'm talking about U-factor and air infiltration primarily) on the top vinyl will outperform the composite equivalent. Look at Renewal By Andersen, they make a very expensive composite window that is admittedly quite nice looking and has some nice features. However, the performance numbers on the RBA double hung is pretty darn mediocre.

Here's a case in point.

The title of your email was Okna composite windows so let's look at this window. The Okna Starmark series is a beefy window that is an excellent performer, made extremely well, and is going to last for a long time if installed correctly. It typically runs about 10% to 15% more than the Okna 800 Envirostar (the company's top of the line vinyl window). However, the Okna 800 offers a .01 AI, while the Okna Starmark offers a .05 AI (the U-factor and SHGC numbers are nearly identical). Is this a huge difference no, but the question then becomes why spend more for a window that offers less impressive performance.

I think at the end of the day, the answer to your question comes down to the particular window you are considering, how well it is made and what performance it will offer. As far as the Okna goes, it's a great window.

Dane - Site Editor - from 2015

Vinylmax Sherwood Review

Any opinions on the Vinylmax Sherwood? It's supposed to be some kind of vinyl/wood hybrid? I was originally looking at the Simonton 5500 and the Sunrise (not sure which model Verde maybe?), but then someone suggested these and I'm not sure what to do.

Anna - Homeowner - from 2011

[Contractor Response]

I don't like the Sherwood model, it looks to me like they made a cheap vinyl window and glued wood to it. It's also bulky, which means a lot less glass to let light in. Look at the Andersen Woodwright, it has similar vinyl exterior and wood interior but much higher quality. Marvin makes a composite, too. For that matter, there are tons of all vinyl windows that offer wood-look interior.

Todd - Contractor - from 2011

Read additional Marvin windows reviews.

Okna Starmark

I looked at a lot of windows before going with the Okna Starmarks. They look nice and actually cost less than the Marvin Infinity. They aren't vinyl, more of a composite, and the only thing I didn't like about them was that they have a little less glass space. We were able to afford entry and storm doors, too, which we weren't sure we'd be able to get. I'm really satisfied with them and I don't regret it at all.

Joe - Homeowner - from 2010

Andersen 100 Composite Series

I've used some Andersen windows, mainly the 100 series. The only real benefit to using them is that they paint well. I would recommend switching to a vinyl window, the Andersens are a composite of fiberglass and wood. They are overpriced and don't perform as well as cheaper vinyl windows.

Bradley - Installer - from 2010

Okna Starmark or Viwinco Cambridge

Starmark vs Cambridge, I think the Starmark wins by a mile. The Viwinco looks good on paper, its ratings are competitive, but they don't last long and they are just cheap and flimsy.

Will - Contractor in Illinois - from 2010

Okna 900 Series

I've been looking into Okna and I've found out a lot of info. The Starmark has a thicker frame, and I don't like that so much. The Okna500 and Okna800 are very similar as far as the frame goes. The 800 has smaller lifting rails (I think they look nicer than the Okna500) and it has a magnetic seal which I like. My biggest problem with the Okna500 is that you can see from the outside if it's locked or not. Basically, I like the 800 better, but it is also more expensive. It isn't much in terms of cost and I think the difference is worth it. Also, the Okna800 I was looking at qualified for a tax credit, but the 500 didn't, which kind of makes up for the higher cost.

Steven - Homeowner - from 2009

Read more on Okna windows reviews.

Amsco vs Milgard Windows

I think Amsco is pretty good. I'd go with Milgard as my first choice, but Amsco is better than Simonton windows. You'll definitely get a better price if you're doing at least one side of the house, one window at a time gets steep.

Amsco's Studio and Artisan series are vinyl, and the Renaissance ones are composites. (Check out all of our Amsco Windows reviews here.) Their warranties are lousy, they will send you parts but they don't cover any labor at all. They'll tell you that the dealer or installer handles that, but when you ask them they'll say to ask Amsco about it. If you can handle any repairs yourself, then you don't need the labor warranty and they aren't a bad deal.

Mike - Homeowner - from 2005

Select Type Of Window
Select Frame Material
Window Brand Quality
Installation Requirements
How Many Windows?
Zip Code

Private Policy