Home : Window Replacement Reviews : Ideal
Ideal Windows And Doors
Ideal Window Cost: $$$
(3 out of 5)
(Amongst All Vinyl Windows)
Ideal Windows And Doors
The company manufacturers four main series, including the Perfect Fit, Professional, Platinum 3000, and Majestic window series. Previously, the company had listed their windows as the UltraTite and DuraWeld. These have now been replaced by the Perfect Fit and The Professional. Neither the Majestic nor the Platinum 3000 series are even listed on their website. Ironically, I get lots more inquiries into these two series than the Perfect Fit or Professional. I was told that this is because the Majestic nor the Platinum 300 are "specialty" dealer series, but that explanation made (makes) very little sense to me.
Ideal Windows Warranty
The Ideal window warranty is decent I would say for the industry. The vinyl window frame, sash, and all moving parts are warranted for the lifetime of the original homeowner. Specifically that they are free from manufacturing defects in material and workmanship. The insulated glass unit is warranted for 20 years from the date of purchase. The aluminum screen frame is warranted for life (not the screen itself though).
The warranty is transferable to one additional owner (however you must fill out a Certificate of Transfer within 30 days of title transfer and pay $50. The new owner is then covered for 10 years from the install date).
Quick Links
Platinum 3000 Series
4000 Series
5000 Series
Majestic Series
Perfect Fit Series
Ultra-Tite Series
DuraWeld Series
Professional Series
Get Our Recommended Window List
Also please consider filling out the free form on our site for 3 quality window price quotes — it’s how we afford to provide free consumer information. We’re not incentivized by ANY company and will help you with ANY questions you might have, and help you navigate ANY bids you receive. That’s our guarantee to you!
Ideal Platinum 3000 Reviews
The Platinum 3000 is the company's drop down window from their premium Majestic series. However, these two windows are pretty darn close in terms of performance and construction. It uses the same frame as the Majestic and has the same reinforcements at the meeting rails as the Majestic. The only difference is a molded, sculpted lift rail instead of the double walled lift rail. The Platinum 3000 comes standard with double strength glass, ESM+ glass package and the UltraView Screen. Performance wise, the Ideal Platinum 3000 achieves a .23 U-factor and .02 air infiltration. I would give the Ideal Platinum 3000 Window a out of 5 stars rating.
Back in May I had a couple of Ideal 3000 Platinum casements installed. Everything looked and felt great. Now that the colder weather has started creeping in, I started to notice cold around the frame area. The room is colder than the windows they replaced. As I investigated, there seems to be too much air infiltration going on. I'm no expert, but it feels like they didn't do enough to prep the cavity where the window goes into.
Who did the work? Have you sent them pictures and asked them to come back out?
The company's name is Statwood Home Improvements. They are in Staten Island New York. I have not spoken to them yet because the weather is still mild and I want them to come out when it's cold enough. There are no pictures to send because there is no visible damage. I just wanted to know if companies typically guarantee their installation in case you are getting drafts or the windows are letting in cold air?
Most companies guarantee the labor for at least one year. Many up to three years, but once the windows go in and there are no issues, it typically stays this way for the next 15 years plus. It should be in the work order details. Check this and then get in touch with Statwood Home Improvements and see what they say. At least have it on their radar - but they should button up their work now rather than later.
Hello. We are in the process of replacing our original storm windows with vinyl windows. A very reputable local window company is recommending Ideal Windows Platinum 3000 triple pane, and gave us a great price point. I was wondering what your opinion of this window is. We are in central Pennsylvania. Thanks so much for your insight.
Dawn, thanks for the soft-ball question :) so much easier than most of the questions I get. The Ideal Windows Platinum 3000 triple pane is a truly excellent window. You've got a great price point and the installation company has a great reputation. That's the trifecta you are looking for!
Came across your website and I would first like to say how impressed I am with your combined knowledge and your great ideal windows reviews! Truly hoping that you guys can help me... I'm looking for estimating pricing on Ideal platinum "new construction" Black exterior/white interior with install. I have attached my window schedule - any info is extremely appreciated! :-) Would love to pick your brain. If you have any time. Thank you and look forward to hearing from you guys!!
Wendy, I would say the Ideal Platinum new construction window and install for a medium sized window would be $700 to $850. COVID demand is the outlier though so that price could be higher, but the range I quoted is the "fair range" in my opinion.
Hello Dane, I emailed with you a couple months ago for advice on windows (below email). We ended up going with Eastern Shore Window and Door for the Ideal Platinum 3000. I ended up calling Ideal to get names of companies near me that that sold their windows and this was one of 2 names they gave me. Eastern Shore sold this window and the Homegard (HGI), which they said ran $50-$60 more per window that the Ideal.
Shirley, sorry for the late reply. I'm not as good on the door front, but I would say this...I'm not a huge fan of Viwinco. So if your were happy with the Eastern Shores and they carry the Ideal, which I consider a very good window, then I'm assuming their doors are the same quality. (But I can't vouch for them as I don't know them personally.) The cost is much lower on the Homegard Conservision 100 from a company you have used in the past and you trust. This would be where my attention would be first and foremost.
Hello Tim, Dane, I find your site informative and helpful - checked out the Ideal Windows Reviews, which were also helpful. I am in the process of replacing 38 windows that consist mostly of double-hungs, although a few are picture windows and case windows. All the quotes are very similar in range, and all the window installers have good ratings, so my questions are really around the following:
Steve, many installers use low expanding foam, some do not. I don't think it's that important as long as they properly seal the window and they feel comfortable with their method(s). I would concentrate on the installers reviews and reputation over their specific approach. Some installers don't feel comfortable with the low expanding foam because if used incorrectly, it can void a warranty. Obviously someone who uses it regularly has no issues and feels comfortable using it.
Dane, Thank you for the list of brands. I am planning on replacing 4 windows, 1 2-pane sliding door and 1 3-pane sliding door for my MD condo, which has the original aluminum windows and doors from 1989. I got various bids. All companies have good ratings, either in BBB and Checkbook or both. There are such a difference in $$ between Co 1 and others.
Gladys, the Platinum 3000 window quote looks excellent. $390 a window for that quality of a window is impossible to beat.
Hi I found your website super helpful! We are planning on replacing all of our windows in our home which currently has original windows from the 80s. We have gotten a few quotes and are between two companies that both have good reputations. The bids are for 23 windows in NJ that include 2 basement windows and 1 picture window, the other 20 are double hung vinyl windows with the colonial grids.
Hi Christina, so for me the Ideal Platinum series and the Okna 500 are very close in quality and craftsmanship. As is so often the case, the Ideal is often priced out much better. This is the bid I would go with...assuming the reputation and reviews of the Ideal company are solid.
Hi Dane, I live in central New Jersey and am looking to replace the windows in my 35ish year old home. I'm starting with the twin double hungs in my bedroom to be replaced with a set of sliders with a fixed glass panel underneath.
Lyn, this actually sounds like a very fair price to me for an Okna 600 of that size and configuration. This would be my suggestion: call up your local Ideal Windows dealer and get a bid from them on either the Platinum 3000 series or Majestic series (their top end series, which are very close to one another, usually a dealer carries one or the other). These windows are comparable to the Okna and often times are less expensive.
Dane, I was told that the "Ideal Majestic is the same price as the Platinum 3000 with similar in performance – but the Platinum 3000 is asthetically more appealing." I was quoted $9,030 for 23 windows.
Grayson, So both the Ideal Majestic and Platinum 3000 are very close to one another and both excellent windows. That price is amazing! Almost suspicious, that's how good it is. Perhaps attributable to the current situation going on with the covid (pure conjecture on my part).
Dane, why are Andersen replacement windows so expensive, yet they give you a huge discount if you decide the same day they come, but still cost about 1k per window? If you lived in NJ what brand would you buy for your home; if you wanted high quality energy efficient windows?
Craig, I assume that Renewal By Andersen prices their products the way they do and markets their windows the way they do in order to maximize profits. I personally don't feel their windows warrant the prices they charge, not even close. Of course, they are free to charge whatever the market will bear.
I’m shopping for replacement vinyl windows in the Northern Virginia area. I am considering the Ideal Platinum 3000 series. The NFRC rating for the window is U 0.22, SHGC 0.20, and VLT 0.44. I’m also considering the Okna 500. I should get specific NFRC ratings for the Okna tomorrow when the installer visits to provide a quote. I believe they are in the range U 0.28, SHGC 0.30, and VLT 0.55.
Rob, I honestly don't think you would notice the difference between a 45 and 55 VLT, but you probably would if you held up the glass side-by-side. If VLT is the key aspect for you, talk to the Okna rep and see if you can get a clear glass on the 500. Any low-e glass contains a number of coatings that blocks the amount of light and heat that passes through the glass. Clear glass will provide you with the most natural light -- you obviously will sacrifice on the U-factor but if that's not an issue then that's where I'd start.
Do you have any information about these windows? We are considering them as they are a great price from a very reputable contractor with excellent reviews. We also like the Fortis Vytex, but they are $1700 more. Also like the Okna, but they are a lot more expensive, 3700 more. The Ideal Windows have good performance ratings, i.e. U factor, etc. but I've read they are a step below Okna. Not sure about Vytex. What qualities should I be looking for in a vinyl window? Thanks for your help.
Mo, the Ideal Platinum 3000 delivers some pretty impressive numbers, although Ideal as a whole gets some mixed reviews from contractors and industry experts. Their premium 3000 model seems very solid to me.
Hello, I have 2 Ideal 4000 model windows (installed in 2006) that need to be replaced. One is 32x 25, the other is 15x25. I only need half of the double hung window , not the entire window. Both damaged by falling tree. What is the model today that is compatible replacement? Thank you for your assistance.
Dan, I would call them up directly at 1.800.631.3400 and see if you can locate the nearest dealer. Or just ask them directly. They are a small enough operation that you should get an answer. I also get confused on what their current models were way back when. At some point I knew, but I hate to give conjecture and send you down the wrong path.
I am thinking about Ideal 4500 Series windows for my house in New Jersey. I 22 windows to replace. It's a lot of money and I want to get decent windows but I also need a good price.
Ideal makes a budget window. You could probably do worse, but Simonton makes a 5050 that is around the same price. Also, take a look at the Softlite Imperial Pro or Classic. Even the Soft-Lite Bainbridge (their entry level window) is better than Ideal if your budget is really tight. But Ideal just isn't what you want to live with.
Ideal is like American Jewel, good enough for an emergency or rental property but not something you really want on your house. You'll pay a little more for an Okna or Gorell, but you won't have to replace them in five years.
Read more on Gorell windows reviews.
I'm looking for info on the SoftLite Bainbridge and Ideal 5000 Series. Any input?
I don't know a lot about the Ideals (although I read your Ideal Windows Reviews page) - it isn't something I see much. The Bainbridge is pretty solid, they have good numbers and SoftLite stands behind everything they make.
I live in east Penn. and want replacement vinyl windows. The Ideal 5000s were quoted at $400 per and the Gorell 5100 window was $572. Ideal had a 20 year warranty, Gorells 50. I had Ideals once before and they were junk, but I've been told they are pretty good now. Is that true?
I'd go with Gorell. They are a better company and better product, but also higher priced. Worth it in my opinion. You'll get a better window, better materials, better engineering, better warranty, better service. If you aren't totally confident, then consider some other manufacturers. There are tons of them, and if you aren't thrilled with one then it's pretty easier to find another you like more.
The Majestic series is the company's premium vinyl window and has a .02 air infiltration rating and a .23 u-factor. These are impressive performance numbers that rival some of the very best vinyl windows out there. (I consider the Majestic included in this list.) The Majestic has a more durable frame and sill wall compared to the Platinum 3000 series.
Ideal Majestic vs. Provia Endure vs Harvey Tribute. Costs being relatively equal, what's your preference? Could you put a rating (1-10) on these? Thanks.
Dave, here's my quick take on these three windows. Ideal Majestic: 10. Then the Provia Endure: 9. Lastly, the Harvey Tribute: 8.
Hi Dane! Came across your youtube video on top windows for 2024 and have been looking at your very insightful ideal windows reviews on replacementwindowsreviews.co. Wanted your opinion on these 2 quotes for replacing windows in central nj
Diego, the Ideal Majestic is VERY good. It’s not as good as the Okna 800, but I would be very tempted to stick with the Ideal — assuming that the installation company received good reviews. The price and window are both very solid…now it’s just time to make sure that the install piece to this works!
I live in New Jersey and feel pretty confident about going with a Soft-Lite Classic Plus series that I got some very good pricing on from what I can tell. Is there anything else I should take a look at before pulling the trigger?
One more suggestion if you want to get a final bid. The Ideal Majestic is on par with the Restorations series, but is often sold at a much lower price point. Might be worth a bid from an Ideal Windows rep - just to see...
Hi, wanted to let you know I got to see the Sunrise Vanguard, they didn't have Sunrise Restoration, but told it's the same. We didn't like the look of it, but the width is the same as majestic which is 3 inches wide combined sash and frame. I have one last question, the company with okna 600 is willing to try and match the price and I'm confused now what should I choose if the price is not a factor: Okna 600, softlite imperial or ideal majestic? Both companies are highly rated, the only difference is the okna company has a lifetime warranty on labor and the other one is 10 years labor warranty.
Sally, go with the Okna 600 and the lifetime labor warranty!
Dane, thanks for replying so quickly, what do you think about Ideal majestic, I got quote for 10 dh windows with energy green package - $610 for each window plus $4k for provia endure slide door. So total it's $10100 for the whole project. This window has narrow frame compared to Soft-lite Elite and the price is $1500 less. But I can't find a lot of reviews on these. What is your opinion in terms if cost value comparing to other quotes I have?
George, the Ideal Majestic is an excellent window, one of my top 20 vinyl series. That is a great price too -- I would think you would be hard pressed to get another company to match that.
Hi Dane and thanks for the great website. It's a great service in the "one size does not fit all" world of window replacement! I live in NW Washington DC - brick duplex townhouse- built in 1975 - original 12 wood clads showing lots of wear...Looking for a reasonable quote. Things that matter to me after energy efficient priorities, include:
Denese, you have two great options here. Ask the Zen dealer about all of their glass packages -- maybe a simple low-e option -- clear glass lets in lots of heat so maybe there is a middle ground here.
Which of these windows would be the quietest? What should the price point be on the Okna 600 vs Ideal Majestic? What makes Okna 800 better then the 600?
Dale, they are all probably going to be very close in terms of noise reducing -- the differences would be negligible -- jumping up to a true soundproof window however would make quite a bit of difference, but you will pay for the privilege to be sure. Buying a cheap vinyl window would be noticeable as well when compared to these really high end vinyl windows.
Hi Dane, thank you so much for your website. It is the best source of information about replacement windows that I have been able to find. I'm looking to replace 26 windows, and a sliding door, in the DC area, and I would be very grateful for your thoughts. These are the estimates I have received:
Josh, the Ideal quote is awesome compared to the others. Your grouping of quotes is awesome as well! Is the Ideal quote sounds too good to be true -- the Majestic and Platinum 3000 window is excellent and it sounds like the installer is really good as well. I say go for it and consider yourself a smart shopper!
First, love your website, has been super helpful. Second, although I found a lot of great info, we are struggling to make a decision. We have met with three highly rated companies in our area (Md) and are getting estimates now. All the estimate visits were great, two with the owners of the companies.
Christine, I would rank them as Ideal Majestic, Okna 500, and Zen Nirvana. The first two are truly top tier windows, while the Zen Nirvana is a high end mid range vinyl window. I find the Ideal Majestic is often priced out very competitively because they aren't a well known name in the industry. I would lean toward the Ideal Majestic myself. That .01 air infiltration is unbeatable...only the Okna 800 equals it...
Is the Majestic better than the Polaris UtraWeld or the other way around?
Jason, the Ideal Majestic, Polaris UtraWeld, Okna 800, Soft Lite Imperial LS and Sunrise Restorations are all top tier vinyl windows. All very high quality.
Hi. What do you think of this manufacturer. Ideal Majestic. Never heard of them
Patricia, the Ideal Majestic is a great window that is better in quality than the ProVia Aspect or the Window Nation Grandview. That's a very good price that Ideal is offering for 11 windows and a slider. All of the spacers you mentioned are good. Industry standards. I'm not privy to each state's code, but the installers ought to know since they install in your state every day.
Thank you for the response. I noticed some specifics did not transfer in my email for Majesty. Please expand a little on WHY you feel it is better. Can you be more specific.
Patricia, the Ideal Majestic series has better fit, tolerances, and components than the Grandview. It has a .23 u-factor and .02 air infiltration rating -- impressive numbers that rival other top tier vinyl windows. A top tier window that often sells for a mid range window.
Hi Tim, I am looking for new windows for my home and found your website, read your Ideal windows reviews and was hoping to get your thoughts. The last time I shopped for windows, I got 5 quotes but quickly narrowed it down to two great local companies. For that project, a home I knew I'd move out of within 5 years, I just selected the lower bidder.
Justin, both of these windows are excellent. I would put them on par with one another. I would actually rate the Majestic a smidge higher than the Okna 500. Both windows are excellent on workmanship, fit, tolerances, energy efficiency, and overall look. If this were my project and I liked the Ideal dealer and the look of the Majestic, then this is the option I would pick. I'd take the $1200 and spend it on some other part of my home. :)
Hi Tim, thank you for the help and feedback. Like I said, two great companies so I'm sorry I can't work with them both. An outside opinion with familiarity with the windows is really helpful, especially since I can't even see the windows in person right now given the COVID situation. I hope you are staying safe, and thanks again.
Tim, I live in Northern Va and I have quotes on some windows that I would like your thoughts on – FYI -- Great web site, thank you so much:
Jeff, the Vytex Fortis and Ideal Majestic bid at $17,200 are the best values of the bunch. Both of these windows are excellent. I would rate each fo these windows comparable to the Okna 500 model. The Kensington Kingston is a decent window, but I definitely think spending the extra $2200 for an excellent window makes sense from the perspective of long term value.
One of my quotes was for Majestic Signature (I think parent company is Ideal). Are you familiar with them or how they compare to Anderson 200 or Simenton? I was quoted about $650 installed.
Evan, the Ideal Majestic Signature series is a very good vinyl window with an .02 air infiltration, a well made frame, good overall construction, fit and tolerances. It is quite a different window from the Andersen 200, which is a wood clad window.
Hi, thanks for your ideal windows reviews and could i ask what in your opinion is a better window? Ideal Majestic Energy Elite double hung or Provia Comfort Tech DLA? I have estimates of $4671 for Majestic and $5500 for Provia for 9 windows.
Anna, Provia Comfort Tech DLA is the glass system, but not the actual model window you are purchasing from ProVia? However, even if I assume you are purchasing the premium ProVia Endure model, the Ideal Majestic Energy Elite is as good or better a window...and for a better price. Both ProVia and Ideal make good premium windows. The Ideal Majestic is an excellent window and that is a really good competitive price!
Hey Tim, thanks. One hopefully last question this go around. I really appreciate your feedback. The Softlite dealer I went to see is pushing me to an Ideal made window that’s made for him and called the Majestic - it’s an Ideal window. Oknas look better to me. Pricing is within $1000 for the 14 Windows. Okna or Ideal?
Tim, the Ideal Majestic is an excellent vinyl window as well. Personally, I might lean towards the Okna but the Majestic has a .02 air infiltration and is a very quality product.
What are your thoughts about Sunrise Essentials and Restorations as compared to Soft-Lite Imperial LS or Ideal Majestic.
Gene, the Sunrise Essentials is the company's entry level window and not one that I would recommend. The Sunrise "standard" window and the upgraded Restorations however are great windows and I would highly recommend those.
Hi Dane, by any chance are you familiar with an Ideal window Platinum 3000? Apparently, it is an upgrade of the Ideal Majestic. A highly recommended contractor is the distributor/installer. The upgrades are better than the Majestic and his pricing is much better since he does not employ sales people.
Gene, I wasn't familiar with them, but I just took a look at the features and the performance and I have to say I'm impressed. Particularly with the .02 air infiltration and the .22 U-factor, although it was unclear whether this was with the triple or double paned glass. Just out of curiousity, what was the per window cost on these fully installed
I went to see the Ideal Platinum 3000 window at the actual showroom and was impressed. The installer helped design this 3000 series based on the good results from the Plantinum and Majestic series. It is exclusive for them and they started using them in Jan of 2016. What are your thoughts? This probably similar to Thompson Creek who bought a manufacturer for their windows they install. The difference would be price and that Ideal lifetime warranty from a firm that has been around since the 20's.
Gene, the Sunrise Restorations is one of the best vinyl windows around, but I'm not sure it's worth $2700 more than the Ideal Platinum 3000 with its .22 U-factor and a .02 air infiltration. Assuming you like the look of the Ideal and feel confident that the installers will do a good job based on past reviews and ratings, then I think the Ideal is probably your best bet. Let me know how the install goes!
The final window price for the Ideal Platinum 3000 double hung R5 is $6300. This includes a fully tempered window in one bathroom. Final measurements were today. They hope to install in 4 to 6 weeks. They use their own employees. I will let you know how the installation goes. Thanks for all your help.
I've received prices from a single installer for 3 different vinyl windows: Ideal Majestic, Soft-lite Elements, Sunrise Restorations. All of the prices are within $3000 of each other to replace all the windows in the house with Ideal being the cheapest and the Sunrise being the most expensive. Soft-lite seemed like a good middle of the road pricing option, but i don't love that they have the biggest frame, especially since we're coming from historic wood windows. Are the Sunrise windows worth the extra money? We're not sure how much longer we'll be in the house. Could be 4 years could be forever. Appreciate your thoughts.
Caroline, the Soft-Lite Elements and Sunrise Restorations are very close in quality, I might put the Elements above the Restorations by a nose. They are two of the very best vinyl windows out there and a notch above the Ideal Majestic series.
I'm in need of vinyl replacement double hungs & called Thermal Window & Door company (the installers) in broomall, PA. I've use them bf (last July) for a larger patio door & think they're terrific!
Bobbi, while I don't have as much anecdotal information on Ideal as some other companies, the Majestic series has some impressive data -- specifically an air infiltration rating of .02 and u-factor of .23. These are on par with the top tier brands that I often recommend in your state such as Okna and Soft-Lite.
Hi Dane, following your advice, we got a local company that install Ideal Windows. Unfortunately, the Ideal Window they install is Ideal Perfect Fit, not Platinum 3000 or Majestic. This company also installs Sunrise Standard window with Omega 12 glass. So, currently, we have three (3) quotes:
Sue, the best value for your money here is the Okna 500 bid. The Perfect Fit is the drop down model from Ideal and, while a nice window, it can't touch the Okna 500. Neither can the Sunrise Standard and that bid is more expensive. For me, the winner is the Okna 500, without much question.
How do these windows stack up against Pella, Andrson, Marvin, etc in terms of value, quality, longevity and price? I'm ordering 3 large windows for my living room and dining room. I'm getting a final quote on Monday.
Barbara, the Perfect Fit vinyl window is very good. Pella, Andrson, and Marvin all make a number of different windows so it's hard to make a blanket statement. However, pound for pound, Ideal makes a better vinyl window than these much more well known companies do.
Hi Tim, I read your reviews and responses. We received a quote for 7 windows for our NYC apartment, for a replacement of metal frame windows. Is the 4k difference justified between the 2 models, or is the Ideal. Vinyl of sufficient quality in your opinion? Thank you for your response.
Laurent, the Ideal Platinum 3000 vinyl series is the better window over the Pella Impervia. Ideal makes very good vinyl windows at a very fair price point. The Ideal option would be my choice in a New York minute as they say! No question...
Hello. We are looking to replace all the windows in our house. Because of a limited budget we decided to go with Earthwise 4700e. I still have my doubts and wanted to get your professional opinion on the product. We were choosing between Earthwise 4700e and Ideal windows Perfect Fit. Still not sure witch one is better. Thanks
Miroslav, Earthwise is a conglomeration of manufacturers who all use the same parts and equipment, but their website contains precious little data on their products. I did a search for the Earthwise 4700e window and came up with one company that makes it (I'm assuming this is who is selling it). The site however offers no specific information on the parts, components, and features of the window beyond very generic statements such as fusion welded frame corners. I would ask for the air infiltration, design pressure, U-value and condensation resistance numbers on the specific window you are purchasing and compare this to the Ideal Perfect Fit window.
Q: Do you have any idea why Ideal doesn't list either their Majestic or Platinum or Platinum 3000 on their website? They just list the UltraTite and DuraWeld. I can't quite figure out if these are equivalent windows or not.
Good Afternoon, the Platinum and Majestic are "upscale" lines and each has their own website. They do this to avoid confusion with their Perfect, Professional, UltraTite series.
and DuraWeld.
I contacted Ideal and asked abort their STC ratings and this is what they said. "Thank you for contacting Ideal. Ideal's windows are not tested for Sound Tranmission."
Huh, I find that strange that they don't test for STC -- however, the Ideal Ultratite is so much better than the Revere Berkshire Elite window. I'd stick with the Ideal window myself -- it's made well, meaning that it should stop noise fairly well. Here is a thought -- you could either get an upgrade to laminated glass or ask about a glass thickness offset upgrade (not sure whether they do this or not) -- so you order the dual pane glass in two separate thickness, which blocks different noise frequencies from entering.
The resulting quotes are as follows for my 17 windows:
Ben, sorry about the Power Home Remodeling sales pitch -- I've been hearing that about them lately, they didn't used to be that way. (More on Powerhrg reviews.) I completely agree that it is between 3 and 4. I feel like the reviews of Major Homes are a bit better than Simplex.
Wonderful, thanks so much for the reply. If the Ideal UltraTite is excellent, why isn't it on your list? At $11.5k that's $675 per window, which doesn't feel like a "very expensive price point". We're in Queens NYC which I assume is a relatively high cost market.
Ben, I thought the UltraTite was $35K, not $11.5K -- I might have misread your email. Yes, the $675 per window is VERY good -- that's more in line with
what I see from Ideal.
Thanks! I just spoke to the contractor i got the quote from (it's https://simplexmv.com/ FYI) and he said that UltraTite has a larger, sturdier frame than the Majestic. He thinks the Majestic and the Platinum 3000 are the same, but the UltraTite is different (although not massively different). He personally prefers the UltraTite to the Majestic because the larger, studier frame is less likely to warp. "He's been doing UltraTite for 12 years, and I greatly prefer it to their other models". Not sure if this aligns with your experience or not. I'm gonna go to his show room tomorrow to see the windows themselves, as well as visit the Crystal factory (why not?!).
Hey Jon, I checked their site, but the only replacements I found is:
Yes, they are the same. The Ultra-Tite is nearly identical to the Majestic/Platinum 3000. Most dealers sell either the Majestic or Platinum (very similar, nearly identical), but their website lists them differently.
Hello Tim, Checking in with another question please! I see you have reviews of Ideal Windows. A company is offering me a very reasonable price for replacement windows and slider doors. The company is Unified that I mentioned to you several months back. They're based out of Long Island, New York and have been around for a long time it looks like.
Katie, I don't know specifics about the Ultra-Tite II, the numbers look okay, not great. I think Ideal makes a decent window, it isn't top tier, but it's probably fine. I would ask them what the air infiltration number is -- .10 or lower is good. I sort of don't like the idea of the company having a single brand of windows that they sell...that sort of strikes me as odd.
We have 22 windows and 4 storm doors that need to be replaced. We've collected a bunch of quotes and they are all over the place in terms of price and quality. The two that I like the most are Okna 500 windows and ProVia doors. This quote was $17.4K.
Kellen, Ideal makes a good window and the DuraWeld is their premium series. Okna makes a better window, though not by a huge amount. However, I'm guessing you are getting a better quote on the Okna windows than on the Ideal (I can't say this for sure since I don't have the door quote from the second bid, but I'm guessing...)
Hello: I've found you web site to be extremely informative. I am putting in 24 new windows in an old Pennsylvania farmhouse. So, I have a quote from United Windows for their series 4500, and a quote from Ideal for their professional series. Plus, I did not see their professional series mentioned on your site.
Paul, the Ideal Professional is the much better window over the United 4500. The Professional is a very solid performer. As long as you are getting the installation from a professional outfit, you should be well served with the Ideal Professional.
The labor warranty on the Ideal from Windows We Are in Brooklyn, NY is only 3 years so that concerned me. Thermalast windows have a lots of bells and whistles, .21 ufactor, >24 SHG, .02 air infiltration, 3 chambers & sash foam filled, nie looking as well. Only one company called and I told her that I wanted a company that specialized in windows and she said she would call me back but didn't. I never heard from Power or Castle. Castle Windows Reviews. Thanks:)
Suzanna, I wouldn't worry about the labor warranty only being three years. Once the units go in and everything is good to go, it's rare for anything to go wrong in years 1 to 15 -- then stuff starts happening. Ideal is a well made window though so this would be my call.
I live in Flemington, NJ in Hunterdon County. Our single family, contemporary style home is 30 years old and has all casement windows of varying sizes. Several are cloudy due to broken seals and others have faulty cranks. They’re overdue for replacement. I should have the funds to tackle this project next summer in 2021, but want to do my homework ahead of time.
Hi Gus, so Okna is a great option. Ideal windows makes a very good window at a reasonable price and they are based in New Jersey. Other brands to consider include Sunrise, Soft-Lite, Polaris, Zen, Vytex and even Simonton. Feel free to send me your bids when you do receive them and I'm happy to weight in on what sounds like the best value for your buck.
Hi Dane, We finally got our other quotes: Ideal windows R5 for 23 windows and 8' patio door $14,717 (the sales guy got a little too aggressive for my taste) Soft-Lite Imperial LS - we were quote $481 per window, $2300 for the patio door. Let me know if this is reasonable and if you ever heard of Ideal windows. Thank you.
Olga, Ideal windows make a good mid grade vinyl window and the price quote received looks very fair. However, the Soft-Lite Imperial LS is a fantastic window (one of the best windows on the market) and that is a great per window price you received! I would absolutely go with the Soft-Lite quote if it were me. Check out our ideal windows reviews page for more.
Prown's Windows and Doors have been using Ideal Windows since 1945/46. In my 26 years at my 3rd generation family business, Ideal has been a lock solid supplier with a huge emphasis on consistency, quality and fairness. We buy 95% of our Windows and 100% of our patio doors from Ideal Windows and don't have a single hesitancy in the world about having all our eggs in one basket.
Northern Windows is a family owned and operated window installation company serving the Hudson Valley since 1989. Our family has relied on Ideal Windows for our entire window needs over 20 years. We have built our business on three basic principles; quality, value and service. This is why Ideal Windows has been and continues to be the 'Ideal' fit for us. Ideal windows make a quality window for every budget and back it up with a warranty that can actually be counted on.
I had a quote on Soft Lite and the installer quoted me almost 25k for the job the other 5 installers quoted around 19k. Out of range for what I anticipated it would cost. Regrettably it seems these window manufacturers allow only certain vendors the right to sell and this limits who carriers what in the area. I also had quotes on windows from Ideal, Harvey and 2 for OKNA 400 vs 500.
Yes, the journey to finding good replacement windows can be a difficult one, so good on you for sticking with it and doing your homework. I would agree that the Soft-Lite is not worth $6K more than the Okna 500 or 400 series (which I still think is your best bet in terms of windows.) Harvey and Ideal are both pretty good companies as well.
I had my house in NJ outfitted with all new windows 6 years ago. We went with Ideals and they've been great so far. They look good and we haven't had any problems. The price was good, too, a lot lower than some we looked at that had similar numbers and features. Checked out your ideal windows reviews and that helped out.
We're going to be getting new windows for our home soon. Someone recommended the Ideal UltraWeld to replace our double hungs. I can't find a lot of info about these online. I did find something about a Polaris UltraWeld but I'm not sure if it's the same window. It looks nice in person, with a thin profile which I like. As far as price and energy efficiency and all that, it seems to be pretty average. It isn't the best or the worst, not the cheapest of the most expensive. I'd like to get a few opinions before we buy.
The Polaris and the Ideal are not the same thing. Polaris is a very solid choice - Ideal is, at best, a mediocre product. They have a flimsy frame and don't hold up as well as windows that are priced at an even slightly higher price point. Look for a product with a U-factor of under .30 and also look at AI numbers. Ideal is a bargain window, and it just doesn't compare to Okna, Soft Lite, or Sunrise.
Related Topics: Sierra Pacific Windows Reviews
Dane - Site Editor
Ideal Windows Complaints
I haven't contacted the company yet because I am waiting for the cold weather to become more consistent before coming over. Am I covered without additional expenses for them to remove the window and secure a better seal or are they going to try and stick me with more charges on top of the already hefty price I paid? Thanks. Any insight would be greatly appreciated.
Kendra - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
[Kendra's Reply]
The windows themselves from Ideal Platinum 3000 are supposed to be very energy efficient among the best in the industry for vinyl windows. So I'm really surprised that I started feeling this.
[Site Editor's Answer]
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Platinum 3000
Dawn - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Congratulations.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Ideal Platinum Review
Wendy - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Dane - Site Editor - from 2021
3000 Series Cost Bid
The price for 19 windows was $10,355 (including upgrade of full screens. We decided to splurge for something on my wish list--a garden window for the kitchen which brought the price to $12,360. This additional cost for the garden window was much less than any of the other companies we had bids from.
I assume that Majestic is a bit better than the Platinum 3000--in one of your emails to me you listed "good" and "top tier" windows and the Platinum 3000 was actually on both lists but I think maybe it belonged on the "good"? We were just getting weary of getting bids (6!) and felt fine with the Platinum 3000 and the cost.
Now we are looking for 2 sliding doors for our condo in Ocean City, MD. I didn't know if you evaluated these but thought I'd run my bids if you don't mind.
Eastern Shore: Homegard Conservision 100, $5,590; with internal blinds $7,790 (they prefer the Homegard slider over Ideal's)
Go Glass: VIWINCO 6068 S-SERIES, $9,930.52; with internal blinds $12,530.52
Shore Windows and Door: Viwinco S-series, $6876.38; with internal blinds $9,618.79
Do you have any thoughts?
Thanks very much!
Shirely - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
The Majestic and Platinum 3000 are very close in quality, they are both really on the top tier list, but I split them up so that they showed on both lists...
Dane - Site Editor - from 2021
Ideal Windows vs. Vytex
How important is using low expanding foam when installing the windows? I ask because the installers have different approaches in window installation: One of the installers do not use expanding foam as they state they use padding around the window is good enough. One of the installers does use foam, and the 3rd installer does not use it, but can, if I think it’s important, which might come at an additional cost. My research seems to indicate that I should find a window installer that uses low-expanding foam.
The answer to above question informs the next question because each installer works with very specific window manufacturers. But my question is around the following:
Feature for feature, which is the better vinyl window between Ideal Platinum 3000, Vytex Potomac and the Simonton 5500, aside from the performance specs: Are each criteria equally important, or is U-factor more important than SHGC, for example?
I heard that Simonton 5500 and the Vytex Potomac have less glass than the Ideal Platinum, i.e., more vinyl. Is that important?
What I’m trying to determine is this: I prefer one installer because he has the highest ratings, but they only use Simonton 5500 windows, which I understand is the least best of the three above. I think I like the Ideal Platinum 3000 windows (pending your input), but they do NOT use expanding foam. Thank you for your input.
Steve - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Performance wise, the Ideal Platinum 3000 achieves a .23 U-factor and .02 air infiltration. The Vytex Potomac-HP window has an air infiltration at .03. The 5500 as you stated is around .17, although their double hung is around .09.
I like the Ideal Platinum 3000, then the Vytex Potomac-hc and then the Simonton 5500. All good windows, but I'd go with the Ideal myself -- all things being equal.
The more glass, the better viewing, but typically the less energy efficient. It's one of those trade offs that you just can't get around. In Europe, their vinyl extrusions are super thick -- great efficiency, but a much reduced glass/viewing area.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2021
Platinum 3000 Series Bid
Co. 1 - family owned business since the ~1980s
Platinum 3000 Series, $390/window U .22, SHGC .20, VT .44 , Air .02 Or Energy Green package U.28, SHGC .28, VT .50, Air .02
PH Tech Sliding Door 60 x 80, $1350 U.29, SHGC .27, VT .51, Air .12
PH Tech Sliding Door 108 x 80 $2390
Total: $5300
Company has very good ratings from 334 customers in CheckBook (7 pages of reviews, very few negative). 4 positive comments posted on BBB (member since 1995), 1 BBB complaint in last 3 years. Checked with MD Licensing Dept and 4 closed complaints and no disciplinary actions.
PH is a Canada firm; they develop PVC window and patio door systems and are assembled by independent manufacturers that have accepted to follow its buildings methods.
This company provided a 4-page spreadsheet with customer names, addresses, and type of purchase (window, door or sliding) in my area zip code. One Board member in my Condo community purchased/installed windows 2 years ago and pleased with windows and $.
Co. 2
Okna 500, $840/window U .27, SHGC .21, VT .42, Air .02
Okna 800, $950/window U .26, SHGC .29, VT .52, Air .01
Okna 8800, $3170/Sliding Door Heat Spacer
Okna 8800, $3870/sliding door
Total: 10,351.67 (800 series) or $10,044 (500 series)
Only company that listed a cost to remove metal windows and a cost for the high access for my condo (3rd floor in back of building)
Co. 3 (many options) (family owned business and very good reviews)
Sunrise Restoration Windows & Doors
Total $7475
Provia Aspect Windows & Products
Total $6815
Vytex Fortis & Restoration Doors
Total $7775
Vytex Fortis & Provia Aspect Doors
Total $6960
Provia Aspect Windows & Restoration Doors
Total $7050
Restoration Windows & Provia Doors
Total $7250
Co. 4 (family owned business -- excellent reviews - and also provided a list of customers in my zip code -- none that live in my condo)
Provia Endure, (windows Endure ~666 each window)
Total $9200
Co. 5 Soft-lite ~8.6 (windows Zen Nirvana which is SoftLite Class Plus Series ~659/window),
Total $8600
Questions: Is there any real difference between VT .44 and VT .50; my condo gets slight sun in the afternoon, I like sun but also want energy efficiency glass doors and windows.
Can you comment on the sliding doors systems made in one place and assembled by a manufacturer?
Should I go with Co 1 by $? I can spend a few $ more; I want a quality product with no hassle. Have lived in unit for over 20 years and never had problems with my original windows & doors
Again, glad I found your site and all your help.
Gladys - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
I haven’t heard of ph tech doors and this would be where my trepidation would come from. I looked the company up and they have been in business for over 50 years, but what does that mean?
I would go back to Co 1 and ask how long they have been working with the patio door company, what the warranty is, how has he handled whatever issues have arisen in the past, etc. I would basically try to get a sense of how confident the company is in the supplier.
I like the fact that they gave you information On past customers, reviews, etc. I would do one more search on google for “Co 1 reviews” and see how they fare on google reviews, homeadviser, and/or yelp.
Assuming they are good reviews, I would be hard pressed to spend the extra money.
If I was going to be in this condo the rest of my life, I might consider the Sunrise Restorations bid just because it’s such a good window/door.
The .44 VT and .50 VT is not a it deal in my opinion.
Good luck and let me know how the project goes!
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Ideal vs Okna
Bid 1- Ideal Platinum Series for $11,800
Bid 2- Okna 500/insul-Tec for $15,000
Bid 3- We got another quote for Simonton windows for $14500 but they didn’t appear to give us a model
Since ideal and okna companies seem relatively smaller and we obviously want to make a good investment do you have any advice on which to choose? I don’t want to cheap out but a few thousand dollar difference might be worth it. Thank you.
Christina - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Platinum Bid To Compare With Okna 600
I'm not sure exactly how to measure windows, but the internal opening size of the double hung pair is 57 1/2 x 71 1/4 inches. How To Measure Windows For Replacement
I'm planning on staying in this house - so I want a good window. I had a quote for $1050 for Okna 600 deluxe - 2 transoms and a slider. Do you have any suggestions? This quote seems expensive, but I'd like your opinion? Thank you.
Lyn - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Platinum 3000 Question
Also, what do you think about this vs. the Okna 800 for $12,987?
Grayson - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
The Okna 800 is an excellent window as well, one of the very best. Unbeatable, basically. Again, amazing price for this top tier performer. If the Ideal dealer has a good reputation, I would have a hard time getting away from this bid.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Renewal By Andersen vs Ideal
Craig - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
In NJ you have some good options. Ideal makes a very good window in the Majestic and Platinum series. This is where I'd start.
You should also be able to get bids from local companies who sell Okna, Sunrise, Soft-Lite, and possibly Polaris. All of these options will be less than RBA and will provide much better energy efficiency and overall value for your project.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Platinum 3000 vs. Okna 500
My question is on the visible light transmittance ratings. I live in an interior townhouse unit with original 1970s wooden single pane glass windows and storm windows and we want our replacement windows to let in as much light as possible. We are not as concerned about energy efficiency since we are an interior unit and our energy bills are already low. We are not expecting to see a dramatic savings when it comes to energy costs. We do however want to maximize our light coming in.
My question is on the VLT ratings. Is a 0.44 noticeably darker than a VLT of 0.55 or 0.50? Do you have a sense for how it would compare against our current single pane + storm window setup? I understand the Ideal Platinum 3000 offers amazing energy efficiency however with a lower VLT as compared to the Okna.
The Ideal Platinum 3000 also comes in a single glass package it seems so there is not ability to choose a different package that would change those numbers. I am also looking at the Ideal Majestic which is offered with a variety of glass packages and defaults to their “Energy Green” package with U 0.27, SHGC 0.28, and VLT 0.50.
Any thoughts/insight on the pros/cons of the windows and the VLT ratings are appreciated.
Rob - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Also see if the Majestic comes in a clear glass and get those VLT numbers. Both the Ideal Platinum 3000 and Majestic are very good windows. Same goes for the Okna 500. Now you just have to find the glass package that works for your needs. One side benefit is that clear glass is cheaper than the low-e!
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Ideal Platinum 3000 vs Vytex Fortis
Mo - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Answer]
The Vytex Fortis is also a solid window, comparable to the Platinum 3000, with a slightly higher air infiltration number (the lower the AI the better).
Okna is one of the top three vinyl window manufacturers so that's no surprise that the cost is higher.
How many windows are we talking here? This makes a big difference in terms of the price differences.
If you are getting a great deal on the premium Ideal vinyl window and you feel like the installer(s) are going to do a great job, I think you can pull the trigger.
All in all, you actually have three very solid options, so good on you for that.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2016
Ideal Windows Reviews | 4000 Series
4000 Series Windows
Dan - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Ideal 4500 Series
Jane - Homeowner - from 2010
[Contractor Response]
Mike - Contractor in NJ - from 2010
[2nd Response]
Steven - Installer - from 2010
Ideal 5000 Series Reviews
5000 Series vs Soft-Lite Bainbridge
Richard - Contractor - from 2010
[Contractor Response]
Wayne - Contractor - from 2010
Ideal Windows vs Gorell
Lewis - Homeowner - from 2009
[Contractor Response]
Danny - Contractor - from 2009
Ideal Majestic Windows Reviews And Prices
I've noticed that the Majestic is often priced twenty to thirty percent lower than similar quality windows. The bottom line is the Ideal Majestic is a top performing vinyl window that can offer some great value to consumers given the right price point. I would give the Ideal Majestic Series a out of 5 stars rating.
Dane - Site Editor
Majestic vs Provia Endure
Dave - Homeowner - from 2025
[Site Editor's Answer]
Dane - Site Editor - from 2025
Ideal Windows vs Okna
15x Okna 800 series (13 double hung, 1 picture window, 1 slider) - $13,747.00
15x Ideal Majestic (13 double hung, 1 picture window, 1 slider) - $10,690.00
I've spoken with the other okna vendor and the price was slightly higher so $900 - $950 seems to be the going rate per window so I don't think I can haggle much lower. Is an extra $3000 worth the price difference for the OKNA 800s over the Ideal Majestic? Added context is this is our first house and we do not plan on selling or renting anytime soon. The winters have been getting very cold and our very old old anderson wooden windows have not been doing a great job.
Diego - Homeowner - from 2024
[Site Editor's Answer]
Dane - Site Editor - from 2024
Window Replacement Pricing
Soft-Lite Windows Reviews
Lucille - Homeowner - from 2024
[Site Editor's Answer]
Dane - Site Editor - from 2024
Ideal Windows Reviews 2024
Sally - Homeowner - from 2024
[Site Editor's Answer]
Dane - Site Editor - from 2024
Ideal Majestic Windows Reviews
Should I get a quote for Sunrise Restoration as well?
George - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Absolutely get a bid on the Sunrise Restorations - what's the harm and it's another great option. I would be curious to see which of those two windows had a more narrow frame so definitely let me know if you get to compare and contrast.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Ideal vs ProVia
narrow frame to preserve as much visibility as possible
clear see thru screens
frame corners ( welds?) that are well done cosmetically- smooth, not bumpy looking like a toddler's craft project!
My best quotes so far are:
Ideal Majestic Series vinyl double hung with UltraVue mesh screens
Warranty- 10 year labor and lifetime limited on the window transferrable
Final cost: $7445
American Window and Siding of VA, Inc.
Provia Endure Fineline Double Pane series with BetterVue screens
Warranty Lifetime and transferable
Final cost: $9032
Zen Windows
The Zen option has glass that was tinted green in 2 level options that I'm not crazy about and I am asking the dealer if there is a clear option since I believe I saw it on some chart or other.
Welcome your thoughts!
Denese - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
The Ideal Majestic is a great deal -- I would be surprised if you could get a better deal.
Nonetheless I will pass on my standard list in case you do want to extend your search...
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Majestic Series vs Okna 600
Dale - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Price points are sooooo hard to say -- $600 to $1000 per window for both of them. The Ideal Majestic will tend to be less expensive, but it will really depend on the actual company that gives you a bid -- company bids tend to be all over the board and really arbitrary sometimes.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Ideal Windows Reviews On The Majestic
Okna 500 Cost: $25,586
Okna 800 Cost: $26,334
Soft Lite Classic Plus Cost: $23,743
Berkshire Elite Cost: $19,220
Ideal Majestic or Platinum 3000 Cost: $15,565
Okna 500 Cost: $29,822
Okna 800 Cost: $31,902
Vytex Fortis Cost: $22,140
Restorations Cost: $23,480
Based on your website, I had been eager to get quotes for the Okna windows, but they came out to be the highest. (The most expensive bid was from Windows on Washington). The Soft Lite is also a serious contender, but it is hard to look past the extremely favorable quote for the Ideal Majestic or Platinum 3000 windows (the installer says they are the same price for the different models).
Should I choose the Majestic over the Okna given the cost savings? Or is the Okna worth it? I worry that the price of the Majestic is too good to be true. The contractor only offers a 1 year labor warranty and charges $40 for visits outside of that year. On the other hand, two of my neighbors used this installer and were very pleased with the work and results.
Thank you for reading this, and thanks again for the great website.
Josh - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2022
Ideal Majestic vs Okna 500
So, ultimately this may be a decision based solely on price, but was wondering what your opinion is re: Okna 500 vs Zen Nirvana ( Super Lite Classic) and Ideal Majestic? We are replacing 34 original windows and two sets of sliding glass patio doors in a house built in the 70s. We only plan to be here 10 more years.
I have read a billion reviews and can't determine if any of the three edge out the others. We do not plan on getting anymore estimates. Any advice you can provide will be greatly appreciated.
Christine - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2021
Majestic Series vs. Polaris UtraWeld
Is the Okna, Soft Lite, or Sunrise that much better build windows than the Majestic windows?
Thanks.
Jason - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Opinion On Majesty Windows
See below. 6 other windows are the same brand
qty 2. 33 1/2 by 73. 1/2. Qty 4. 31. 1/2 by 33. 1/2
Total 11 plus slider
U factor .27. SGHC .22. VT .48. Air T. <.30
Total 6500.00. Current Windows 27 years old. Original windows
Don't know what regular locks means.
Does the type of foam spacer matter.
Intercept versus Duralite versus Super Saver?
Note: front two Windows are within 18 inches of floor. Is there a new code that states they are supposed to be tempered.? Any other brand suggestions?
Other products with quote from different company
ProVia Aspect 8900.00
Grandview: $8900.00.
A lot of sun/ heat in back. May be here 10 years more.
You had positive reviews in 2018
Patricia - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
[Patricia's Reply]
I need to go view the window because I do like the overall profile look of the Grandview but not the price
Additional detail about the Majesty quote:
Energy Elite package, Contour Colonial Foam filled, Triple Silver Low E Argon GAs
There are two other options:
1. Energy Green package. Dual Pane, Double strength glass with soft coat LowE
2. ESM: Dual Pane 7/8 double strength IG with Double surface of Low E Argon GAs, Foam filled Frame and Sashes and Ultra Intercept Spacer.
Besides the major issue of the sun being hottest in the rear(of course we like the sun in the winter in Northern VA) are these options over Kill.
The same company gave me a quote on Polaris Thermalweld 7420 DH Windows
Double Strength glass. Same 6500.00 price range.
They have access to several manufactures but this is what was suggested 4 days ago. I was planning on getting a couple 3 more quotes on different mfg before deciding.. OKNA or Simonton. Your thoughts.
My potential installer will know the state codes. Two front windows are less than 18 inches from floor. There is a code that states that they may need to be "tempered".
Patricia - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
The Grandview is made by Vytex. It has a .26 U-factor and .08 air infiltration rating - a decent vinyl window to be sure, a solid performer.
The Polaris Thermalweld is a good window, better than the Grandview in my opinion, but only by a bit. Not as good as the Majestic.
I would definitely get the Okna bid. Not the Simonton bid, unless it's on the Reflections 5500, but even this one can't touch Okna or Ideal.
As far as the window upgrade, I don't think you have to get the Energy Elite, but the Energy Grew looks like a nice mid range option.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Ideal Majestic Window Pricing
I'm in a home I don't plan to leave for some time and have received quotes from the same two great local companies I met previously. The company we have previously used sells the Ideal Majestic and quoted us $13,250, and the other company sells the Okna 500 at $14,500.
I know the Majestic installer because they have done great work for us, and the other company has a great reputation and has done work for my parents. So I feel like the companies and installers are both great. Any thoughts? The specs on the windows seem similar, the companies seem similar, so I'm having hard choosing between the two. Is Okna worth the extra money, and if so why? Thanks!
Justin - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
[Justin's Reply]
Justin - Homeowner - from 2020
Kensington, Vytex Or Ideal
Dealer 1: These quotes include 11 oversized windows that are 36 x 72 and replacing 5 transoms with glass.
27 Kensington Kingston double hung vinyl windows with LOW E w/argon glass, foam filled sashes and frames, white int., white exterior, white hardware. $14,800
27 VYTEX FORTIS double hung and fixed vinyl windows with ENERGY SAVER PLUS glass, foam filled sashes and frames, white int., white exterior, white hardware. $17,200
27 Ideal Majestic – $17,200
Dealer 2 – this quote includes transom windows
31 white Okna 500 series double pane windows, with internal grids. Investment- $21,890
Dealer 3 -- this quote includes transom windows - 31 Vinyl-lite windows with with LOW E w/argon glass, foam filled sashes and frames, white int., white exterior, white hardware. Vinyl-lite is a local window maker in Woodbridge Va.
Thank you.
Jeff - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
You don't have pricing on the Dealer 3 bid. I've never heard of Vinyl-lite windows so I can't make any sort of judgement on the quality of their products etc.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Ideal Majestic Signature vs. Andersen
Evan - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Answer]
The 200 series is Andersen's entry level wood window and honestly not the best wood clad window out there. It isn't a bad one either, but the Andersen 400 series is my pick for sure of the two.
Head to head, I would go with the Ideal Majestic in a heartbeat. I tend to like vinyl windows though and think they beat out wood clad in terms of cost, durabiltiy, maintenance, longevity, and energy efficiency. I should say this is for a well made vinyl window, not a poorly made one.
In terms of cost, $650 is a fair price for the Ideal Majestic Signature window. However, I would use the Andersen bid to see if the Ideal dealer is willing to lower that price. Basically, I would spend a bit of time seeing if I could find his "floor price." Even if he doesn't move on price, I still think you have a very solid window at a nice price.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Ideal Majestic Energy Elite vs.Provia Comfort Tech
They seem pretty similar to me but I am curious if I am missing something as there is a substantial price difference. Thank you for your expertise. Hope to hear soon.
Anna - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Majestic vs. Okna 500
Tim - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Either window is excellent — I would concentrate on who is doing the installation and pick whoever you feel is going to do the better job. Congrats, it doesn't sound like you can make a bad choice here!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Ideal Majestic vs. Sunrise Restorations
Gene - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Response]
The Restorations is very close and quality and craftsmanship to the Soft-Lite Imperial LS (also one of the best vinyl windows out there.) The Ideal Majestic has a .02 air infiltration and a .27 u-factor, which is right there with the Restorations model.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Gene's Response
Gene - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Response]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Gene's Response
I just received a quote of $9,200, with grids, for the Sunshine Restoration window from another contractor. I know you liked the window but is it roughly worth $2600 or $2700 more than the 3000 Ideal one?
Gene - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Gene's Response
Gene - Homeowner - from 2016
Majestic vs Soft-Lite Elements
Caroline - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
However, the Restorations does use that thinner frame, which is very nice in terms of the overall aesthetic. I would definitely recommend going with either the Elements of Restorations, I personally don't mind the thicker frame, in fact, it makes the window feel a bit sturdier to me, more substantial. So this is what I would say, if the thinner frame is important to you for its visual appeal, shell out the extra money for the Restorations. If not, go with the Elements. Either way, you are getting a fantastic window!
Dane - Site Editor - from 2016
Majestic Signature Series
My salesman came out yesterday & he sells Majestic Signature series Windows for $450 per window. They are made by Ideal Window Co. In Bayonne, NJ. Can you go into further detail about Ideal & suggest a good vinyl double hung window to purchase other than Ideal if they in fact a budget window that are good for rental properties. Thank you.
Bobbi - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
As always, I would recommend you get a couple bids from local companies that sell these vinyl windows and see how they compare to the Majestic Signature series.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Ideal Perfect Fit Windows Reviews
Perfect Fit Series vs OKNA 500
1) Ideal Perfect Fit: $875 per window installed
2) Sunrise Standard: $950 per window installed
3) OKNA 500: $895 per window installed (the installer gave us some discount from a previous quote)
My questions are:
1) What do you think of Sunrise Standard compared with OKNA 500? How is Ideal Perfect Fit?
2) What do you think of Omega 12 glass?
Thank you so much for all your help.
Sue - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Perfect Fit Series
Thanks Tim.
Barbara - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2021
Ideal Perfect Fit Series
$10,500.00 for Pella Impervia Fiberglass type
$6500.00 for Ideal Vinyl: perfect fit type, which we were told are similar to the Ideal Platinum 3000 Vinyl series.
Laurent - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Ideal Perfect Fit vs Earthwise 4700e Widow
Miroslav - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
The Ideal Perfect Fit is a decent window, I wouldn't put it in the top tier category by any means, but it's a decent performer. I would ask for the air infiltration, design pressure, U-value and condensation resistance numbers on the specific window you are purchasing and compare this to the Earthwise window.
If I had to make a selection, I think I would pick the Ideal over the Earthwise in name and reputation, but not by much. I would imagine these two windows would be relatively close in terms of quality and performance, but I could be wrong -- the numbers, particularly the air infiltration, should help answer this. I think you also need to look at which company doing the installation. Reputation, personal, references, online references, labor warranty, presentation, price -- this should obviously factor greatly into the decision.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Ideal Ultra-Tite Series
Ideal Ultratite Windows reviews
Btw, I'm happy to recommend your company for Maryland based consumers - Ideal makes an excellent window. Do you cover the entire state?
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
[Owner's Reply]
That would be great - do not cover the entire state, just the counties near the Washington DC Beltway - we also service Washington, DC and northern Virginia.
Joy - Ideal Branch Owner - from 2023
STC Rating
Should I move on from Ideal and use Window Universe then?
Greg - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
That's how I would proceed...
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Ideal UltraTite Windows Reviews and Pricing
1. Renewal By Andersen - Fibrex Composite: $45k, reduced to $30k when I told him that it was outside of my budget. Lifetime warranty (I think? tbh i didn't listen too closely b/c i knew it was outside my budget)
2. Power Home Remodeling - Pella Symphony: $21k, reduced to $19k, reduced to $16k IF and ONLY IF i signed *RIGHT THEN*. To be honest, $16k is *within* my budget, so i would consider this offer, however the "you must sign right now otherwise you don't get this price" is very shady, and I refuse to sign anything like that. Lifetime warranty including labor!
3. Simplex (in Middle Village, Queens) - Ideal UltraTite: $11.5k. 10 year warranty including labor. Seems like a great deal!
4. Major Homes (in Bay Side, Queens) - Okna 800 Deluxe: $13.75k reduced to $12.9k from negotiating. 1 year warranty, negotiated to 5 years (still trying to see if i can get 10 years!). Seems like a great deal! NOTE: he is also offering the Okna 500 for $11.5k, so a $1.4k reduction in price to go from 800->500
5. American Windows Plus (in White Plains, NY) - Crystal 200s: $10.8k. 20 year warranty including labor! Seems like an amazing deal, except everyone else tells me Crystal is very low quality product. And i went to the Crystal factory and indeed, it didn't seem very good.
6. NY Green Top (in Flushing, Queens) - Crystal 200s: $14.8k - $4k rebate via the NYSERDA Comfort Home program. Very unprofessional contractor, was not impressed in the slightest. They originally quoted me $10.8k which would have been $6.4k after the rebate (a steal!) but then at the last minute jacked up the price $4k likely to compensate for the rebate, which is shady and also they are unresponsive and no good. All of the NYSERDA contractors I called were busy/unavailable or unprofessional/small time.
7. Liberty Windoors (in Maspeth, Queens) - Veka Tilt-and-Turn European style windows: $220 - $800 per window (for my sizes, closer to $220, so: incredibly affordable!!) NOT including installation (that would have to be arranged with my own contractor). Incredible *heavy duty* windows (hundreds of pounds each!) with great build quality and absurdly high energy efficiency (U-Value of 0.19!! crazy!). Ultimately my partner and I decided not to pursue these windows even though in theory i love them and when i visit my friend's in Berlin with these windows i'm always so impressed with how cool they are (they open on TWO axes!! so cool!) because we don't want windows that swing IN, as the layout of our home doesn't really afford the space for them to be swinging in, and we prefer double hung for that reason. Incredible deal it seems, given you find a good contractor and are interested in this very different style of window.
Ok so there's my long list! It's between 3. Simplex and 4. Major Homes. Simplex offers the better warranty and slightly better price with the UltraTite, and they come recommended by my neighbor (although admittedly he hasn't personally worked with them, he just "knows they do a lot of business around Queens, he sees them everywhere"). Major Homes offers the much lauded Okna 800s (and Okna 500s too), and seems to be willing to negotiate both on price and on warranty.
I'm currently leaning Okna 800s because after this long and grueling search, $12.9k seems reasonable all things considered, and if i can get a 10 year warranty I'm confident that any defects will be fixed, and the windows will last and be great. I could easily be convinced to drop to the Okna 500s (it's not like my house in Queens is in perfect condition, it's over 80 years old!) to save some money, as well as switch to the UltraTite for the superior warranty and potentially lower risk contractor. The Major Homes owner was a tiny bit salesly (nothing compared to Power or Andersen) while the Simplex guy stands by his product and his work and doesn't sell at all (which to me is a good sign).
Ben - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
I think this is who I would go with -- if you are going to be in your home long term, then I would go with the Okna 800 and call it a day. One of the best windows out there from a highly rated review site -- can't really beat that!
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
UltraTite Review
I'll definitely get more quotes, with your advice in mind! But I might find that I can't find anything less than $10k for 17 windows, and if so it's looking like the ultratite quote is quite attractive! I'll use the link to help you out. Thanks again!
Ben - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Ideal is a bit weird -- the Majestic is I believe (but you'll want to confirm this with them) the UltraTite -- or it's the Platinum 3000 series -- on their website they don't even mention the Majestic or Platinum 3000, but most homeowners I deal with get bids on these models and not the models listed on their website -- the window industry is a wacky place...confirm what the UltraTite is and if that company has good reviews, I would strongly consider this bid!
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
[Site Editor's Answer]
FYI i filled out your form and got several calls pretty quickly. I'll let you know how it goes. I'm hoping to get some good, comparable quotes <$13k for all 17 windows, or <$750 per window, and then choose the best quality for that price point.
Thanks a million!
Ben - Homeowner - from 2022
Ideal UltraTite Windows
UltraTite doublehung UltraTite Double Hung or
DuraWeld doublehung DuraWeld Double Hung.
Are these the same Ideal windows that you are referring to?
Ren - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Basically, the Majestic/Platinum 3000 are exclusive windows sold by certain dealers.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Ideal Ultra-Tite II Windows
They are pushing the Ideal Ultra Tite II Windows - actually that is the only window the salesman would talk to me about basically – but I don't see those reviewed on your site. Have you heard anything about them. I'm also sending you my quote from them in another email. I would greatly appreciate it if you could tell me what you think. Thank you very much!
Katie - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
The bid looked reasonable but if it were me and I was going with the Ideal Ultra Site, I would request that they upgrade to the R5 glass or the Energy Gold Plus glass package for the price they quoted you at.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Ideal Duraweld Reviews
Duraweld vs. Okna 500
The second bid I liked was Ideal Duraweld windows, with no price quote for the doors (he said he'd get back to me when he had a price.) This was $12.8K. Also, I have been scouring your page on ideal windows reviews but the pricing is still a bit thin.
Kellen - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Unless the Ideal Duraweld quote with the doors comes in lower, I think you need to go with the Okna option. If the Ideal quote is lower, shoot me another email with the quotes and what door they are using and I can offer you my opinion.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Ideal Professional Windows
Ideal Professional Windows vs United 4500
The difference is about 10% in favor of the United, but I see you feel these are the low end of the mid-range window. So, do you have any experience with the Ideal Professional series? U-Factor is .30 and SHGC is .28 on the Ideal Professional. Thank you in advance for your help.
Paul - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
General Reviews
Ideal In Brooklyn
Suzanne - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
I like the numbers on the Thermalast -- I just don't trust anything I haven't heard of -- I've been in the business a long time. But...good products do hit the market and maybe this is one of those cases...I wouldn't worry about Power hrg or Castle, I think there are better options out there. PowerHRG Reviews.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Ideal Windows Reviews in New Jersey
My neighbor just replaced all his double hungs with Okna brand installed by a local contractor with a good reputation. He’s the neighbor who told me about Okna after doing extensive research. What are some other quality casement brands I should research and consider besides Okna 700? We have 15 medium size casements, 5 small casements, 2 large and 2 fixed windows in the LR and DR that are flanked on either side by a pair of medium casements (DR) and large casements (LR). Thanks.
Gus - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Best Window On The Market?
Olga - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Dane - Site Editor - from 2017
Ideal Owner Review
The products, the support staff, the deliveries are simply so reliable. I love their quality, their consistency (product and entire company team) and reliability. They are critical values to my home improvement business. I get plenty of vendors who walk in to get some of my window and door business. Candidly, the conversation is 1 sided and over in 30 seconds. I have ZERO interest in looking at their "killer pricing" cause I'll get what I pay for. I am VERY PLEASED and never doubt that Ideal is my primary Window and Door supplier for a very long time.
David - Owner - from 2015
Energy Star Requirements
Their service is unmatched and we are still able to get parts and fix windows that we installed 20 years ago. Ideal has also proven themselves to be an industry leader in new features and glass packages to stay ahead of the competition and energy star requirements. As we've expanded and added other exterior remodeling services to our business, one thing had stayed constant. Ideal has set the standard to which all other company's are judged.
Steve - Window Installation Company - from 2015
Ideal Windows vs Harvey
The journey to find the right installer and the best window started in late April and we are still looking. It has been a confounding path to say the least. Next to buying my car I have had to "do my homework" carefully and still no concrete decisions. Hope to arrive at one soon.
Nan - Homeowner - from 2015
[Contractor Response]
If you like the quote on the Okna, take the lowest quote you have from the Ideal and Harvey and see if you can get one of the Okna guys to come down to that price and pull the trigger (assuming you feel comfortable with the installers.) Honestly, in terms of vinyl replacement windows, you really can't do much better than Okna - which is usually very similar to Soft-Lite windows cost.
Dane - Contractor - from 2015
Satisfied Customer
Travis - Homeowner - from 2005
Ideal vs Polaris
Freda - Homeowner - from 2012
[Contractor Response]
Matt - Contractor - from 2012
Paradigm Windows Reviews