Simonton Window Reviews | VantagePointe, Daylight Max, Reflections And More

REVIEWS

BEST WINDOWS

WINDOWS PRICES

STYLES

Home : Replacement Windows Reviews : Simonton

Simonton Windows Reviews

Simonton Windows is one of the largest replacement window companies in the United States, with one of the most recognizable names in the business. Their windows and doors are available through a number of different channels, including the big box stores such as Lowes, Dixieline, Sears and Home Depot. As well, many local contractors and companies sell Simonton to their customer base. Finally, some higher end stores do carry Simonton's higher end window and door series.

What They Sell: Simonton Windows are available in all 50 United States, including Alaska and Hawaii. The company sells a slew of vinyl windows and doors - their most popular series include the VantagePointe 6500 Series, Reflections, Impressions, Daylight Max, and StormBreaker Plus series.

Quality Products: The company stands behind their products and has lots of series and models to choose from. Their lower end series Assure and Reflections windows aren't great, but their mid range and higher end Reflections, Impressions and StormBreaker Series are well built and often competitively priced.

One Downside: The company sells A LOT of window and door series, which can be confusing. (It even confuses me sometimes and I live and breath this stuff.) Here is an example - the Reflections 5300 series is essentially identical to the Prism Ultra Gold Series (originally they teamed up with Norandex on this window). At one point, the Prism Series was only available to certain window dealers, but now the different names tend to be more geographical in nature.

Company Rating: Simonton Windows gets a 4.3 out of 5 stars based on 212 consumer reviews below.

Dane - Site Editor - Page Last Updated: April 9, 2024

Stormbreak Plus Cost: $$$/$$$$
(3/4 out of 5)

Nita, the Simonton 5500 is a good window. Call up the Zen dealer and have them come out and give you a bid. Tell them you only want a bid on the Nirvana and Lotus, not the Karma model. The Nirvana and Lotus are the Soft-Lite Classic and Soft-Lite Pro (confusing right?)

Both of these models are quite good and are often at a nice price point. Not always so, but often. The more bids you have, the stronger your negotiating position.

Good luck!

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

Simonton 5500 Review

I need to replace 14 windows (2 double casements, 2 single casements, 10 awning). I've had estimates from a number of companies. I recently viewed the Simonton 5500 series. Nice window, but man, I now understand the importance of VT (Visual Transmittance). The sample was a double hung window, but holy cow, there was a lot of frame in that window. I realized how important VT is when considering replacement windows. The VT rating for the Simontons was .49. It is hard to find the VT rating for a lot of windows. Most of my windows will be casements or awnings, so maybe VT isn't as much a factor. In a double hung it was pretty obvious.

I've seen the Okna casement product. They are beautiful and have a good VT of .54, but the price is about $12,500, which is above my $10,000 budget.

I am waiting to see the Ply Gem Premium sample. What good mid-range windows have a good VT rating? I am also looking at the Sunrise windows.

I love this website. I have learned so much in the past 2 months. You guys really do a great service to homeowners.

Jeff - Homeowner - from 2015

[Site Editor's Response]

Jeff, thank you for the nice compliments, we try our best to help out homeowners who are looking to get the best value for their dollar. I am surprised by how expensive that Okna casement window quote is, $12,500 for 14 windows is a lot of money. Those double casements can be quite expensive.

Simonton Windows do tend to be somewhat bulky. Ironically, American windows are much less bulky than vinyl windows in Europe, which are extremely bulky but also last considerably longer and offer better performance. It's basically a trade-off and those are some of the choices that you as a homeowner have to make. Vinyl, for the most part, will offer better performance numbers than other materials, the one exception being fiberglass.

Sunrise makes a pretty good vinyl window that uses a less bulky frame and it sounded like you were going to take a look at them. I'd be curious how you thought they measure up to the Ply Gem premium that you looked at.

In terms of comparing window numbers, you should look at the NFRC.org website. Click on the verify ratings residential link and search by manufacturer. The website is a little tricky to discern as far as what components and glass the window is using, however it has a wealth of information that will give you VT ratings, u factor and SHGC.

Let me know what you end up doing and how the nfrc.org site helps to compare the VT numbers...

Tim - Site Editor - from 2015

More Okna Windows Reviews

Simonton 5500 Window Series

My showroom has samples of the Simonton 5500 Series and the HiMark 800, and when you look at the two together the differences are clear. The 5500 is a good, solid window and it will work fine for most homes. The HiMark, though, is in a class by itself. It's truly a premium window, with a good build and great look. Window replacement costs are expensive, so if it was me I'd buy the best I could afford. They'll last longer and give you fewer problems over the years.

Harry - Window Dealer - from 2012

Please note that all Simonton Windows reviews prior to 2015 have been archived.

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Windows Reviews :: 9800 Series

Simonton CV500 vs Milgard Windows

We are considering replacing all our windows and sliding glass doors. We have the original windows in our home that is about 28 years old. We have spoken to two private window contractors and a representative for Home Depot. The private contractors seem to be leading us toward Milgard, one toward the Tuscany and the other toward the Style Line Series. The Home Depot representative is encouraging us to go with the Simonton CV500. Which brand and series would you recommend? Thank you for your help.

Sally - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

I would go with the private contractor and the Milgard. You will pay more for it, but it's a better window and hopefully better installation. The Tuscany should add 10% to the price over the Styleline and is worth it in my opinion. I like the Tuscany, it's well made and while not flashy, it's a decent performer, and has some good features.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2016

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Windows Reviews :: Daylight Max 7300 Series

Hi Tim, I was looking at your Q&A website today. What a fantastic service you are providing to prospective window buyers. We live in San Jose, CA.

My husband and I are in the market for 7 retro windows and an entry door. We have received 2 bids.

Bid 1: 7 Simonton DaylightMax windows.
Installed for $6,790
Masonite door with 2 sidelites and obscure glass.
Installed for $7,400

Bid 2: 7 Anlin DelMar expanded view windows with pull tight cam locks.
Installed for $8,925
ProVia door with 2 sidelites with Wrought iron inset and obscure glass.
Installed for $10,421

Our friends live in Modesto and installed 21 Anlin windows, a sliding glass door, a backyard entry door with a single hung window, and double entry way doors both with decorative glass for $27,000. This was 5 years ago.

We really like the Anlin windows but we think that the pricing is quite high. What do you think? If it is too high, is it appropriate to have another Anlin dealer quote us a price or are they working in territories?

Are you familiar with entry way doors? What do you think of the pricing we have received?

We have to make a decision next week because the installation time on the windows is about two months out. It’s even longer for the doors.

Sincerely.

Frances - Homeowner - from 2020

[Website Editor Reply]

Frances, the pricing seems high on that Anlin quote. To be sure, the Anlin is the better product over the Simonton Daylight. Still, I think the Simonton/Masonite is probably the better value in this picture. Anlin and ProVia is a great combo, but $5K plus for those doors is pricey.

If there is another Anlin dealer who will bid out your project, then absolutely get their bid. I think you need another Simonton bid, as well as maybe a Milgard dealer bid.

I think a few more bids will show you whether the bids are high because its summer and these guys are busy, or whether the bids are simply overinflated.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2020

We are forced to replace a large window with two awning windows and two plate glass windows. Total width is 196" and height is 62". We live in Florida, on a river, and close to the gulf - obviously a hurricane zone. Can you compare PGT class C window to Simonton class D window, please. This window faces the south, which is on the river. We have estimates that are very similar in price.

Deanna - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

Deanna, PGT in my opinion is the superior window to the Simonton. Now, I will say that the installation quality would push me one way or the other, so if there is a noticeable difference between the two (reviews, reputation, etc.) then this would be my deciding factor.

But all (installation) things being equal, I would have to go with the PGT hurricane windows over Simonton hurricane windows.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

Simonton StormBreaker Windows

I'm looking to purchase a home from a builder in Fl. who has won "Builder of The Year" awards on multiple occasions. I'm a bit concerned because he will be using the MI high impact windows (Storm Armor)if I purchase the home. I cannot find any reviews on these MI windows and was wondering if these are rated any better than the non-impact windows they sell. Thanks for your feedback on these windows.

Don - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

Don, MI does not have a stellar reputation in the industry, but I know lots of builders like them, I'm assuming because they get them at a good price and they figure the windows are "good enough." I don't know much about the Storm Armor series. I'm sure they are better than the standard MI vinyl windows, but that isn't a recommendation by any means.

I would ask the builder for two other impact options or brands that he could order. If he does, see if you can compare the performance to the Storm Armor, specifcally the Depsign Pressure Rating, U-factor, Air Infiltration Number and Condensation Resistance Rating.

I would ask if he has access to PGT, Custom Window Systems, Stanek or the Simonton StormBreaker Plus window. Without knowing anything about the Storm Armor, I would think that the options I mentioned would be a better long term solutions than the MI. Each of the companies makes a very solid impact window that will be more expensive than the MI, but isn't going to be exorbitant.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

Please note that all Simonton Windows reviews prior to 2015 have been archived.

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Windows Reviews :: Madeira Series

Simonton Madeira Series vs. Anlin Catalina

The Catalina is a very good window as well. The Simonton Madeira and Daylight are a step below this but still good windows. The Milgard Intrinsic is right on par with the Simonton offerings. Just make sure to find a well reviewed online company to do the work.

Ellen - Homeowner - from 2021

[Site Editor's Answer]

Thank you so much have bid on anlin but is Catalina is Catalina ok. Also working with.another company these not on your list Simonton maderia and daylight max should I push for ones on your list. Or are thes ok also Milgard intrinsic. Same not on your list. Phone bids work or have to come to come to.condo have 3 anlin quotes.

Dane - Site Editor - from 2021

Simonton Madeira vs. Milgard

Hi Dane and/or Tim. I really appreciate your site. It's one of the few places I've found to get some good information on replacement Windows. I've been researching replacement windows for about 6 weeks now and feel no closer to making a decision than before.

Puget Sound/Seattle area home

Need new windows to improve comfort (25 windows)

Quoted $1,400/window for Simonton Madeira

Quoted $1,200/window for Ply Gem 2

Quoted $800/window for Insignia e2 (aka AMI casement window with upgrades)

Quoted $500/window for Revere Berkshire Elite (same AMI casement without upgrades)

Almost decided on Milgard Tuscany windows but had a low quality feeling when testing

Alside has had a bad rap in the past but the Insignia the salesperson brought seemed like a nice hefty window

Not sure what to do now, curious abut Champion but unsure if it's worth the time

The Full Story

My family and I moved into a 1983 two story home last September. After a very drafty winter we are looking for ways to improve comfort in our home. We already have plans to foam insulate under the floor which has many bats of fiberglass insulation falling down and we are going to do some work in the attic. There's no getting around it however, our old aluminum windows, despite being double pain are incredibly chill inducing.

Unfortunately, living in Washington, our choices for quality window companies seem few. I've read many of the blogs and have found the preferred window brands unavailable in our area. For example, Soft-lite, Sunrise and Okna are all unavailable in our area.

We started by having someone come by to give a quote but this guy turned out to be a salesman who tried selling us a Simonton Madiera (which seems like a fine window) for almost $1,400/window.

We quickly learned that this is the norm as we had another come by and offer us Ply Gem 2 windows for nearly $1,200/window. Again, the window seems OK but that price seems crazy.

Most recently we had a rep from Apex come by and he offered an AMI window that comes with a lot of upgrades (they call it Insignia) for about $800/window. This was their promo home rate which I don't really know what I think about that.

I have a quote for the same window sold under the Revere brand. This quote comes from Window Universe which are the same guys that run the blog "The Window Dog." I've found that blog to be a great resource and they seem to know their stuff. But the reviews of Window Universe are not very good. So while they seem knowledgeable it seems they have some kinks to work out with their installers. That quote was the lowest I've seen btw, $490/window.

I know Alside windows don't have the best reputation but the sample that the Apex guy brought over was actually one of the nicer vinyl windows I've gotten to mess with. I had all but decided on Milgard at one point but I tried them out at Home Depot and they seemed really flimsy, very light and the sash wobbled as it went up and down. An installer ball-parked me $600-$800/window for Milgards installed. He was a straight-up installer, no marketing or salespeople.

The other window sold in our area that I've been told is good quality is Champion but I know they only sell through their dealers and I really don't want to go through another 3 hour spiel only to end up with another $30,000 quote.

So now, I have no idea what to do. The window I see get the best reviews that is available in our is Milgard but they were somewhat flimsy feeling, especially compared to the Alside window we tried. Am I missing something about Milgard? Any advice?

Dennis - Homeowner - from 2018

Simonton windows tend to use quite a bit of vinyl in their frames. Is there a reason why you don't do a picture window across the span? Or if you went with a higher end brand like a Sunrise Restorations that uses a thinner frame, you might be able to do an XOX where you have casements on the side and a small picture window in the center.

I think you need to bring more people out and have them toss out ideas for the opening and really explore the options. I tend to think two double hung next to one another is an awkward look. There has got to be something better than that out there.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2018

Simonton Prism Platinum vs Norandex

Can you give me your opinion of the Simonton Prism Platinum versus the Norandex Extreme 8000? I have a choice between the two. Prices are comparable. Seen pro's and con's for both.

Any insight you can lend would be great! Thank you

Jarett - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Answer]

Jarett, the Simonton Prism Platinum is a good vinyl window, better in my opinion than the Norandex. I'm not even sure who actually makes the Norandex, something tells me it's a relabeled window -- maybe an Atrium -- I would stay clear of the Norandex brand if it were me.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2016

Simonton Platinum Prism vs Amerimax Craftsman Portrait

We are looking to replace 16 windows in our house, a combination of double-hungs and sliders. We got a pile of quotes for a variety of windows, and after deciding that we do not need high-end fiberglass windows, we have come down to the two lowest vinyl bids, Simonton Platinum Prism and Amerimax Craftsman Portrait (both double-pane). The Amerimax quote is about $1,400 less than the Simonton.

The Amerimax dealer made a big deal about the windows being made in Colorado (we are located in Denver) and that this ensures that the window will have argon in it, claiming that windows made at lower altitudes lose their argon upon being shipped to Denver b/c of the capillary systems they stick in the windows to ensure safe shipping. We are not sure whether or not give this credence?

The Amerimax quote is also for single-hung windows rather than double-hung. It is true that we often have trouble pushing the upper sash up enough to close our current windows, and to be brutally honest, we never clean the outside of our windows anyway, so perhaps the single-hung is fine. Is there something else we should consider about this?

A further question I have (which I can't seem to find an answer to) is whether one of these windows has narrower frames than the other, as I would like as much glass as possible since I feel our house can be a bit dark.

Of course, I would also like to know if either of these is more durable than the other, or has more issues with manufacture or operation, as I don't ever want to think about my windows again!

To throw a wrench in, the third lowest quote was from Zen Windows, for their Nirvana windows (which I understand are equivalent to Soft-Lite Classics). Their quote was $3,200 higher than the Amerimax, so unless there is a compelling reason to choose them over the Amerimax or the Simonton, we are not considering them. But I wanted to put them in in case there is such a reason.

Thank you for any input!!

Margaret - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

Hi Margaret, you've asked some good questions here. There is concern over windows made at lower elevations and shipped to elevations over 6000 ft. However, the capillary tubes help relieve the differences in pressure that would occur with the elevation change (assuming that the company does it correctly.) There should be a number of companies that manufacture windows in or around Denver though so you should have some options (make sure to ask about the elevation changes and capillary tubes to each of the companies to make sure that they use them and feel comfortable with the process, just to be safe).

If your two main bids are Amerimax and Simonton and the Simonton is more expensive, I'd say the clear winner is the Amerimax. I like this company and their vinyl windows.

I actually like single hung windows for the very reasons you suggest, plus there are less parts and components that can fail over the years. Many contractors automatically assume a single hung is a builder grade window, but many manufacturers have been making quality single hung windows because they offer better performance and still offer the ventilation.

Zen is a good window, and you are right it is the Soft-Lite Classic model. The Nirvana is better than the Craftsman Portrait, but I probably wouldn't pay the extra $3200. I'd go with the Amerimax, which is a good quality mid range vinyl window.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2016

Margaret's Response

Thank you for your reply. I realized after I sent my question that my bid for the Zen Windows included a painted exterior, and the other two quotes did not. Once I eliminate that, the Zen Nirvana window comes in at only $1,000 more than the Amerimax Craftsman Portrait, and about $200 less than the Simonton Platinum Prism.

It sounds like from your answer that the Simonton would be your third choice of these three? I admit that, though all three installers get great reviews on BBB, Angie's List, etc., we like the Simonton installer the best, though that's more of a feeling than anything concrete. Would it be a mistake to choose the Simonton for the installer; are the other windows that much better? Thank you!!!

Margaret - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

Margaret, the installation is very important, I always say 50% windows, 50% installation. The Simonton Platinum Prism is a good vinyl window, I'd probably put it on par with the Amerimax Craftsman Portrait, but I would put the Soft-Lite Classic above these. But by how much, probably not a huge amount. If it were me and these were my options, I'd go with the installer who I felt was going to do the most thorough job, installed quite a few of the window I selected, and gave me the best overall feeling (and obviously had great reviews).

I have to say on the windows alone, I'd probably go with the Zen if it's only $1000 more, but again, the installer would probably be a bigger factor with the selections you have. Let me know how your project goes!

Tim - Site Editor - from 2016

Simonton Prism Platinum vs. Zen Lotus

Looking to replace 11 double hung windows and 1 large double casement and I am trying to chose a decent windows for a mid-range price. Currently have quotes on the Simonton Prism Platinum and the Zen Lotus. For installation I have a highly recommended company for the Simonton and for the Zen I would be using their contractors. I have read numerous pros and cons on both window manufactures. Pricing is slightly lower on the Zen but I am looking for recommendation on the better windows and warranties. I wouldappreciate any suggestions.

Al - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

[Site Editor's Response]

Theresa, good for you for getting 4 bids, that's a good start. Okay, the best of the bunch is the Sunrise, although the Sunrise Essentials are their lower end model and I would stick with their standard frame or any upgraded model from here - Verde, Vanguard, Restorations. Whoever gave you the bid should have access to some if not all of these options, but their standard Sunrise frame is very good. I know nothing about Sun View windows, I did take a look at the Lindsey website, but it didn't provide me with any energy efficiency numbers or specific features on the window so I really can't comment.

Ply Gem makes a number of window series, their builder series is not very good, their Contractor series is okay and the Ply Gem Premium Series is good (probably on par with the Sunrise Standard Series). The Simonton Pro Finish Builder is not very good (they do have a Contractor Model and Master Model in the Pro Finish Series that are both decent, not fantastic, but decent Simonton quality). The Simonton 5500 Reflections series is quite a nice window (see if you can get a bid on the Simonton 9800 Series if they carry it, this is quite nice as well.)

I would take the Sunrise and Simonton 5500 Series quotes and try to get the prices down on each as much as possible (sometimes by telling them that you have several quotes for the same project for $500 less etc. and ask what they can come down to in terms of price.) Good Luck!

Tim - Site Editor - from 2015

Simonton ProFinish Master vs Viwinco Choice Windows

I'm replacing most of my windows with New construction Windows as part of residing mt house (I have access to the flanges). The original 21 year old Capitol Windows are junk. I have a 13 year old addition with Builder's First Source windows that seem ok (they're staying). I tried to match the Builder's First Source windows and ended up with two Certainteed (MI) windows in the garage... they seem ok, but it's hard to tell, since it's a garage.

The contractor has priced Simonton Pro-Finish Master and Viwinco Choice Windows. The Simonton is more expensive and I assume they better... are they? Is the difference significant?

Martin - Homeowner - from 2015

[Site Editor's Response]

Martin, the Simonton ProFinish Master window is a solid vinyl window, better than the ProFinish Builder and with a fewer nice features that don't come standard on the ProFinish Contractor (the ProFinish is available in three levels or options).

Viwinco offers two new construction windows, the S-Series and the Builder's Choice, I'm assuming that your contractor is referring to the latter option. The Simonton option is going to be better then the Viwinco. Simonton is a bigger company and you will have more options if something does go wrong. Sure, you might pay more for the Simonton, but it's a better long term option that I would hop will provide better value over the life of the windows.

As always, make sure they do a thorough job installing the windows. I think you will be happy with Simonton ProFinish Master windows.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2015

Please note that all Simonton Windows reviews prior to 2015 have been archived.

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Windows Reviews :: VantagePointe Series

The Simonton VantagePointe 6000 series is made specifically to be sold through Home Depot. It can be order in a number of options, each of which carries a different number; the 6100, 6300, and 6500 (from simplest to best). The VantagePoint is available as a single hung, double hung, picture, slider, awning, casement and a garden window. Standard features include tilt latches, dual air locks, a beveled sash, a coil balance, and extruded lift rails.

The Simonton VantagePoint is a decent vinyl window (particularly the 6500 series), but certainly not a top tier window. I haven't been able to find any data on the window, but I will post it when I do. As usual, I have issues with some HD installation and I would recommend that consumers who are looking to buy the 6100, 6300, or 6500 window from HD find their own installer to do the work. I would give the Simonton VantagePointe Series Window a 4.4 out of 5 stars rating.

Dane - Site Editor

Simonton 6100 vs 6500

We have 16 window openings and many many choices. What would your call be here?

Anderson 100: $17.7K
Simonton 6500: $16.3K
PGT EnergyVue: $11.2K
Simonton 6100: $13.2K
Window World 4000: $10.8K
Reliabilt 3900: $10.4K
Sierra Pacific Windows 8500: $10K
MI 1650: $9.8K

Brandi - Homeowner - from 2023

[Site Editor's Answer]

Brandi, I like the Sierra Pacific option or the Simonton 6100. The Andersen 100 is a solid choice, but not at that price point. I would certainly consider the PGT Energyvue option as well.

Dane - Site Editor - from 2023

Simonton 6100 Double Hung Windows

I live in NYS and I need some guidance with getting new windows and (2) sliders. I received a quote from Home Depot to replace 9 windows and 2 sliders. They suggested Simonton 6100 double hung windows and Simonton 6500 (3) panel sliders. They quoted me $17,728.00

I’d like to know if these windows are a good choice since I’ve seen a lot of bad reviews on line and it’s making me very nervous. I’m not sure if it’s just customers with bad luck or that the windows are bad quality.

I also received a quote from Power home remodeling who construct their own windows but they quoted me $28,000, which I found to be very high. Do you know if these are good quality windows. Their on line reviews seem to be very good and they have an excellent warranty. Should I negotiate the price? (More about Powerhrg reviews here.)

Debbie - Homeowner - from 2022

[Website Editor Reply]

Debbie, both of the bids at first glance strike me as high. I think you need to collect a few more bids to get a better idea of the fair market price in your area. I haven't heard of Power Home Remodeling, but they sound like a big outfit. The bid they gave you seems excessive.

[Email dane@replacementwindowsreviews.co for his recommendations]

Dane - Website Editor - from 2022

Dan, The Simonton VantagePointe is a specialty window that is sold exclusively at Home Depot. You are correct that is is the 6000 Series, the 6100 is the entry level, 6300 the mid range and the 6500 the premium option. The window has some decent features, including a number of rather interesting interior frame color options. In general, it's a pretty standard vinyl window that is probably equivalent to the Anlin Monte Verde (one of their specialty windows that is more of a budget option). I would say Anlin is a level above Simonton when comparing apples to apples.

The Simonton VantagePointe window, with their Low-E 366 Cardinal Glass, Intercept spacer and krypton fills, you should be looking at around a 0.30 U-factor, 0.15 air infiltration, 0.32 visible transmittance, 3.33 R-value and 0.18 SHGC. While I don't like this AI .15 - the rest of the numbers are decent.

As to HD, they are so big that they get pretty amazing prices, local distributors can rarely come close. They can't compete though on service and I really don't like their installation, which they subcontract out. If you like the price point and options being offered on the VantagePointe in store, go for it. But I would suggest finding a window installer elsewhere - the last thing you want I shoddy installation - it will cost you more in the long run. Good luck!

Tim - Site Editor - from 2015

Simonton Home Depot Reviews

Hi Dane, we just had a representative from Home Depot discuss with us 3 replacement windows. (We live in Suffolk county, Long Island, N.Y. in a 40 unit Condo community - all windows must look the same!)

The windows we are considering for installation are the 6500E Vantage Pointe Windows - double hung. I would like to know how you regard the quality of these windows. We need windows that will reflect the high summer heat but retain the warmth of the house during the winter months. The windows face west - lots of high afternoon heat in summer. Would you recommend an alternative to these windows which would better fulfill our needs. (We have a deadline for savings and must decide by this coming Wednesday.) Thank you so much for your assistance.

Carol - Consumer - from 2015

[Site Editor's Response]

Simonton Innovo vs. Sunrise Sliding Doors

Tim, I am trying to decide between the Sunrise sliding door and the Simonton Inovo sliding door. Both seem to be well constructed and similar in features. Price wise the Simonton is coming in at a lower cost by about $1000.

Any opinion on which might be the better option to go with?

Greg - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Greg, Sunrise makes a very good sliding door and Simonton makes a good sliding door. Assuming you like the overall look of the Simonton series, I would save the $1000 and go with that one. The Sunrise is going to be a bit better, but honestly not $1K better.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

Simonton Innovo vs ProCraft

I've gotten two bids for my window replacement in the Seattle area (vinyl double pane replacing single-pane aluminum frame) and the numbers are very far apart. I'm getting funny feelings about the use of "house label" from both companies - I'm assuming they use private model numbers exactly to prevent comparisons. One company quoted their ProCraft Pro-8000 series ( http://www.procraftwindows.com/proseries-8000-vinyl-windows.cfm). They state that these are made by CDI in Tacoma (Comfort Design Windows?), but it isn't clear about which model. Have you heard of CDI?

They don't exist in the manufacturer list you have. And their model names don't translate directly. The other company did the same thing - They quoted their "Innova Pro Series" (http://clearnrg.com/products/) which are stated as made by Simonton with some upgrades and such, but aren't clear about which line's frame is used as the base. By reading your site, I know Simonton can be all over the map in terms of cost, quality and value. As an example of one window in the bid, a 72x42 slider from ProCraft (CDI) was quoted at 932 installed, while the Innovo (Simonton) was quoted at 1596 installed. Even with installation cost of 150 on the window, both seem a little high. And unless its apples and oranges in terms of quality, the latter seems REALLY high. Any thoughts? Definitely time for a third quote, methinks.

Chris - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Answer]

Chris, if the installation cost is $150, which seems perfectly reasonable to me, the window cost is REALLY high, especially for ProCraft (never heard of them) and Simonton. Think about it this way, you can go to Home Depot and order an Andersen 100 series (a composite frame that is certainly as good as most Simonton windows) and order that for somewhere in the neighborhood of $450 in that size…this is a guess of course (it might actually be worth your while just to see).

HD always offers really low cost on the windows, but their installation is very hit or miss. Assuming you were to hire someone off of yelp who gets excellent window installation reviews and they charge $150, you'd be looking at $600 fully installed. Now if you found another company who sold the product and did the installation, you might be in the $650 to $750 range, but unless there is something I'm missing, the product cost is high.

Try to find a Milgard dealer and get a bid on the Tuscany model, there must be a bunch up there. Amerimax might be available up there as well. Bottom line is I'd keep looking because that price seems high to me…if the other bids come in at that same range then at least you'll know that something is driving up that cost. Might be worth a call to the HD windows department and see if they can quote you a price on a window with those measurements.

Thanks a bunch for your insight. It confirms my feeling that these prices are either high for what we get or that they are positioning themselves at the high-end and feel that they can justify it with their customizations to these models. I'll keep looking and try to get another couple quotes from window places and home depot too. Love your site - most folks buy windows once or twice in their life, so everybody is a rookie and this sort of info is needed.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

Anna, I have never heard of American Window Systems out of Texas. I took a look at their website, they have a lot of models so it was unclear which window you were talking about. In general, you get what you pay for in the window industry (but not always) and I have to imagine that true of this very regional vinyl window manufacturer (who I've never heard of and who isn't listed on the nrfc.org website as far as I can tell).

The Simonton Generations Windows are I believe the Reflections 5500 window (or very very close), which is one of their better models. I think the name is simply a marketing deal -- just to make it more confusing!

If it were me, I would forget the AWS and instead get a couple more bids from local companies who carry the Milgard Tuscany and the Don Young mid range vinyl window. This should be comparing apples-to-apples and will give you a better product sampling to compare.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Window Reviews :: Bay And Bow

Simonton makes good bay and bow windows. Like most manufacturers, they purchase the bay box from another company and then add their own windows into the premade bay or bow. This isn't always the case, especially with bow windows, which might be made on site of a project. Therefore, a "Simonton Bay Window" doesn't tell you what you need to know -- you want to know what series you are buying from Simonton. I would give the Simonton Bay And Bow Series Window a 3.8 out of 5 stars rating.

Dane - Site Editor

Simonton Bay Windows

I was considering getting an argon Simonton bay. What's your opinion on these?

Silvia - Homeowner - from 2023

[Site Editor's Answer]

Hey there -- simonton makes a good window in their Impressions series and their Reflections 5500 series. Simonton bay windows are solid -- most companies send their "bay window" orders to one of three companies who make the bay box and then the company simply places their windows into the openings and voila, a bay window. Installation is key when it comes to bay windows as these are complex installs and there are plenty of places to screw them up. I would definitely suggest getting multiple bids as bay window price quotes can vary widely (just like with any more complex install). If you'd like a list of additional brands and options, I'm happy to send something your way --

Dane - Site Editor - from 2023

Simonton Bow Windows vs. United

Hi Tim, my contractor quoted 3 prices for replacing my bow window for United (2 options - $3,794 & $4,089) and Simonton ($4,658). Is Simonton a better option than United? If I want to price a higher quality "brand" than Simonton, what manufacturers would you recommend?

My home is 60 yr old split level and my wife & I plan to stay in the house maybe 5-10 more years. What level of quality do you recommend that we invest in for this project?

Jim - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Jim, Simonton is absolutely the better window compared with United windows. I would definitely recommend going with the Simonton option, even if you aren't in your forever home. It's not like Simonton is the most expensive window out there, it's more in that mid range and is appropriate for your timeline. Both companies probably buy the actual bow/bay window box from the few companies that specialize in making them so there will be very little difference there.

I would still go back to the Simonton dealer and tell him you have another bid for $4,000 and say if he can get close to that price, you are ready and willing to sign right then...see what he says.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Windows Reviews :: Evolution Series

Simonton Evolution Window Information

Thanks for all of the great info you provide on your site! We are getting bids on various replacement window options, and one highly recommended company quoted us on the Simonton Evolution window. I cannot find any information on what that is comparable to (is it the same as the 5500? Is it something else entirely?). Do you have any idea what that model might actually refer to? Thanks again!

Kim - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Kim, model or serial numbers can be found on the frame or in the sash. You may want to take a picture of any label with your phone, drive down to Home Depot, and ask the guys to take a look at the pictures and tell you definitively for the model number. They carry Simonton and will know exactly what to look for.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2018

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Windows Reviews :: 2300 Series

Simonton Window Series 2300 Glider

I have a Simonton window series 2300 glider that has a crack on the inside pane and I’d like to replace the portion of the window that does not move. My HOA is hard to deal with and require all external portions of the condo to match. Can you give me any guidance?

Thanks.

Nancy - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Your best bet is probably to find a local window repair service using yelp or cragislist. they will usually provide you with an estimate over the phone and then they come out and repair the glass. simonton doesn't provide an accidental glass breakage policy in their warranty that i know of.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

Hi Kathy, well Harvey vinyl windows are good, although the common comment is that they charge a bit more for a pretty midrange vinyl window.

Simonton is certainly a well-known manufacturer and their mid range to premium products are very solid. So in regards to them, I would make sure that you know what window series you are purchasing.

Ideal is a smaller manufacturer, which is always a bit more of a gamble since there's a better chance that they're out of business in 20 years as opposed to a big company like Simonton.

One way to really compare the actual windows is to look at the performance numbers of each one and see how they compare there. In particular, ask for U-factor, SHGC, air infiltration and the visible transmittance or VT. The contractors should have these numbers, although you can also check nfrc.com - the site can be a bit cumbersome to navigate though.

The other issue, of course, is the installation portion of the project. The installation of the window is just as important as the window itself. So make sure that you feel comfortable with whoever is installing the windows. I like the installers who seen real picky about their work, who seem like they fret over every tiny detail. These are the guys you know are going to do the job completely and thoroughly and not cut any corners.

If it were me, I would say Simonton then Harvey than Ideal.

Dane - Site Editor - from 2015

Best Simonton Windows

Dear Dane, we are in the process of replacing windows and have gotten a quote from an installer for MI Energy Core windows. However, after doing some research online, it appears that MI windows are a lower quality window and have gotten some bad reviews (as well as a class action lawsuit).

We are looking for a good quality mid-range window. We basically need 8 23"W x 59"H double-hung windows and 10 23"W x 59"H single hung windows. Looking at your website, Simonton appears to be a good brand. However the series names that are listed on the website do not match up with the collection names on the Simonton website. I'm assuming they just came out with new names? Can you recommend which Simonton collections are the better quality ones and which to stay away from? Is there another brand that you recommend over Simonton?

We live in the mountains outside of Albuquerque, NM. Our house is pretty shaded, but we do get quite a bit of sun, as well as 19" on average of rain and 59" of snow (not sure if any of this matters). Also, do you recommend vinyl over aluminum (or fiberglass)? Thank you very much for your time,

Melissa - Homeowner - from 2015

[Site Editor's Response]

Melissa, I would have to agree to the MI is not typically on many contractors top 10 list. The Energy Core is not bad though, although I haven't seen numbers on it. In terms of good mid range vinyl windows on the west, I would say look at Milgard, Amerimax and Anlin. Milgard will be available for sure, Amerimax possibly and I don't know whether Anlin has reps in your area.

I would say stick with vinyl, although fiberglass is certainly an option. Aluminum is really only something you should consider if you are in very hot climates, which Albuqueque is not based on the fact that you get that much snow. Fiberglass options should include Marvin Infinity, Inline, and Milgard Ultra.

Simonton is a good brand, probably not as good as the ones I mentioned, although it all depends on which model you select. I like their 9800 Impressions, and their Reflections 5300 and 5500 series.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2015

Top Of Page ˆ

Related Topics: Quaker Windows Reviews

Apex Windows Reviews

Who We Are

Guide To The Process

Top Rated Windows

Negotiate A Window Bid

Private Policy