| REVIEWS |  |
BEST WINDOWS | |
WINDOWS PRICES | |
STYLES |
Home : Replacement Windows Reviews : Anlin
Anlin Windows Reviews
Anlin Window Cost: $$$/$$$$
(3.5 out of 5)
"Personally, I would rate Anlin a 4.7 out of 5 in terms of brand reputation and overall quality. A great buy at the right price point."
Quick Links
Panoramic Series | Catalina
Del Mar Series | Coronado
Monte Verde Series | Ali'i Extreme
Mar Vista | Patio Doors
General Anlin Reviews
Get Our Recommended Window List
Also please consider filling out the free form on our site for 3 quality window price quotes — it’s how we afford to provide free consumer information. We’re not incentivized by ANY company and will help you with ANY questions you might have, and help you navigate ANY bids you receive. That’s our guarantee to you!
dane@replacementwindowsreviews.co
Anlin XTRU with Infinite-e Glass
Dane, thank you so much for your prompt response and input.
The Anlin Coronado was the window we were leaning towards, however, our dealer quote us the Anlin XTRU with Anlin Infinite-e glass package. The quote came in at $35,700 for a total of 33 windows.
We have three windows we are changing. The current configuration is three 36-inch single hung with an eyebrow above that spans the entire length of the three windows. We are changing to a 3 light (1/4 - 1/2 - 1/4) with 70/30 oriel. Because of this change the installer is adding trim to the exterior of the house on these three windows. This is included in the price.
Based on your recommendation, I was able to locate a Zen dealer in our area and just reached out to them for a bid.
Sifting through all the sales pitches to identify the best option for our budget has been interesting to say the least. Your unbiased opinion has provided us with the input we’ve been in search of. Thank you!
Karla - Homeowner - from 2022
Anlin Windows Reviews :: Panoramic Series
The Panoramic series is a solid vinyl window, built with a slightly thinner frame in order to allow more glass area and gain the title of "panoramic." It is ideal for picture windows where homeowners really want want more glass in a good window. With the upgraded Sun Matrix Plus glass package, the Panoramic delivers a .03 air infiltration rating, STC rating of 35, U-value of .027, and an SHGC of .18.
Consumers will sacrifice some energy efficiency with the Panoramic. I prefer the Del Mar series, which offers a sturdier frame, but I see the appeal of the thinner frame for certain projects. I would give the Anlin Panoramic Series Window a out of 5 stars rating.
Dane - Site Editor
Anlin Windows Reviews On Panoramic Model
Hi Dane, I have enjoyed your website. I recently received an estimate for Anlin Panoramic full replacements (29) for a home in North Texas that has original aluminum builder grades from 1998. They included a back door replacement but we can exclude that for a discount of about $2,900. Quote still seemed a bit high for white vinyl windows. We actually want to get black trim which would be about 25% more per the window company.
I'm uncertain if Anlin is the best combo of quality/warranty/price.
Thanks in advance.
John - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
John, Anlin is a good brand but their bids are often quite high -- my suggestion is to collect four bids and then take a look at them side by side to see what's what...
Here is our simple, no-cost form if you wanted No Cost Window Bids
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Anlin Windows vs MI
Hi Dane, thank you for all your guidance so far! We have gotten several quotes and are ready to pick one to move forward with. Here are the quotes we’ve received. This is for 28 windows including install.
Zen Windows:
Soft-Lite Classic Plus: $25k
Soft-Lite Imperial Elite with triple pane glass: $33k
Designer Doors and Windows:
Anlin Panoramic: $29k
Also offers Anlina Catalina for ~6% more: about $31k?
Lifetime Windows:
Anlin Del Mar: $50k
Infinity by Marvin: $68k
Power by Pella: $36k
Quint Pro: MI 1620: $28k (Read all of our MI Windows reviews here.)
Window Universe: Gentech Signature Elite: $27k
We are nixed the quotes at the bottom, as the ones at the top seem to be better quality and better warranties within the same price range. We were originally very interested in the fiberglass as we hear they are less susceptible to hail damage (almost all of our current windows have visible hail damage that the previous owner never addressed, so it is a concern in our area). However, I don’t think we can justify the extra expense for the Marvin fiberglass windows.
We are thinking about either the Soft Lite Classic Plus or the Anlin Panoramic. Both have warranties that seem to cover just about everything (except hail of course) and the energy efficiency ratings seem similar. Maybe leaning slightly towards the Anlin Panoramic because we actually got to meet someone in person and see the window vs Zen is all online. Also I think I may slightly prefer the look of the thinner Panoramic frame. But we are hoping these last 30+ years, so if there is a clear winner or some other important considerations, would love to hear them! I do wonder if the Panoramic will be as stable since the frame is thinner and I don’t believe it is foam insulated like the Soft Lites are.
Kathryn - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Kathryn, I agree with your assessment about the Soft-Lite Classic or Anlin Panorama options. Both very good options.
One other option you might want to consider because you plan to be in your home for 30 plus years is the Imperial Elite. It is one of the best vinyl windows on the market, but obviously will cost quite a bit more over the Classic Plus.
I think any of these three options would be good though and I understand about the Panorama profile.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Anlin Panoramic vs Catalina
Here is a quick overview of the quotes I received for eight (8) windows to replace the original windows of my 1951 home. I live in Phoenix, AZ with scorching hot summers, and I'm specifically looking for windows that are energy efficient.
Two (2) XOX (108x51 & 86X39), Four (4) Single Slider (54x51, 54x51, 71x47, 53x51), One (1) Single Hung 37x51), One (1) Picture Window (70x51)
Anlin Del Mar - $17,109.82
Simonton Daylight Max - $6,998.93
Amerimax AG3 Insulated Glass System- $12,160
Anlin Catalina Series Cost - $18,600
Anlin Panoramic Series Cost - $16,651
Milgard - $10,564.01 (did not say which series in the quote)
All the quotes are inclusive of install.
I'm leaning toward the Anlin based on the reviews I saw on your website, but I feel the price is steep for 8 windows. Unless what I was quoted is fair?
Thank you for your input!
Jessica - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Jessica, that's quite a range of prices. The Anlin seems expensive, but it is the best window in the group and all of those bids are more or less equal to one another. The Amerimax bid doesn't say the model just the glass package. Nor the Milgard -- weird for window companies to give you a bid and not tell you what it is a bid for --
If you plan to be there for many years, then the Anlin Del Mar might be the call. The bids do seem expensive, although those XOX are expensvie units.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Anlin Windows Reviews On The Panoramic
I want to thank you for taking the time to talk with me about your window project. Below is a breakdown of the equipment and quote.
(1) Quote - Consists of 15- Anlin Panoramic Single Hung Tilt design windows. All constructed with Anlin's proprietary Titanium Dioxide Infused Vinyl Extrusion Multi-Chamber Welded Frame, Expanded View Series for Maximum glass Maximum viewing area, Standard Easy Clean Glass Coating on Outside, Sun Matrix Glass Pkg. with Argon Gas Upgrade with NEW GENERATION SPACER, Triple Fin weatherstripping for weather tight seals,
True Action Lock system, plus Anlin Panoramic Sound Pkg. with Sound Suppression Technology
Sun Matrix Plus Glass Pkg. with Platinum Elite Next Generation Spacer System and Argon Gas Upgrade.
SHGC 0.18 U Factor 0.27 Air Filtration 0.03 STC Rating 35 99% UV Block
15 - windows installed - Total - $15914.00 - All Dark Bronze Color Exterior / White Color Interior - Colonial Grids included
Got another bid from the same guy for Wincore 5400 series for $17,750.
David - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
David, the Anlin Panoramic is the better window over the Wincore 5400 -- and it's cheaper...
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Window Replacement in Chandler AZ
Hi, I received a quote for $19,000 for 12 windows and one sliding glass door for Anlin Panorama. This does include two large picture windows (with one arch), but rest are fairly standard size.
What do you think?
Crystal - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Crystal, it sounds like a decent bid to me. Now get two to three more bids, compare them, and make your selection based on windows and the installation company.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Del Mar Cost vs. Panoramic Series
Hello Dane, thank you for the excellent website and tips and advice on the website, it has been a critical resource in evaluating our window project. I really do appreciate all the advise you have given there.
We are replacing the Viking windows in our house which seem to have been done as a DIY project by the previous owners, we can see the screws in the frames used to attach the windows, the frames themselves are uneven and bowing, some are leaking. This has prompted us to replace them before the next rainy season.
I have attached a quote from one of the contractors, who after providing us the quote said they would take almost $9K off (20%) because our order would be clubbed with a large apartment complex order they have received. That sounded like a cheap sales technique and a look on yelp showed that they have given similar 20% discounts to other customers when they complained about something.
This quote is for the Del Mar-E, we got another quote from another Anlin dealer for the Panoramic series. That quote is about $4K cheaper than the one attached one. The second quote does not price the windows and labor separately as the attached quote, instead they given the price per window inclusive of materials, labor and taxes. Comparing it with the attached quote they seem to be charging about $1,000 for labor per window/door (allocating some difference in price to the difference in price between similar sized Del Mar vs Panoramic windows).
I would love to hear your thoughts on this quote. I think 2-3 years ago this quote would likely have been around the $20K - $25K mark for the same windows but I know the costs have increased substantially in the past 2 years.
Looking forward to hearing your opinions.
Asif - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Asif, I have struggled recently with many of the price quotes I'm receiving. Anlin is basically charging you $1600 for a two lite slider -- that is double what I would expect. Then $1000 for labor on each window. Maybe this project is more expensive than I realize, but it seems very overpriced to me. But then again the other company is charging you windows and installation and it's not that much cheaper.
I would continue to garner bids until you find something that is more reasonable myself.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Panorama vs Del Mar
The contractor I talked to recommended the Panoramic line in response to my concern about the potential loss of glass area with the Del Mar or Catalina styles. Is there any downside to the Anlin Panoramic?
Suzy - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Like all thinner vinyl framed windows, you will sacrifice some performance for the increased glass area. The company tries to counter balance this with a better glass package, but a thinner frame means you will have a slightly less sturdy frame. It's a trade off -- for instance in Europe they use incredibly thick vinyl frames and they lose quite a bit of glass area, but their windows are very energy efficient and they last forever.
I tend to think that the eye gets used to whatever it sees and that you won't see the difference once the windows are in. Basically I'm in the camp that says if you are going to replace your windows you want longevity and performance. However, this is an opinion and these are your windows. If the viewing area is a big deal for you, then I think you should absolutely consider the Panoramic over their traditional vinyl windows. Yes, you get slightly less performance and possibly a bit less on the overall life of the window, but we aren't talking about huge numbers.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Anlin Panoramic vs. Simonton Daylight Max
Hello Dane, we are looking to replace 1970s era windows in elderly mother’s SoCal condo. Window installer came out to measure and will send quote in a day or two, installation dates backlogged until June!
The following are their preferred brands Anlin Panoramic, Monte Verde (by Anlin), and Simonton Daylight Max. Mom’s condo doesn’t get much direct sunlight, so we are not overly concerned for keeping heat out. Warranty that can be transferred is probably a bonus, as may be a good selling point down the road. Main concern is keeping heat in, and ease of opening windows and one slider.
Would appreciate your rankings on the above brands. Thank you!
Carisa - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Carisa, of the brands you mentioned, I would put them in this order from best to least best (they are all pretty decent windows) — Anlin Panoramic, Monte Verde (by Anlin), and Simonton Daylight Max.
The Anlin is the better brand over Simonton in general. To be honest, the Monte Verde isn’t all that much better over the Simonton Daylight Max.
Please let me know if you have any additional questions!
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Panoramic Windows Bid
Hi Tim, we received a quote for 17 Anlin Panoramic Windows in Dallas for $14,650. Does that seem like a reasonable quote? It looks like you think Anlin windows are solid windows?
Thanks.
Eric - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Seems high to me. Is it full frame installation? If so, it's not bad. I certainly think Anlin windows are high quality, but they can be expensive.
Since you are in Dallas, you should get a quote from local dealers who carry Sunrise, NT, Don Young (aluminum), and Zen (if they are selling Soft-Lite and not Alside).
I would get these bids and see how the Anlin compares to these.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
[Eric's Reply]
Thanks Jon.
Yes, this quote is for full frame installation.
We did get a quote from a contractor who works with Sunrise, and they quoted us at 16,850 for only 15 Sunrise Replacement Windows. (they wouldn't replace 2 of our windows b/c they are very small.)
Part of the reason we like the Anlin quote is b/c the installer was referred by another contractor we trust (who used to install windows but doesn't anymore). i'm a little leery of whether or not an installer is going to do a good job.
Are you recommending Sunrise, NT, Don Young, and Zen b/c they do well in the heat? Are they going to perform substantially better than Anlin?
Thanks.
Eric - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Anlin is on par with these other manufacturers. I thought you might want multiple quotes to see how they compare. The Sunrise quote is high and not worth the extra money over the Anlin quote.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Anlin Windows Price List
Hi Dane, we are getting full frame replacement quotes for 5 windows and two sliding doors for our condo:
95x80 doors
47x59 XO
35x35 XO
60x23 awning
47x23 half circle picture
71x40 XO
We live in the bay area and have gotten a couple bids which seem very high. One was for the Anlin panoramic windows with Malibu doors or Milguard Tuscany at 17,500. A second dealer quoted Anlin Del Mar at 10,900 and offered the panoramic at approx 1k less (official quote not provided). Are we just way off on what to expect for 5 windows and 2 sliders?
Thank you.
Ian - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Ian, the first bid is crazy high, but the second bid is not bad actually. Those are big doors and the half circle windows can be pricey. However, is it a bargain price, no. The Bay Area seems tricky right now with pricing I’ve noticed.
I wonder if you could get a quote from an Amerimax dealer — I’m not certain that brand is up there, but you can google Amerimax windows in Palo Alto, California (insert your city) and see if any local companies come up.
I would use the bid to compare it with the Anlin bid and possibly to ask the Anlin dealer to match it (assuming it comes in lower.)
Maybe also try another Milgard dealer and see how that bid comes in. The Anlin Del Mar is a very good window and the company makes a good door. I just wonder if they would come down off that $10.9K.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Anlin Panoramic Series vs. Simonton Daylight Max
My small condo on the southern California coast has a total of 3 vinyl (casement) windows - a single pane, a double pane and a triple pane. (The center pane on the triple is fixed, does not open). Salt air does a job on the casement hardware, plus when the windows swing open they encroach on my (already small) patio space. So I want to change to sliders (XO and XOX) on the double and triple, respectively, and a single hung on the smaller single pane window. All panes are about 22”W x 54”H.
For the retrofits, I think I need to use narrower frame models, so as to maximize viewing area and not deviate from the look of the existing casements in the building. The HOA needs to approve this project, and they won’t want the windows to look too different from the exterior from what’s already there.
So far I have quotes from 4 contractors; 2 on Simonton Daylight Max, 1 on Anlin Panoramic, and 1 on Alside Montrose. I’ve eliminated the Alside for quality reasons. To do the job with Simontons was quoted at $3,365 and $2,175, respectively (big difference). Anlin was quoted at $3,245. I want to get one more Anlin quote, which I am looking for now. But first of all, don’t you think these prices (even the lowest) are high for this small, 3 window job? I like the feel of the Anlin, but if I have to pay an extra $1,100 (about 50% more!) for the project to get Anlin, not sure it’s worth it. How much more should I be willing to pay for Anlin than Simonton in this case? We do plan to keep this condo for the foreseeable future.
Your thoughts would be appreciated. Thanks!
Martin - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Martin, I took another look at the numbers on the Simonton Daylight max window and was pretty impressed by the air infiltration .06 and U-factor .29 on the sliders. I'm curious about the price difference between the Simonton quotes. Was it through two different Home Depots?
The Anlin Panoramic would be my pick of the bunch so far, although the lower Simonton quote is tough to ignore. I would be careful to properly vet the installers on this one since its so much lower.
In terms of cost, it's tough to say. These aren't three standard windows, the XO and XOX are more complex set ups -- some people might define your project as 6 windows.
You may want to throw a Milgard Tuscany quote in for no other reason than to see how it compares. If it's in that same price range, then you know the numbers are fair. I might take the lower Simonton quote back to the Anlin dealer and ask him to match it. (Or tell him that the price is more in line with what you were hoping to spend.) He probably won't match it, but I'll bet you will see something close to his lowest price point.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Anlin Windows vs Simonton
Hi, I'm looking at Anlin Panoramic retrofit Windows, for the 2.5 inch verses the 3.5 inch frame for bigger views. Are these as good as their Del Mar and Catalina series Windows?
Also comparing them to Milgard and Simonton 7300 Daylightmax series. How do any of these compare to Amerimax? What series do you recommend from Amerimax? Can't find a distributer/installer yet for Amerimax and the Anlin rep told me Amerimax is rumored to about to go out of business? Any info on this?
What do you recommend please? The Anlins and Simontons are about equally priced.
Thanks so much,
Bob - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Bob, the Anlin Panoramic is a good vinyl option, but because they are maximizing the glass area, you will lose some performance and possibly some long term durability. Not much, but there is always a trade off in these decisions. The Del Mar and Catalina use a slightly stronger frame, but you lose out on the extended glass area. All of their windows are solid though so I wouldn't worry about it too much.
I would put Anlin on par with the Milgard Tuscany, although I might give the nod to the Anlin. I would definitely go with the Anlin over the Simonton 7300 Daylightmax series. I think Anlin makes the better window. Normally, I see bids on Anlin that are much more expensive than Simonton.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Anlin Windows Reviews :: Catalina Series
The Anlin Catalina is the company "mid range" vinyl window model. It uses a 2 and 7/8 inch frame depth, .80 inch frame thickness, equal sightlines, the Elite spacer, double strength glass and a single vent latch. The Catalina can be ordered in 14 exterior color options, 2 glass package options, 5 hardware options, 3 grid patters and 2 casing configurations. This window is available in a single slider, single hung
The Catalina series differs from the Del Mar series in the following ways: the Del Mar series has the Innergy thermal reinforcement, ultra-strong fiberglass thermal inserts to strengthen the sash and frame, and Comfort•Core—green foam injections into the window frames to maximize energy efficiency. I would give the Anlin Catalina a out of 5 stars rating.
Dane - Site Editor
Catalina Series Cost
I have a bid from a contractor on 28 windows and 1 door using the Anlin Catalina series and Malibu door. $27.8K - is this a good price?
Shelly - Homeowner - from 2024
[Site Editor's Answer]
Shelly, 28 windows and 1 sliding door using the Anlin Catalina series and Malibu door for $27.8K is probably a pretty decent price. Certainly in the realm of fair. I would probably collect a few more bids if this were my project in order to know how the local competition would price it out. That's really the only way to know if the price is fair or inflated.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2024
Anlin Catalina Windows Reviews
Dane, I have a quick question - the Anlin Catalina or Milgard Homemaker series? The bids are very similar, so I'm straight comparing the quality of the windows themselves. same price.
Ronny - Homeowner - from 2024
[Site Editor's Answer]
Ronny, both good products. Probably very similar in terms of quality to be honest - I guess that is reflected in the price. I'd go with the window offered by the company with the best online reviews myself. I think this is the most important factor here. Windows are probably equal - although I like the Anlin brand over the Milgard brand.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2024
Anlin Windows Reviews 2023
Hi Dane, here are my bids on 5 Windows.
Bid 1: My personal notes- This contractor has almost 300 five star reviews online. He also carries one of the top brands/lines you recommended and at a lower cost then some of the other quotes
Anlin Catalina CAT in White, 1 Malibu (door)
Glass package for windows includes- infinite-e Glass (95%), Argon Gas, and the Del Mar Sound Package
Additional information: AAMA Certified installation- multiple caulk lines and semi active expanding foam. Patio and French Doors are automatically tempered. Upgraded to stainless steel rollers on sliding doors.
U-Factor .27 SHG .22 VLT 52% UV 95% Air Infil 0.04% STC 34
Quote: $7,200
Bid 2: My personal notes- This contractor has around 150 mostly five star reviews online. I specifically asked for the the models/lines that you recommended based on the brands they carry and I was quoted (seems like they either don't carry the specific Simonton lines you recommended or decided to choose for themselves what to quote me)
Brand: Simonton Daylight Max
Glass Package- E3 and Argon Gas
Quote: $6712
Bid 3:
My personal notes- This contractor has around 150 mostly five star reviews online. This is the first quote i had reached out to you on that you thought sounded high. He quoted me the following:
Milgard Styline $11,000
Amsco Studio $12,000
(Amsco Windows Reviews)
Anlin Catalina $13,500 (NEARLY DOUBLE COST OF BID 1 FOR SAME PRODUCT)
Conclusion:
Based on the 3 bids, i'm thinking Bid 1 sounds fairly priced and the company has a very big online presence and reputation. If you think i should still try to get another Bid or two, i can do that as well. Thoughts?
Thank you again for your help!!!
Dan - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Daniel, I completely agree that bid 1 is fairly priced, the window is high quality and the installation company has a fantastic reputation. The trifecta -- you really can't ask for more than this. That's a solid price for 5 windows and 1 patio door. You did your due diligence and found an awesome deal. Congrats!
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
[Dan's Reply]
Dane, thank you so much!! I honestly could not have done it without your advice. Greatly appreciated! If there's anything I can do on my end, please let me know.
Dan - Homeowner - from 2023
Anlin Windows Reviews On The Catalina
Hey Dane, can you tell me your thoughts here?
30 Catalina Series - totally varying sizes but all singe hung or double hung and most are I'd say pretty normal sized.
Total Cost: $44,457.96
Cash Discounted
Total: $40,901.32
July Promotion: $39,000.00
Frank - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Frank, that’s an expensive quote — I would continue to find other bids as comparison to discover whether there are better prices and products out there, or whether this is the fair market price for your project.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Anlin Windows vs Milgard
Hi Dane, I have read a lot of information on the website and it has been really great. I've also read a lot of the question/reply streams, which have also been great. I am planning to replace some windows in my house here i nthe Denver metro area. I have quotes from an Installer I trust. Here is the information of both estimates:
For some reason I couldn't paste the screenshot for the Milgard Tuscany estimate, but at least you can see the specifics of what i'm ordering. The Milgard estimate for the same products came in at $10,162. I am very noise-sensitive and am tired of listening to every little thing that goes on outside my house, so I have opted for the sound reduction glass in both brands estimates.
I believe this will be the double pane "dissimilar thickness" style glass for both Anlin Windows vs Milgard. So, the Milgard quote is about $680 more total, but I don't consider that enough of a difference to be a major factor in deciding between the two. My Installer has more experience installing Milgard, but has a better "working relation" with his Anlin contact. My installer has done a nice job of being unbiased and is probably right to say that I'd probably be happy with either brand.
I am trying to find that key piece of data or item of consideration that could tip me over to make the decision to go with one brand over the other. I did read your information about negotiating the estimate and I will certainly do that shortly. My sense is that negotiating through Anlin may be easier for my Installer since as I alluded to earlier, he has a better working relationship with him, but i don't want to incorrectly assume anything. Thanks in advance for your advice!
Eric - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Eric, for me, when it comes to Anlin Windows vs Milgard. I think Anlin is better made and tend to have less batch issues over Milgard. I also happen to like the look of the Anlin Catalina over the Tuscany. If this were project, I'd go for the Anlin Catalina and you get to save $700 :). That's my take for what it's worth!
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Anlin Windows vs Milgard
Hi Dane, first off, thank you and your team for such a fantastic window resource. Your site's question/ answer format was super helpful for learning a substantial amount about different brands and product lines.
My wife and I are looking to replace 33 windows in our San Diego home, and we currently have quotes for Anlin Catalina, Milgard Trinsic, and Simonton Daylight Max/ Madeira. I wanted to confirm that quality goes in that same order, with Anlin as the best, followed by Milgard and then Simonton. If you have any other mid-tier vinyl options you highly recommend, we're all ears! Thanks.
Shane - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Shane, I would say that is correct in terms of the overall quality. I'd say the Anlin is a step over the other two brand/series. The only other option you might look into is the Amerimax brand. I believe that there are dealers in your area, but their Craftsman Portrait is a solid performer. I want to say that BM Windows used to carry them, but they might have switched to Milgard --
You are definitely on the right track with those options in San Diego -- I think the Catalina is a great option, depending on the price and reviews/ratings of the dealer you are working with.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Catalina vs Monte Verde
Hi John, I just got another email from the window guy saying that the Anlin Catalina is not available and will be installing Anlin Monte Verde instead. Is that a downgrade?? Is $630 a window still a good deal? I appreciate your advice!!
Cheryl - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Cheryl, the Monte Verde is still quite a good series. Is it as good as the Catalina...it's close -- but here's the thing, $630 per window these days is an excellent price. I don't think you can really complain too much about this window at this price. Assuming the installation company has good reviews, I think you are good to go!
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Catalina Series Costs
I received a quote on 3 Anlin Catalina for $6,800.
1: 95*58 XOX
2: 71*59 XO
Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Nick - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Nick, I can't say it's an unfair quote because I don't know exactly what is required of the project, but it's not exactly inexpensive. Pricey is what I would say. I think one or two more quotes would clarify this for you.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2022
Anlin Windows Reviews
Dane, we just got a quote for 16 windows and 1 sliding door for $18,987. This seems really high. What are your thoughts?
Very Respectfully.
Tony - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Tony is this for new construction or full frame replacement or an insert / retrofit installation?
Dane - Site Editor - from 2021
[Tony's Reply]
Retrofit Catalina window.
Tony - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Tony, yes then this is quite a high quote. I think all of these companies are swamped with work and they are taking it out on the consumer. What about getting a few more bids to see what's out there?
If you would like some quality local bids you can use our Price Quote Form, beginning with your zip code where it says Find Local Five Star Rated Pros. The bids are free and you can send them to me and I'm more than happy to provide you with my take on any cost quotes you receive. I'm not incentivized by any companies so I'm happy to provide you with unbiased advice on your best option(s).
In addition, here is my list of good and great windows:
[List Redacted -- contact us directly (Dane or Tim) for our good and great windows list]
Dane - Site Editor - from 2021
Anlin Del Mar vs Catalina
Dane, thank you so much. I have more question. I live by the noisy street. What is the best I can pick to block the noise. I was told Anlin Del Mar is good but $21000 expensive verses Catalina $17,000.
I have 13 windows and 2 slider and one french doors.
Ryan - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Ryan, noise reduction is a tricky one. I don't think you are going to see much difference at all by going to the Del Mar. One step you can take is to custom order the glass so that the interior and exterior panes are different thicknesses. This will block some noise frequencies. Or you could do laminated glass, but this is not cheap.
The real noise killer is the spacing between the inner and outer panes of glass, but most double pane windows are standard depth. You can buy a sound control window like the Milgard Quietline, but they can be very expensive.
I think a good vinyl double pane window will go pretty far on noise abatement compared to old single pane aluminum windows.
Remember, your walls can also transmits sound so if this is another place to look.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Anlin Catalina Windows Reviews
Hi Dane and Tim, we are replacing all of the original windows in our home (installed in 1989), as well as the back door (French door w/ hide away screen). We live in Texas and in the summer-time our rooms that face direct sun can get to 90 degrees because so much heat comes in, so it is time to replace them.
After receiving a quote from Renewal By Anderson for nearly $100,000, we decided to get a quote from Anlin. While we know Anderson and Anlin are 2 different types of window, we cannot see ourselves spending $100k on this project! But because the 2 quotes are so far apart, we would like to know if we're getting a good price with Anlin. We opted to go with a clean look so no grids in the windows and their quote for replacing all 36 and the back door is as follows.
72x72 picture window-2
48x84 single hung-8
60x48 double slider-4
24x48 single hung-1
36x84 single hung-5
24x60 single hung-4
36x60 picture window-1
80x60 picture window-1
36x48 picture-3
24x24 circle-1
36x60 single hung-2
72x84 picture-2
48x72 single hung-2
French Door-58x80
Quote: $30,000
Thanks in advance and any input will be greatly appreciated.
Josh - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Hi Josh, so Renewal bids are often Insanely expensive. The Anlin quote looks good and they make a very good vinyl window.
You may want to get one or two more bids to compare the Anlin Quote to. My suggestions would be a Sunrise window and a Zen Nirvana model. These are comparable windows and doors, and you might get a bid that’s even better than the Anlin quote. Just something to think consider...
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Anlin Windows Reviews
Hi Dane, just found your site and it's extremely helpful. I am waiting for my 4th estimate for window replacement (which is in a few days). I've eliminated one already (ridiculously over-priced) and the other two I liked the sales people (which means nothing because it's all about the installer) but here's my dilemma.
One's estimate is for Anlin Catalina and the other is Milgard Trinsic. Their bids were $16 apart!
The sizes are: two of the same at 36" across and 72" vertical; replacements on these will be solid-picture on the bottom and the top two thirds a single hung. Another window approx 36 wide & 38 vertical (slider); and the 4th is 78" wide and 24" high (will have sliders on both sides).
All 4 windows retrofit and vinyl (as you can tell by the brands). Both companies quoted approx $5500 for the 4 total windows.
I'm in the Bay area (30 minutes north of SF). What is your feeling on the price? What is your feeling on the brands? Also, is there any specific foam or sealant I should be requesting (as one said that they have a "special" sealant that others don't have that is more pliable/doesn't cause cracks, etc).
I'm guessing they'd all use similar foam, sealant etc but what do I know. (also, if you add this one to your blog, could you wait until after I make a choice/negotiate, based on your comments?). :D Thanks in advance...
Beth - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Beth, the Anlin Catalina would be my pick. Anlin makes the better window over Milgard in my opinion. Not cheap for 4 windows is it?
Most companies use a similar sealant or one that works well for the particular window they install.
I might look for one or two more bids just to check that price. Maybe a Simonton 5500 Reflections or maybe a Ply Gem Pro or Premium. Just to see about the price. I still the Anlin is the best west coast option you have.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
[Beth's Reply]
Thank you so much, Dane! One of the two $5500 bids had originally said they were going to do Simonton but then said they had to change to Milgard because Simonton couldn’t do the proper configuration for thetwo 6-foot windows (he said something about Simonton adds a stucco fin, and that they couldn’t do it with a molded(?) retrofit frame...but that Milgard would make a retrofit fin with the configuration they were going to do).
They also went on to say that one of the other companies I am having out would do a block frame with no fin and they’d try to add their own fin over on top of it - but that in doing that, it wouldn’t be guaranteed for waterproof). I really didn’t hear/understand the reasoning...
May I ask your opinion on the price? 4 windows (although they’re unusual sizes) does that seem high? If so, should I try to negotiate down and if so, what is reasonable? Sorry for all the questions - but you seem to be the window God... very happy I found your site...
Beth - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Beth, the price seems quite high to me, although I have no idea what's involved in the installation. That's where the extra bids come in. If you have four bids and they are all the same basic price, then you can assume that that's the fair market price. Bids have a tendency to be all over the board and often times you can get one that is much better than the others.
Get a couple more bids and use the lower bids to ask Anlin if they will match the low bid. Always worth a shot.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Anlin Windows vs Andersen
Hi Dane and Tim,
I've enjoyed reading your web site. We have a 40 year old brick home in Dallas with the original aluminum two pane storm windows. We have gotten several quotes to replace the windows (21 total) with good quality vinyl. Typical of other buyers we have quotes from companies representing a variety of manufacturers having a wide range of prices. Seems like the industry has companies that will try to charge as much as possible and then offer discounts when you walk away.
Two have caught our attention that are not at the bottom or top end of the quotes are from Anlin, specifically the Catalina. Since many of our front windows are tall/narrow (24x72) we were planning on going with their expanded view style which has the uneven site lines but gives a little more glass.
We have a quote from two well rated dealers/installers. Company A is at $17,911 and company B at $19,538. Below is the detail from Company A, which uses employee installers vs contract installers. All are traditional sliding single hung or OX (except for a couple of pictures noted) with specs of U-factor: 0.27 / SHGC: 0.23, VLT: 0.54, and CondResist: 55.
Quantities and Sizes are:
7 at 24x72 ($407 ea)
2 at 18x72 picture ($416 ea)
1 at 36x13 ($320)
1 at 72x36 ($422)
2 at 24x72 ($407 ea)
1 at 72x36 (2 locks) ($504) (side of garage)
1 at 24x36 ($348)
1 at 72x72 2 wide by an exterior door ($620 + $415)
1 at 72x72 2 wide ($415 + $415)
3 at 36x96 ($460 ea)
1 at 24x36 obfuscated ($378)
Add Veratex trim at $1,295, Field Mulls for Kitchen $460, Installation $5,505 plus tax = $17,911.
The other option we have is a friend who is a home flipper and has purchased windows from a big box store (84 Lumber) and has used the same installer for all twenty jobs over the past 10 years. We have not had that installer come out yet, but our friend said the installer price should be at or under $200 per opening. That would put his install cost at $4,200 compared to Company A at $5,505. Our local 84 Lumber carries MI and Jeld Wen. Based on reading your site I think we'll stay away from MI and consider a good quality Jeld Wen.
Is there a Jeld Wen product that would compare favorably to the Anlin Catalina? Or is Anlin so much better that we're better off sticking with the Anlin dealer and their lifetime (double) warranty. We have not examined any contract from Company A yet that gives the specifics about the warranty but the salesman says it covers the installation, product defects, glass breakage ... pretty much everything. Note that Company A said the Catalina even site line version would be more expensive.
What would you suggest? How fair is the pricing from Company A?
Thanks.
David - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Hi David, so the Catalina is a good window, quite a bit better than anything Jeld Wen sells. The best big box product I've seen is the Andersen 100 composite window. I'm going to say that a 72x36 Andersen 100 will run you $350 as opposed to the $422 quote from the Anlin dealer. I think the Catalina is the better window over the Andersen 100 though, and think this bears out when you compare the numbers of the two.
While the Anlin is not exactly cheap, you are also getting some add ons that total $2K....still $16K for 21 windows isn't exactly cheap, but it's still probably the better deal long term. You would save probably $3.5K by going with the contractor, but you would have a slightly lower quality window.
For me, the Anlin pencils out if you are staying in the home long term. If not, then I'd go with a mid range Jeld Wen and the contractor.
Have you had a quote from an NT dealer on their Presidential series? I would say that that window is on par with the Anlin Catalina. I'd be curious to see how the window and installation costs compare here.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Anlin Windows Reviews Catalina Series
Dane – am having buyer's remorse as I think I'm overpaying for replacing my windows. I didn't do research first and I should have. The 7 windows and 2 sliders I'm replacing are as follows:
6' slider
7' slider
29 X 58 - two
70 X 57
34 X 57
82 X 59 – two
82 X 70
I have a quote for Anlin at $14,900 -- is this too high for Catalina infinity plus with argon gas? I have til 3/2/2020 to rescind the contract.
Susan - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Susan, if I assume that both the sliders together total $6K (so $3K each), that puts us at $8900. That puts each window at $1200 plus. Yes that's way too expensive on the face of it. I would rescind the contract for sure and then go out and get some more bids to see what they come in at. The bid might not be too high, but you're never going to know until you get additional bids.
My gut tells me its way too high and Anlin dealers have a tendency to bid high on their projects. I've seen very fair Anlin bids and others that were super high.
The other thing is that slider doors can vary in cost greatly based on whether the size door you need is standard or not. Different companies have different standard sizes so that's another place where three or four bids will let you see how much the slider door prices will vary.
To answer your other question, Anlin threatened to sue us if we posted a pricing page -- ironic since I'm a fan of their windows and doors and probably provide them with quite a lot of business :)
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
[Susan's Reply]
I'm in San Marcos, just north of San Diego California. I rather like Anlin; I've had Sierra Concepts (now deceased!) and Milgard. I was impressed with Anlin's spacer between the two panes - seemed like it would keep the argon better than the metal spacers a lot of other companies use. Susan
Susan - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Yes, Anlin is probably my favorite on the west coast, but I think that the economy and overall business of the window business is maximizing some of the bids that homeowners are seeing. In San Diego, I often recommend BM Windows which ironically sells Anlin -- they used to sell Amerimax, which I like quite a bit. They might still, try them.
Newman also has a solid reputation and sells Milgard, which aren't as good as Anlin but the new Trinsic is a decent window that's nice looking.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Anlin Catalina vs Del Mar
Hi Tim and Dave,
I hope all is well with both of you.
I’m in Sacramento, CA and I stumbled across your website when trying to research the difference of the two referenced window lines.
My tall entry door window broke some time ago and I'm finally getting around to it. Apparently not high on my priority list since this happened prior to July 4th! (I hate doing adult things!) I'm trying to decide if I want to bite the bullet and complete a whole house window replacement or just get the glass on the one window fixed.
My windows are original to the house, aluminum dual pane, from 1988! Yay!
I have received two bids from two different individuals/companies.
I am replacing 9 windows (1 - half moon shape, 1 - next to entry door and 1 - small bathroom) and 1 door slider. All are single sliders (where applicable).
The first gentleman, from Impressive Exteriors, gave me a quote of $10,327. He only offers the Catalina line. Informed me, he did sell the Del Mar line for a period of time but he started to hear from his customers of the ticking noise the bearings made and went back to selling the Catalina line. He told me sometimes the top isn't always the best. I did like the whisper quiet of the slide on the Catalina window. Two very good friends used this company and really like the work and the service they received, referred him to me. They primarily specialize in window and patio doors. They do siding as well but don’t really advertise it.
The second gentleman, from Northwest Exteriors, gave me the initial
uote of the following:
Del Mar Windows Cost - $9,431
Catalina Windows Cost - $8,725 (Though he informed me, they do not carry this particular line but could order it, if this is the window I REALLY wanted)
Bayview - $7,950 (Though I don't see it as one of the lines of window on the Anlin website)
He later told me he would give the Del Mar for the Catalina price, $8,725. As well as outfit all them the True Action Locks and sash dead bolts. I wasn't to thrill of the ticking noise on the Del Mar when I heard it. This company apparently does all sorts of things. From windows and siding to Solar and HVAC. My backdoor neighbor referred him to me. She is in the process of redoing her siding on her house. Which seems to be an ongoing project. She hasn’t had any siding on her house in at least 4-5 months. But that's another story.
Can you tell me, of the 3 different series, which would you recommend?
Is the Del Mar line really that much better? Especially if could come down in price so quickly and easily? Or is the difference between the two so slight that the two lines are interchangeable?
The quotes I received, is it in the right ball park?
At this point any new windows I receive would be better than what I currently have. Since my current windows are just horrible. So anything at this point is an upgrade! I’m ok with a mid grade window. I wouldn’t know the difference between a better and a great window. But any advice or information you can give me would be greatly appreciated.
I would like to thank you in advance for taking the time to read my long-winded email and look forward to your response.
Thank you and have a great day!
Jamie - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Jamie, the Del Mar has a few upgrades from the Catalina, but the Catalina is quite a nice window. If this were my project, I would go with the Catalina option. I would go black to the first company and tell them you have a bid on the Catalina at $8.7K. Tell him if he can come within $200 of his competitor that you’re ready to sign the work order. I’m not quite sure if he would go his low, but if he comes close, that’s where I would go, especially since he seems to have a solid reputation.
The Bayview is a lower end window from them and I think it makes more sense to go with the Catalina. I like the Del Mar series a lot, but it would give me pauses to pay more if installers are having issues with them.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Anlin Catalina Windows Cost
My wife and I are replacing 4 horizontal sliders and have a number of bids that are very close in price. Of the four below, do you have any that you would recommend?
Zen Nirvana Cost: $3090
Simonton 5500 Cost: $2870
Amerimax Craftsman Portrait Cot: $2860
Anlin Catalina Cost: $2795
Len - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Len, that Anlin Catalina quote looks tough to beat, that would be my recommendation.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
Anlin Windows Reviews Southern California
Hello, I have a window and door replacement project in Southern California. I am planning to replace 10 windows and 2 sliding door, sizes listed below. They are original aluminum in stucco. Thus far, I have been looking at Anlin and Milgard, but I am in need of unbiased recommendations on other manufacturers and lines to explore. The amount of manufacturers and specific lines that each sell is overwhelming! I am basically in the market for a good value vinyl window form a reputable manufacturer. Additionally, any input on the best caulking available that the installer should be using?
Sizes:
96" x 58" Double Vent
96" x 58" Double Vent or Half Vent
95" x 43" Double Vent or Half Vent
190" x 80" 4-Panel Slider Door
94" x 80" 2-Panel Slider Door
35" x 23" Half Vent
71" x 46" Half Vent
96" x 46" Double Vent or Half Vent
96" x 46" Double Vent or Half Vent
71" x 58" Half Vent
35" x 58" Picture Window
35" x 46" Double Hung
Current Bids:
Anlin Catalina (Sound Package Included) $12,000
Milgard Tuscany $13,900
Milgard Style Line Windows with Tuscany Doors $13,300
Thank you very much for any input that you can provide, it is sincerely appreciated!
Nate - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Nate, as far as I'm concerned Anlin is the best west coast manufacturer. The fact that your bid from them is lower than the Milgard means that's the best bid by far. Usually the Anlin bids are 15% to 25% more than the Milgard bids in my experience. The Catalina is a good series for windows and the Malibu is a good door.
In terms of other west coast options, Simonton always springs to mind. Ply Gem as well, but they aren't as good in my opinion as the Anlin. They may be worth getting a bid just to see where they fall price wise though.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
Anlin Windows Reviews Catalina/Coronado
Buying 18 double sliders and casements and 1 sliding door. I have received three bids. All three installers had very good reputations in the Denver area where I live. We three out the first bid because it was out of our price range. I was curious what you thought of the other two? Thanks,
Renewal: $42,000
Anlin Catalina/Coronado: $19,000
Sunrise Vanguard Sunrise: $19,000
Diane - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Diane, the Renewal quote is very high compared to the other two and you were probably right to toss it. Between the Anlin and Sunrise quotes, I'd have to opt for the Sunrise. Not by much, but the Sunrise Vanguard is a bit better than the Anlin Catalina in my opinion. Both very good products.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
[Diane's Reply]
I get it. I just wanted to make sure I'm not being taken advantage of. Being new to the window environment, it's nice to have people like you to bounce things off of and steer us in the right direction. I will be getting one more as per your suggestion. I had one rep tell me it was going to be over 2,000 a window. I thought the medics were going to have to be called(a little humor). I appreciate your knowledge and answers. Thank you!
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Diane, I totally understand and the $2K each is very instructive. Some companies will charge you what they think you will pay. The Sunrise and Anlin bids sound fair because they are so close in price. The Amerimax bid would show you (me) just how fair they are. There more bids, the more options and prices. Welcome to the world of windows -- it can be a bizarre place.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
Catalina Anlin Window Quote
Hello, I am hoping you can help me determine whether the quote I received today for doing 7 windows and 4 sliders for the Catalina Anlin is reasonable. I can see from the reviews the Catalina is a very good product. Here is what I have on the quote sheet:
Catalina XO: 72x48, 34x45, 45x34, 34x47, 70x46, 46x16, 46x16
Malibu PSD: 84x72, 96x96, 96x84, 96x84
The quote is for $24,160. I figured the sliders are quite large especially the one in the master at 96x96. I signed a contract but have a 3 day right to cancel. I am hoping I will hear from you soon.
Thanks for your help.
Lauri - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Hi Lauri, yes that sounds pretty pricey to me. Let's assume the Malibu sliders are $3000 each, which is on the upper end to be sure. (I would ask for a price breakdown on the sliders only to see the breakdown.)
That means that you are being charged $12,000 for 7 windows. Two of which are somewhat large, but the others look pretty standard sized. That seems way to expensive to me. Unless you have some serious work that needs to be done on the frames and sills. I obviously don't know the answer to this.
This is where two more quality bids will tell you what you need to know about the Anlin bid and give you a couple more options. Plus, you can take the bid(s) back to Anlin and tell them if they match the bid you will sign the work order that day. They might not come all the way down to the competitors bid, but I'll bet you'll see some downward movement on that price.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
Anlin Catalina Series vs. Jeld Wen v4500
I sure am glad I stumbled upon your site! I am in the process of getting new windows. I am between two companies one of which will be installing Jeld Wens and the other that will be installing Anlins. For the most part, the prices are comparable.
What would you do? It's for 7 single hungs. It's either the Jeld Wen v4500 or the Anlin Catalina series.
Allison - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Allison, this is an easy one -- the Anlin is a much stronger product than the Jeld Wen. Jeld Wen makes a good door and actually a good wood treated wood window, but their vinyl windows are not the best in the business. Anlin makes an excellent vinyl window and the Catalina series is one of their best. Go Anlin and good luck to you!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Anlin Catalina vs. Milgard Style Line
Hi, I live near Santa Cruz, CA and have two quotes from highly reviewed installation companies that vary considerably-- $8,000 between the two quotes. I'm trying to figure out if the window type is significantly different or what could be making that much of a quote difference. We have a lot of windows—28. Both were quotes for the entire house.
First, Angie's list didn't have anything listed that I saw on the freely available portion for any installation companies in this area. I'll be looking into buying a month of reviews to see what I can find. Yelp reviews average out to be essentially the same between the two companies.
The Milgard quote was $15,000 and was listed as Low E. Beyond that, I don't have any specifics on the type of Milgrad window. We would have to remove and reinstall all of our blinds (the house came with three different style of blinds throughout the house).
The Anlin quote was for the Catalina Infiniti and came in at $22,000. Removal and re-installation of the blinds is included in this quote.
From the research I've done I have a couple of questions/clarifications. In terms of the difference in quotes, my assumption (that I will clarify) is that the Milgrad quote was for a more basic window than the Catalina Anlin series. Is this a correct assumption?
It seems, again from CA research that there seems to be more buyers regret with Milgrad's customer service compared to Anlin.
I know it's a personal decision, but it just seems like the two quotes are significantly different and I'm trying to understand what may be causing that. Any help you can provide would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks!
Jenny - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Hi Jenny, you've done your research, which is great. I would say that Anlin makes the better window of the two companies, but I'm not quite sure its 8 grand better. Of course, it depends on which window from Milgard. I would recommend the Tuscany over the Style Line, which should run about 15% more. So let's say that puts the Milgard quote to $17,500 and a difference of $4,500. Now this makes for a tougher decision.
I would take both quotes and use this article to see how much lower you can get on both of them.
Negotiate A Window Bid
See what each one comes back at. I would put the difference maker at the $4,000 mark myself. However, I would also take a look at who is doing the installation and try to figure out what your gut tells you about which company you feel will do the better job. It does sound like both of the companies you have contacted offer good installation reviews though. (Awesome...)
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Milgard Tuscany Series vs. Anlin Catalina
First of all let me say thank you for such a wonderful and comprehensive website. My mother and I have been talking with so many different sales people with regards to new windows for our home and it's been quite a journey as we've received all kinds of quotes.
I've done a lot of research on not only manufacturers but also installers for our Southern California home and I think I've narrowed the choices down to two manufacturers, Milgard (Tuscany Series) vs Anlin (Catalina/Malibu Series). I wanted to take a moment to gather your thoughts on the quote. We were also pitched the Milgard Style Line series but we preferred the Tuscany for its features. Is the Catalina/Malibu series a good mid range quality comparable to the Tuscany series? Anlin also offered us the Bay View series but we were looking for something a bit greater quality of window. We are also trying to be conservative with how much we are spending as we are undergoing a huge home renovation. I'm just worried that by cost we might be sacrificing a lot in longevity quality.
We have a lot of windows in our home and some are large picture style that cover the entire wall of our living room. The Milgard quote we received seems quite high to me, and doesn't even include two smaller windows that would still need to be added to the quote.
What are you thoughts on these two quotes and also on the quality of each series. Personally I'm learning towards Anlin's Catalina/Malibu series.
Milgard Tuscany Series = 13 windows and 2 sliding glass doors for $18,795
Verses
Anilin Catalina / Malibu Series = 15 windows and 2 sliding glass doors for $13,380
I failed to also mention that both quotes included all taxes, parts, labor, haul-away, clean up, etc. However the Catalina series by Anlin also included screens for the windows which the Milgard company that quoted us did not include screens in their quote for the bedroom windows.
Jeremy - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Hi Jeremy, the Anlin Catalina/Malibu series is quite good and certainly a window I would have in my own home. I would say the Catalina is generally very close in quality and craftsmanship with the Tuscany series. I would also agree that the Tuscany quote is too high given the Anlin quote, which looks very fair to me. I think you are exactly right that the Anlin is the way to go.
I might go back to the Anlin dealer and throw out a number and see if he'll come down off his price a bit. I'm not sure he will, but it never hurts to ask. Here is an article with my take on the best approach to this process.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Anlin Catalina Windows Cost
A few weeks ago we signed up and got approved through the HERO program. They pointed us in the direction to a contractor that installed windows. The contractor (++++ Solar) came out and measured and quoted us for the Anlin Catalina system, 10 windows and 2 sliders = 23,000. After we signed the agreement with the window company, I decided to look around and get reviews on the window systems we were getting (I know strange to do it after the fact). I came across your site and saw a post by a consumer that said they had 22 Anlin windows installed and he paid 16,000 I think. Thats when I started panicking!
Long story short, I called the window company and pleaded with them to break my contract. Today I got your email and looked at the estimate price ranges for that same Anlin Catalina window system and you have it listed at $450-$475....+++++ Solar was going to charge us $2,000 per window! I'm beyond frustrated with that company!! Big corporations trying to take advantage of the consumer.
Again, thank you so much for this information and saving my sanity!!
Marc - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Marc, I hear this time and time again. If you are looking at Anlin, I assume you are on the West Coast. I would suggest getting a few bids and using these bids to get the best price. Companies I like include Anlin, as well as Amerimax, and Milgard. Simonton makes a couple good vinyl windows, but they are a step below the three I mentioned - their Reflections 5500 and their Impressions 9800 series are the Simonton models I'd recommend.
All three (Anlin, Amerimax and Milgard) should have local companies who service your area. Get the bids and let them know that you are in the process of collecting bids (nothing like competition to get their best price). This will also provide you an opportunity to see, feel, operate the different windows, which is nice since they are going to be in your home for the next 20 years.
Take your time and make sure you get the best price and best window for your home!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Anlin Windows Prices
As requested, below are 3 separate bids, from 3 different window replacement dealer/contractor:
Bid #1: Sears brand - $6,250 for (3)-6' wide & (1)-8' wide sliding window low-e. More Sears windows reviews.
Bid #2: PlyGem brand low-e3 - $3,000 for (5)-6' wide, (1)-8', & (1)-4' wide obscure/tempered bathroom window.
Bid #3: Anlin Catalina brand - $4,600 for (3)-6', (1)-8', & (1)-4' tempered/obscure - all sliding low-e.
Don - Homeowner - from 2015
[Site Editor's Response]
Don, I like your Anlin bid. The Catalina window is a good window. Seems kind of expensive though, make sure you negotiate the price to get it as low as possible.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2015
Anlin Windows Reviews :: Del Mar Series
The Del Mar series is a very solid vinyl window that is available on the west coast states. It uses a 2 and 7/8 inch frame depth, .80 inch frame thickness, equal sightlines, the Elite spacer, double strength glass and a single vent latch. It can be ordered in 14 exterior color options, 2 glass package options, 5 hardware options, 3 grid patters and 2 casing configurations. The Del Mar is Anlin's single hung and slider window, that can also be ordered in several geometric shapes as well.
The Del Mar series is an upgrade from the Catalina in the following ways: the Del Mar series has the Innergy thermal reinforcement, ultra-strong fiberglass thermal inserts to strengthen the sash and frame, and Comfort•Core—green foam injections into the window frames to maximize energy efficiency. Nice upgrades to be sure. I would give the Anlin Del Mar a out of 5 stars rating.
Dane - Site Editor
Anlin Del Mar Cost
Dane, we have a bid for the Winchester series from Quaker that was $725 per window installed. The other contender is the Anlin Del-Mar that was $790 per window installed. Which is the better pick do you reckon' - thanks so much!!!
Quaker Windows And Doors Reviews
Priscilla - Homeowner - from 2024
[Site Editor's Answer]
Priscilla, I think the Del Mar is the better pick here. Both good options, but I like Anlin other Quaker in vinyl.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2024
Anlin Del Mar E Series
Thanks again Dane for all of your help. One more question for you - I got the Anlin Del Mar Expanded series with the narrow profile frame (vs. the Del Mar series with the traditional profile frame).
I asked the sales guy if the Expanded series windows are not as strong (due to the decreased size) but he said there is no strength difference between the two series. Do you agree with that? I want a strong(er) frame so if the Del Mar series is stronger I rather go with that.
Also, with regards to fiberglass reinforcement what I gathered from my own research is that the fiberglass reinforcement is not in the outside frame itself; just only where either the sliding or the double hung window meets the non-moving part. In other words, a picture window won't contain any fiberglass reinforcement. Would you agree with that?
Tamas - Homeowner - from 2024
[Site Editor's Answer]
Tamas, by definition a more narrow profile would mean the unit is not as strong (unless they are using some type of internal reinforcement). However, it really shouldn't be an issue unless you have large openings, then I would have some concerns.
Yes, the fiberglass reinforcement is in the lift rail - so no it would not be present in a fixed frame window.
Anlin makes a strong frame in general, using a titanium dioxide in the vinyl to strengthen the extrusions.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2024
Anlin Del Mar Window Prices
Looking at replacing 28 windows, including some custom openings and several arched top window opening.
NT Executive Series: $25K
Anlin Panoramic Series: $28K
Anlin Catalina Series: $31K
Anlin Del Mar Series: $37K
Renewal by Anderson Series: $92K
Erica - Homeowner - from 2024
Anlin Windows Reviews
Dane, thanks for all of your help. I sourced quotes for a few additional window companies with the focus of finding vinyl options from your "replacement windows Texas list". Surprisingly, I was only successful in finding vinyl options in my Zip code for the NT Exec and Anlin Del Mar.
A summary table is below including some options that did not make it on your list. I specifically wanted to ask you about the quality of the Burris and Vistamark options below, as I found those contractors to have a higher reputation for installation quality and I liked their price point of around $30-35k for 37 replacement windows. My approach right now is to assign value equally between parts and labor.
Finally, as part of the replacement window project I am hoping to maintain as much of a glass opening as possible. I have quite a few 12" height transom windows for which I don't want the glass opening to reduce too much. In my attempt to compare the "sample windows" in person, it seemed difficult to assess the width of the vinyl jamb.
In one example the Del Mar appeared skinny in its jamb width and then the next contractor's sample of the same Del Mar appears slightly different with a thicker jamb width. The difference was notable enough that I am unsure if they are both truly the same Del Mar frame. In the same discussion, the NT Executive seemed to have the widest jamb width when comparing to the other samples. Do you have any insight or recommendations in this regard?
Company 1 Apex Insignia $46,100
Company 2 Window World 4000 Series DH $22,759
Company 3 Burris Tectview AC $30,689
Company 3 Vistamark Endura Series 110 $35,995
Company 4 NT Executive Series 100 $40,037
Company 4 Del Mar $38,338
Company 5 NT Executive Series 100 $35,200
Company 5 Vistmark Endura Series 100 $31,200
Company 6 Del Mar $40,000
Corey - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Corey, not cheap those bids. I feel like the Del Mar for $38,338 and then the NT Executive Series for $35,200 are the best overall values, although the Tectview AC at $30,689 is a pretty solid move as well. If company three had sterling reviews, I might be inclined to go this route.
I think your timeline in the home would also factor into the decision. Forever home, I'd probably put in the Del Mar, 12 years or less, I might go Burris and save the $8K.
I hear you with the glass area -- consumers often ask me to make these comparisons, but I don't have their glass area measurements memorized. I just don't - if this is a major concern, could you go back to the two Anlin reps and ask about the Panoramic series - you will take a hit on the performance, but you will get more glass area. My recollection of the NT Executive is the same as yours, pretty thick frame... (NT Windows Reviews)
You couldn't find a Sunrise dealer? Their Restorations series has a thin frame but still maintains excellent performance data. I would think it would run as much as the Apex Insignia though...
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Anlin Northwest Exteriors Reviews
New update on my bids, today I had a company named Northwest Exteriors in Rancho Cordova, CA give me a quote for the Anlin Del Mar series (6units) and 2 Anlin Malibu series glass sliding doors. Financing it would be about 13.5k and straight cash would be about 12.2k. What are your thoughts on this quote given to me?
Anlin Del Mar Windows Prices: $13.5K ($12.2k cash price)
Marcos - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Marcos, Northwest Exteriors seems to get good reviews and that's a pretty fair price for 6 windows and 2 sliding glass doors. The cash price is a good option -- if you have cash sitting around :)
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Anlin Del Mar vs. Milgard Trinsic In Arizona
Dane was hoping you could send me your list of good/ great brands and options in Arizona. I think I've zeroed in on anlin del Mar - have also looked at Milgard trinsic and window world (quite a difference - quality and price across the 3)...
Just making sure there is something I haven't missed. Thank you!
Steve - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Steve, the Anlin Del Mar is probably your best option if you can handle the cost. The Milgard Trinsic would be another solid option...I'll send you my recs.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Anlin Windows vs Marvin
Hello Dane, I'm looking at replacing windows on the southside, second floor which involves time and expense in scaffolding, and takes a beating from hot sun (Los Angeles), rain and wind.
Wondering if you know of Anlin's history for problems after the 10 year or so marker? I googled for that and came up with very little but maybe I didn't google the right words.
Googling Marvin Elevate, i saw a number of complaints right after the ten yr warranty expired. I certainly like the look of the Elevate wood interiors but I'd rather have a window last 20 yrs or more, and not have to pay for scaffolding and replacement in ten years.
Would you suggest the DM as a better choice for problem-free longevity as their lifetime warranty suggests? I think I could probably put up with the interior DM look in exchange for no problems with the exterior. (More Anlin Del Mar Windows reviews here.)
Also, I see that Anlin used to market their windows as Apex Xtreme. Sometimes when a company changes their marketing name, it means they had troubles under that name. Do you know anything here?
Anlin's reviews are so good, it raises my suspicions!
Thanks for all your informative and specific, unbiased reviews.
Freda - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Freda, if it were my project, I would go with the Anlin Del Mar. Statistically, they will last longer than the Marvin in my opinion. Anlin has been in business since 1990 and have weathered quite a few economic downturns -- they are a solid manufacturer in my opinion. Anlin makes windows and markets them under some different names and I believe this is what Apex Extreme. They do the same thing in Hawaii and give it a Hawaiian sounding name -- not that uncommon in the window business...
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Windows Reviews At Altitude
Hi Dane, thanks for your response to my window inquiry. We are considering the Anlin Del Mar window which you mentioned. That fits best with our budget. We got 4 bids for 4 different brands ranging from $14,000 to $22,000 for 12 windows with the Anlin at $15,000.
We don't really need the crème de la crème in windows, but we want something good and durable that's affordable. All the sales pitches seem to derate vinyl and push for some more expensive materials such as fiberglass. What is your perspective regarding vinyl for Colorado at 6,000 ft elevation?
I would appreciate your thoughts on this.
Don - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Don, I just did a video on this exact subject if you want to take a listen -- and could you click the subscribe button??? -- this really helps me out!!!
6 Quality Vinly Windows
Anlin at 6000 feet is gonna be just fine :)
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Anlin Del Mar Infinite Plus Price Quote
Hi Dane, I recently got a quote for 28 windows (12 picture windows, 11 single hung, 1 awning, and 4 horizontal sliders single hung) to be replaced with anlin del Mar infinite plus with argon gas and the sound package for 41,500 and I just wanted to know your opinion on if that is good pricing? It will be replacing aluminum double pane single hungs from the 1990s. Most of them are standard sized windows but I do have 3 rather large ones that are arched; one is staying a picture window and the other two are being turned into each having two single hungs with an arch (i counted these as 1 picture window and 4 single hungs in my first sentence). I am in the Dallas tx area.
Thank you!
Julia - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Julia, I really like Del Mar from Anlin windows, but that seems like a heavy price tag to me -- anything over $1K per window I always suggest that you consider getting a few more bids to compare. You very well might save thousands of dollars and get just as good a window (or close).
[Email dane@replacementwindowsreviews.co for his recommendations]
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Del Mar Cost With Tempered Glass
Dane, we are replacing 13 windows in our house and have decided to aim at the Anlin. We are replacing 10 single hung Del Mar tempered glass four of which an eyebrow top, and 3 XO and the quote is $22,750 installed. This has seemed competitive with the Anderson quote we received and better than the first Anlin quote we received but it still seems like a lot for what we are getting. Does the price seem fair?
Jonathan - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Jonathan, it seems expensive to me unless you are doing full frame installation -- is that the case, then I'd say that's a fair quote given today's prices. If so, I'd say that quote is fair. I'm happy to send along my recommended windows list if you are interested and wish to broaden your options.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Del Mar Bid In Los Angeles
Like others, I discovered your site as I searched for information on our window replacement project. We have a two story home in greater L.A. area, but inland so it's pretty hot in the summer, with 85-95 degree days.
We are replacing 16 sliders, two sliding glass doors and 6 atrium large panes.
Anlin Del Mar series is only available from one vendor here in an exclusive. Cost roughly 34K.
Other vendor offered the Simonton Daylight Max at 31K but is also an Anlin dealer. He also suggested the Panoramic series with Malibu doors at 30K.
I've seen your posts that the larger glass window may lose some energy efficiency. Is it significant? Our downstairs is freezing in winter and the upstairs way hot in summer. Should we be considering the Coronado line instead? Or doing some upgrade to another glass? I'm not sure how much we care about the larger pane size, smaller frame.
Thanks so much for your help with this big, confusing project!
Happy Holidays!
Sheldon - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Hi Sheldon. Man that is a pricey bid for the Anlin Del Mar, and not much less for the Panoramic series. Have you looked for an Amerimax dealer -- there might be one that services your area and they make quite a nice window. What about a Monte Verde dealer -- this is Anlin again and a more entry level series, but the price could be quite a bit lower (maybe). The other option might be a Milgard Trinsic -- not as good, but a pretty solid performer -- might be nice to at least see what the bids come in at...
Glass in general is not a good insulator so the larger the glass area, the less energy efficient it tends to be. Having said that, window glass for the home has come a long way in the past 30 years with the special coatings they use to let in light but repel UV rays. I think an upgrade to a better glass package is the way to go. Ask each company that comes out for their recommendations and options -- grill them on which of the glass options is right for each large window. Hopefully if you get three more bids, then you will also get a good handle on what your best option is on the glass.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Windows vs Milgard
I am currently perusing bids for 3 single hungs with sound proofing packages
I have got bids for both Anlin Delmar and Milgarg Tuscany
Both bid are virtually identical
I’m basing this on the 2 pane system with the inner pane thicker than the outside pane and argon gas fill and ungraded seals
Do you have any knowledge as to whose sound package is better.
Thanks .
Kurt - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Kurt, I honestly don't know the answer to which manufacturer's sound package is better. I will say this, the Anlin Del Mar is the superior window to the Milgard Tuscany. I would also think that the Anlin sound package would be superior to the Milgard Tuscany by the simple fact that the window has tighter fit and tolerance. Overall, it's a better put together window so that would certainly be a part of noise reduction. Beyond this, I have to plead the 5th.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Del Mar Windows Reviews
Hello! Great site you have! Today I received a bid in Phoenix for 9 windows and 1 standard slider for Anlin/Del Mar windows. This includes 238 square feet and 198 perimeter feet. Window models are half round above half vent-2 slider round too-2 half round permanent 3 sliders. Obscured picture window and 1 sliding door two panel.
Quoted for $19890 with 40% off sale $11,934 and cash $10,940. What do you think of these prices? Thanks!
Leslie - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Leslie, that price is okay, toward the top of the range of what I would expect. Prices have been pretty crazy as of late with the increased demand for home improvement projects. You might want to get another bid on say the Milgard Tuscany. You can always use the lower cost of the Milgard bid to see if the Anlin rep will lower his price. Also see if there is an Amerimax dealer in your area. Your call of course...
Tim - Site Editor - from 2021
Anlin Windows Reviews In New Mexico
Hi Dane and Tim, I’ve looked at about 7 or 8 window companies. I don’t know if that’s a good thing or if it has caused more confusion. I have several questions.
1. What is your opinion on spacers? Are foam spacers best? I’m under the impression that the mylar foam spacers are higher performers. However, Simonton and Window World both use Intercept spacers, with aluminum U-shaped pieces in between the windows. I thought that was outdated but they are still being used. We have 10-year old, double-hung Simonton windows that came with our house 7 years ago, with this type of seal, and they are still working splendidly, with no seal failures. The windows are a bit stiff going up and down, but I just learned that the weather seals need to be vacuumed occasionally (live and learn), and they could use some Teflon spray on the sides.
Anlin Del Mar uses the Platinum Elite, which is foam with dessicant inside. They recently switched from mylar-backed foam spacers, about a year ago, and that makes me wonder if they had too many problems with seal failure, and thus condensation, so they needed something to absorb the minimal condensation, in order to fake a perfect seal. (I’m becoming skeptical of all claims that say, “We have the best window on the market. Our seals will never fail.”)
Amerimax uses TrueWarm, which is foam only.
So in your experience, which have you seen to be best?
2. I know you’ve given sufficient reviews on Anlin and Amerimax, but I’m stuck. I’m most impressed with Anlin Del and all its features, but what troubles me is that they’re not made in the same altitude as Albuquerque, NM (and they have that dessicant-filled spacer that is suspicious to me).
I like the idea that Amerimax is manufactured in an altitude similar to mine and has the mylar-backed foam spacer. However, Amerimax doesn’t offer a patio door to meet my needs. I want a sliding glass door with a fixed panel that is removable. The opening is smaller than the standard sliding glass door space, and only one removable door makes it smaller than your standard front door opening, which would be about 30”, so it would make it difficult to move furniture in and out the door.
Nor does Amerimax have as many great features as the Anlin Del Mar product (thicker glass [better sound-reduction]; sashes reinforced with fiber glass; amazing, heavy duty screens; passes forced-entry tests). Their pricing is very close in comparison, but it seems like you get more bang for your buck with Anlin Del Mar. I thought about buying windows from Amerimax and a door from the Anlin dealer, but then the prices go up for each company. The other problem is that the Anlin dealer has to sell a ProVia door with the removable fixed panel.
If I knew that the ProVia door and the Anlin Del Mar were ok in our altitude, I might just decide on them and go with one dealer. Anlin has already made it clear that they will not be adding capillary or breather tubes because they don’t install them unless the destination is 6000 ft or higher in elevation. Anlin is manufactured in Clovis, California, at 361’ and Rio Rancho, NM is 5290’. We’re pretty close to 6000 feet. The dealer has only been selling Anlin for 6 months and their reviews are very good. ProVia Doors Reviews
3. With all that said, as far as you know, do Anlin windows truly hold up to our altitude, without too much bowing? Or is Amerimax best? I have heard of Denver-made windows bowing out in Albuquerque.
I appreciate your thoughts. Thanks for helping folks like me who have trouble making big-spending decisions about windows.
Catherine - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Catherine, I wouldn't put too much stock in the spacer question. Most window manufacturers offer ‘warm-edge’ spacers that are made from composite materials. The Intercept is a decent spacer and the Anlin spacer is good as well. The spacer shouldn't contribute to seal failure, that is more a function of the overall construction of the IGU.
The altitude issue is something to definitely consider. My issue is that I don't know enough about it to weigh in with too much authority. I agree with you about Amerimax manufacturing at altitude and therefore having a solid understanding of how that affects the windows. I am going to give you this link to a forum run by very knowledgeable installers that talks about this issue.
I will say this, ProVia makes an excellent door and Anlin makes a very good window. I would probably order the windows without an argon gas, which can have issues at altitude. If you do want to go with Anlin, ask for some references from other consumers in the area.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Anlin Del Mar Windows
Hi Dane or Tim, I’m in Mesa, Arizona and have just received a bid for 22 Anlin Del Mar Windows for @29,116 (after $6,500 in discounts).
5 x single hung
11 x XO sliders of various sizes (23 x 11 to 7` x 47)
2 x Octagonal (36 x 36)
3 x Single Hung (36 x 48)
1 x XOX. (71 x 59)
3. x Picture Window. 2@ 17 x 59 and 1 @ 84 x 59)
The install is a bit more complex as they have to cut into the current wood trim about 1” on each window to account for the larger Del Mar frame (current frames are aluminum). I do like the company and the installers have an excellent reputation.
Can you give your opinion on whether this quote reasonable.
Thanks in advance for your opinion.
Steve - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Steve, sounds about right. Have you looked at the Milgard Trinsic, it's a thinner frame and might cut way down on your installation price. You might also find a Simonton dealer and inquire about the Reflections 5500 series. Quite a nice window, not as good as the Del Mar, but it might provide some interesting comparisons to your current bid.
I just think you might want to see what else is out there before you pull the trigger on the Del Mar.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Anlin Del Mar vs Coronado
Hi Tim, Just found your site. Thanks for the useful insight and information.
I am looking at Anlin Panoramic Windows and Milgard Trinsic. Having read your feedback, I’m fairly certain you prefer the Anlin.
However, I have a few detail questions about Anlin.
First, I am somewhat confused about which Anlin series to go with. In general, I’m trying to maximize the light I have, so Panaormaic would seem to make sense. However, this issue of uneven sight lines is something on mind. Should I be worried about that? And is that a reason to veer toward Del Mar? My guy didn’t even mention Del Mar. Also— are the Del Mar and Catalana comparable in terms of gass size?
Second - do you have an opinion about the glass itself? Anlin guy is suggesting blue tinted Graymax LowE for hottest sections and regular green tinted low e for cooler? Again, I’m concerned about how much Gray max will cut the light — and will it look weird having two different color windows?
Third— The Millard guys never mentioned anything about a tint or light chance with their max Low E glass. Does this mean Milgard glass is better in terms of the light in lets in?
Fourth - iff Anlin has double lifetime warranty— why do you prefer Del Mar for durability over panoramic ? Since both can be repaired no problem if there is need?
Thank you so much. I hope I’m not all too all over the place.
Ted - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Ted, thanks for the questions, I'll try to address each one in turn.
I like the Anlin Del Mar the most, but I actually think all of their window lines are quite well made. Totally get the desire to go with the Panorama, which provides more glass area and slightly less energy efficiency. That's the trade off. Uneven sight lines are an aesthetic consideration and therefore completely personal preference. The Del Mar and Catalina are the same in terms of amount of glass.
The Del Mar series is an upgrade from the Catalina in the following ways: the Del Mar series has the Innergy thermal reinforcement, fiberglass thermal inserts, and Comfort•Core, which are injections in the frame to maximize energy efficiency.
The glass is also a bit of an aesthetic consideration as well. Some consumers are bugged by the darker tint of an upgraded low e glass. I would see if you can physically view the different glass options before you purchase. The dealer should have something to show you so that you can make the determination if the darker color bothers you or not.
I don't think you will notice the two different glass colors unless they are side-by-side, but again some people are very picky about this. I tend to think a good quality low-e is a just fine for most homes, unless you are in a very hot climate and really need to keep that heat out of the house in the summer months.
Milgard offers a number of glass packages and the same basic principles apply; namely, the more coatings you have, the better it reflects heat, and the darker the glass. Again with the trade offs...
Warranty on labor typically only lasts for a couple of years so say eight years down the road something goes wrong with a window and you call up the dealer and he agrees to come out and switch out the window, he is still going to charge you for the labor, which is typically 35% of the cost. So if the cost of a window and installation is $650, then you are on the hook for $227.
I think the Del Mar is a better window over the Panorama in terms of energy efficiency and upgrades, but not in terms of how long it will last. I think you are better off with Anlin over Milgard because it is a better made window.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
[Tim's Reply]
Tim, thank you so much for this response. Very cool of you. I think i will go with the Anlin - and just see which glass/model i like best. The bids I got for trinsic and panorama were almost exactly the same by the way - 17k 24 windows.
Ted - Homeowner - from 2020
Anlin Del Mar vs. Simonton
Dane , We're in the process of getting bids for replacing 14 windows in our 1995 home ( replacing viking windows which have all failed). One bid from Northwest suggested Anlin Del Mar series for a total cost of $11,560 and Brothers Home improvement carry’s Simonton, but was really promoting their brand made by Lindsay windows for $10,832 . What are your thoughts ?
Thanks.
Mark - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Mark, if the price difference is $700, the Anlin Del Mar is definitely the way to go. The Del Mar is a better option over anything that Simonton carries, as well as Lindsay windows. The Del Mar series is a solid product.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Anlin Del Mar Retro Price Quote
Anlin Del Mar Retro Replacement window
8 single slider, 4 single hung, 1 small shower slider, 2 small bedroom windows that don't open and sliding glass door (5 ft). CAT Exterior quote $23744.00. This seems to be quite expensive
Eva - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Eva, super expensive, keep collecting some more quotes. What city, state are you located?
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Anlin Del Mar vs. Pella Encompass Series
Hi Dane,
Thanks in advance for the website. I am looking for some professional advice on our home window replacement.
We are currently considering 2 different brands.
The Pella Encompass Series & the Anlin Del Mar Series. We live in north Texas (just north of Dallas). Our house has 38 windows. The quote from Anlin Del Mar installer is below. The Pella quote is at $52k, but financing is at 5 year loan “zero %”. Both quotes include tempering of backyard windows (about 12 windows upper and lower sash).
The Anlin Del Mar quote is at $46,968
What do you consider to be the best choice. Thanks so much!
John - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
John, the Encompass is a poorly made window in my opinion. The Anlin Del Mar is the MUCH better window head to head. A very solid offering. I wouldn't even consider putting an Encompass in my house.
I will say this: both of those bids seem high to me for 38 windows and adding tempered glass to 12 windows, but that's just off the top of my head.
I would suggest you get two more bids: one from an NT dealer on the Presidential or Energy Masters series, and one from a Sunrise dealer on their Standard window. Maybe even another from your local Zen dealer (who should sell Soft-Lite windows, although some sell Alside. Soft-Lite's are good, Alside are really not.)
I'd be interested to see how these bids compare. I think you can get a comparable window for less money than the Anlin bid.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Anlin Windows in Phoenix
Afternoon Dane, I live in Phoenix, Arizona area and have 27 windows of various sizes and shapes, in addition to 2 sliders.
I received quotes from Anlin and Anderson. Definitely about $40,000 price difference due to materials used and other factors. Anlin is primarily distributed on the West Coast. I am looking at the Del Mar Series for Anlin and wanted to know if there are issues with the vinyl in the Arizona heat over time. Any thoughts into long term viability of Milgard in this heat environment.
My plan is to be in this home for 20 yrs or so given I am now retired. Appreciate your thoughts……and direction. Thank you
Denise - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Denise, a high quality vinyl window should weather the Arizona heat well. A poor quality vinyl window can have issues over time. Anlin is probably the best vinyl window available on the West Coast. Better than Milgard in my opinion. The Del Mar series is quite good.
Milgard is still one of the better options out West. Either of these options should serve you well. Personally, I would opt for the Anlin if the price difference isn’t outrageous.
Obviously, the Andersen bid was very high. I would rather have a well made vinyl window in that heat than a wood clad window myself. Wood is an organiz material that swells and contracts with temperature changes and the desert certainly has lots of that temperature variation.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Anlin Del Mar Prices
Hi Tim, just finished getting bids for 21 windows. The two bids I'm considering are the Anlin Del Mar for $15,988 and the Milgard Tuscany for $13,300. Are these two windows comparable and should they be closer in price?
In your opinion which window is better?
Thanks.
Dale - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Hi Dale, so the Anlin Del Mar is the better of the two windows. Is it $3K better? Maybe, that's about the price split I would have expected. Here's how I usually make this determination: if you are going to stay in the house 10 years or less, then go with the Milgard Tuscany. A good mid range vinyl window. If you are going to stay in the house 10 years or longer, then go with the Anlin Del Mar.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Anlin Del Mar Quote
Hello, I'm replacing 3 windows with Anlin Del Mar windows.
XO slider: $1,350
Single Hung: $1,050 each
Double Hung at $1,078 each
XO slider, 2 single hungs: $3,450
Tom - Homeowner - from 2020
Anlin Del Mar Windows Bid
Hi Tom, Can you tell me your thoughts on a bid I got from Anlin distributor for 13 windows Del Mar (4-O’s and 9 XO’s) vary sizes) and a sliding door?$15,645.
Aisha - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Aisha, at first glance that strikes me as a high bid. That doesn't mean it isn't fair, but I say get some more bids to compare it to. On the west coast, I'd look for local window companies who sell Milgard windows, a high quality Simonton, Amerimax, and Ply Gem window. These are all solid vinyl window manufacturers. Anlin is my favorite on the west coast, but their bids can go pretty darn high sometimes. More bids will tell you whether this is fair or not.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Anlin Delmar Quote
Dane, we are in midst of replacing about 40 windows of various sizes in the house. About 11 of them are going to be new replacement and the rest are going to be retrofit.
Anlin Delmar was quoted at 38k
Milgard Tuscany all retrofit was quoted at 35k
Simonton Daylight Max 47k for 18 new replacement and rest retrofit.
All installers have a very high Yelp rating. I am leaning towards Anlin Delmar even though it is 3k more than Milgard Tuscany. What are you thoughts on the various window manufactures listed above?
Rushil - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Rushil, of the bids you have, yes the Anlin Delmar sounds like the best of the bunch. The Delmar is a much better window in my opinion than both the Tuscany and the Daylight Max. A very good vinyl window and it sounds like you have a high quality installer. That's a great combination!
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
[Rushil's Reply]
Dane, I want to thank you for a very quick response. Until I accidentally stumbled upon your website, I was sold on getting Milgard Tuscany, as I had not heard of Anlin window systems. The Yelp review for Anlin was 5/5 for their after sale services and honouring the warranty while Milgard and Simonton averaged around 2.5... Does the $37k seems reasonable for 38 Delmar windows( 11 of the windows are New Replacements and the rest are Retrofit).
Again Thank you for your time...
Rushil - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Rushil, it sounds pretty high to me, but because the other bids were right around that same price, I'm inclined to think this is a fair market price. The only other thing you could do is to get a quote on say the Simonton 5500 from an independent Simonton dealer. This is a very good window and I believe would be a nice comparison quote to the others you have.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
Anlin Delmar Series Windows
Hi Tom, I live in San Jose, ca and recently got a quote for Anlin Delmar series windows for my home. It’s for 9 sliders, 3 double hung and 1 French door with sidelights. This also includes 4 cut downs on 4 windows, making them bigger top to bottom. The quote is for 11,800. What are your thoughts? Appreciate the input.
Ameen - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Ameen, that's a pretty fair price for the door, windows, and the framing work on the four windows. Anlin makes a very good window, the best on the west coast as far as I'm concerned.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
Anlin Del Mar Bid
Hello Dane and Tim, I came upon your site and I would like to get your opinion on the two quotes I received. I live in San Diego in a 2 bedroom condo. My current windows are fine but it's the original single pane window that they installed when they built the condo in 1986.
Since I just had a new flooring done, I thought it would be a good idea to upgrade the windows as well. My place doesn't really get too cold or too hot but the recent winter had required my elderly mom to have the heater running through the night. I have no complaints on the level of noise. It's not by a main street.
I have a total of 5 windows and a sliding door (8 feet sliding door), so total 6 windows.
I got 3 quotes. Once for a Pela 250 from Lowes, one for Anlin Del Mar for the windows and the Malibu for the sliding door with a local installer and another from a local installer that says their product is similar to the Simonton Madiera or Daylight Max, their product name has different name.
I'm deciding on the Anlin Del Mar and Malibu vs the the Simonton Madiera/Daylight Max.
Anlin Del Mar is $5,968 in total project which includes labor and materials and disposal of old materials.
Simonton Madiera/Daylight Max is $4,718 total project which includes labor and materials and disposal of old materials.
Right now I'm trying to get the sales guy for the Anlin to come down closer to the Simonton. Would you put the Anlin and Simonton the same category or family? I'm wondering because of the price range but based on what they told me, seems like they have same features and benefit. One of my neighbor had the same installer as the Anlin but she doesn't remember the manufacture of the windows that she got but happy with the install and the product. My other neighbor got their windows from the installer for the Simonton. Both of these neighbors are happy with their windows and installer.
Right now I'm leaning towards the Anlin because of what the salesman showed me. The Anlin screen frame seems sturdier than the Simonton and the whole product seems better but that's because of what the salesman for the Anlin showed me. I would like your opinion of which is better for me and bang for my bucks.
Christina - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Hi Christina, so I would put the Simonon Daylight Max below the Anlin Del Mar in terms of quality. Some of the upper echelon windows from Simonton are on par with the Anlin Del Mar, but not the Daylight Max. So I would say the Anlin is definitely worth the extra money over the Simonton.
However, the Simonton Daylight Max is a decent mid range vinyl window and probably fine for San Diego. If I were staying in the home long term, I personally would spend the extra money on the Anlin. If I were not sure about how long I was going to stay, I'd probably opt for the Simonton. Of course, the quality and reputation of the installer would play a big role in my decision.
I would still try to get the Anlin dealer to match the Simonton quote. I don't think he would come down that far, but I would see how low I could get him to go.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
[Christina's Reply]
Thank you so much for the quick response! As of now, I do intend to stay in the condo for the unforeseeable future but never know what the future holds. I do like the Del Mar better.
Right now the offer is for $5,626 (~$300 lower) for Del Mar windows and Malibu patio door. He also offering the BAYVIEW by MONTEVERDE for $4,700 (price match to the Daylight) for Bayview windows and patio door or $4,999 for Bayview windows and Malibu patio door. The warranty on the Del Mar is definitely the best of the 3 options.
The installer for the Anlin and the Monteverde is the same company that my neighbor had her windows installed over 5 years ago and she's happy with them and no problem so far. So that's why I'm leaning towards this installer.
What do you think about the Bayview? Is the price good for them and quality? He said that these are the best prices for them (Del Mar and Bayview). I'm sitting out for a while longer and see if he would come back lower :) I have 30 days to think about it.
Thank you in advance!
Christina - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Hi Christina, the Bayview is the company's drop down window. I think the Del Mar option is worth $627 more, especially since you are staying in the condo for awhile going forward.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
Anlin Del Mar vs. Simonton Daylight Max
Dane and Tim, first, of all thank you for the work you do and the website. So here goes… This is my second home and first time window shopping. I have boiled down what I think are the “value/mid grade” windows I can replace my 20 year old dual pane windows with. I have gotten a few estimates from local highly rated installers who I trust will be able to do the job.
We live in Phoenix in a two story wood frame stucco exterior home, our major issues are heat and sun. Our master bedroom has a big 108/60 XOX. The window faces south and allows a lot of heat/sun light into the room 365. It gets direct sun from morning to night. In the summer at 10pm the master bedroom is 5-7 degrees higher temp than the rest of the house with the AC running.
Should we invest in higher energy rated windows for this room only and pull back on the energy ratings on the rest of the home with natural shade or use the same energy rating for entire home (all installers are recommending this of course)? Right now the est for all new windows are energy star rated for the Phoenix zone.
In no order of preference (No upgraded hardware or colors). 14 windows. A combo or sliders, single hung, and picture and 1 sliding glass door. These are the total prices tax, install, clean up…
Simonton Daylight Max: $9300, retrofit
Amerimax Craftsman Portrait: $13,000, full pull out and replacement
Anlin Del Mar: $13,000 if we buy right now or $17,250 later, retrofit
Ply Gem Pro: (budget play) $8700, retrofit
What would you recommend?
Michael - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Michael, I would suggest the only change you make for the XOX window is to upgrade the glass to minimize the amount of heat that enters. Basically the glass package that has the lowest SHGC. Talk to the sales guys who gave you the bid and see if the window brand you end up going with has something that can reduce down the heat that enters through that window. You might have to combine that with shudders etc. to keep the heat manageable.
I would rate the Anlin Del Mar as the best of the windows, followed by the Amerimax Craftsman Portrait. No surprise there since they are the most expensive of the bids. I'd put the Simonton Daylight Max next, followed by the Ply Gem Pro. Again, in order of the bids you have so I'm not sure that helps.
If it were me, I'd probably stick with the Anlin or Amerimax, but whether or not to do the full replacement or retrofit is tricky. It sounds like most of them are suggesting the retrofit option. If that's the case, I might stick with the Anlin. Incidentally, I like the air infiltration numbers on the Daylight Max casements and fixed frames, but not so much on the sliders and single hangs.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Anlin Del Mar vs. Milguard
I'm in the process of buying 13 windows in the Los Angeles area. I received some original bids, but here is an update:
Company #1 lowered Anlin Catalina price from $7,900 to $7,450
Company #2 lowered Anlin Mar Vista price from $8,277.28 to $7,984 (they give you Del Mar for price of Catalina).
I kinda of like company #1 better. Is there really a big difference between the Catalina and Del Mar?
Would love to get your opinion before I pull the trigger today or tomorrow.
Tracy - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Tracy, the Del Mar does have some nice upgrades. However, for Southern California I think the Catalina is a good window, especially if you like the company better and feel like they will do a beter install. That was a nice price drop too. I would trust your gut and go with the company you feel most comfortable with, especially since they are selling the same brand to you.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Anlin Del Mar vs. Amerimax ProMax8
I live in Southern California, in the Thousand Oaks area. We are looking to replace 18 single pane windows and trying to decide between two brands for retrofit vinyl windows: Amerimax ProMax8 and Anlin, Del Mar. Both manufactures offer these upgraded packages (ProMax8 and Del Mar), to our local companies because they are large dealers of these windows. Both windows offer a double life time warranty (ProMax is a $75 cost to second owner), argon gas between panes of glass, foam spacers, and a sound reduction package. They have similar U-factors and SHGC energy ratings.
Do you prefer one brand over the other? If so, why and what are the differences to consider, if any?
We have checked out the companies that carry these two retrofit windows and each have excellent reputations for professional quality installation. In our research we have discovered that vinyl windows are similar, but the most important aspect is quality installation. I appreciate that you know the different manufacturers of vinyl retrofit windows and what each one has to offer. With so many great choices I am just glad we have narrowed our decision down to these two manufacturers.
Thank you and looking forward to your reply,
Cheryl - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Cheryl, I've never heard of the ProMax8 from Amerimax so I will have a tough time making a judgement on it specifically. The Anlin Del Mar is quite a nice vinyl window and I might give the nod to Anlin over Amerimax in an apples-to-apples comparison.
You might try to compare the windows by performance data -- see if you can get the u-factors, design pressure ratings, and air infiltrations on both of them. I would go with the window with the lowest u-factor and air infiltration number. (I'd love to hear what the ProMax8 is...) By comparing these, you should find your winner, although I would imagine the numbers would be very close.
Both of these windows sound like they are very solid, I would probably base my decision more on the company doing the work, although it sounds like you have two good options.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
[Cheryl's Reply]
Thank you for your quick reply. It seems the Amerimax promax8 was a package they offered their bigger dealers. Those who sell 500 windows a month. It has a few extras built into the window package that are not considered optional like the sound reduction package is on all windows. The promax8 also has a high definition screen that is less visible to the eye. Not sure this is for us since we live in a slightly windy area and the screen is finer. It also includes a child proof lock.
But the products are so similar and the performance package is about the same.
I appreciate your response. I think both Anlin and Amerimax are good windows. Now to make a choice. If you want to see the ProMax8 package you can go to Progressive windows in chatsworth.
Cheryl - Homeowner - from 2018
Anlin Del Mar vs. Simonton Daylight Max
Good morning -- I happened upon your site and am wondering if you could give me an opinion on choosing between the Simonton Daylight Max and the Anlin Del Mar replacement windows? I live outside of Sacramento, CA; temperatures range from 28 degree lows in the winter to 112 highs in the summer. Thanks very much -
Robyn - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Robyn, both of these windows are decent, but the Simonton Daylight Max is not as good as the Anlin Del Mar window. The Daylight Max is more of an entry level/mid range vinyl window that uses a thinner frame with more glass area. Go with the Del Mar option and you will be quite happy come year 8 and beyond.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Anlin Del Mar Series vs. Simonton
Hi Dane, I had a company that carries Anlin windows come out to give me a quote for 9 windows and 1 sliding door... I believe it's the Del Mar series that is soundproof for $9800.
I also had a another company that carries Simonton windows come to quote me for the same exact windows for $8770 and if it's a check they will even take $500 off.
I am having a hard time to find most current reviews of these 2 products comparison. Each company is saying there product is better than the other
Sue - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Sue, the Anlin Del Mar series is good. The quote sounds high to me. Assuming that the sliding door is $2,000, that's quite a bit for the 9 windows.
The $8270 for the exact same windows sounds much more in line with what I would expect (not knowing the size of windows, upgrades, etc.). I'm a little confused if this is for Simonton windows or Anlin with this second company. Simonton makes some pretty mediocre window series, as well as some very good windows, so if we are comparing Anlin and Simonton, I'd need to know what Simonton series we are talking about.
In general, Anlin is the better window by a bit, but again it depends on which series you are comparing.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2017
Anlin Del Mar Desert Windows
Dane, Thank you for your advise. One more question. Which would you choose: Anline Del Mar Desert package at $13,533 or Milgard Tuscany for $10,500? We live in Phoenix, A.
Mary Jo - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Mary Jo, If it were me I would probably go with the Del Mar Desert package, but I would use the Milgard quote to see how low the Anlin dealer will go. Tell him that if he can get close to the Tuscany bid, you will sign that day. See what he says and give him a few days to lower his price.
- Site Editor - from 2017
Anlin Del Mar Luxury Series Costs
I just got a quote for Anlin Del Mar Luxury Series. My 22 year old home is in Phoenix and some seals are broken with condensation. I am not replacing all windows but the windows which the seals are broken and others with direct sunlight.
Unfortunately, the height of my windows which have direct sun is 77" tall and about 90" wide. So therefore, I was told the manufacturers do not make such large slides anymore in my price range.
I also needed to replace a double door to a walkout balcony. Here is the quote I received. Vinyl with argon installed . Del Mar Luxury Series.
(4) X 35" X 77" double hung
(1) X 85 X 60 X0X
(2) X 23" X 77" double hung
(1) 48 X 77" Picture Window
(1) 28" X 85" Transom
(4) 48 X 56" double hung
(1) 61 X 80 French doors
The total including parts and labor is 11,800.00
Is this about right in price?
Thank you for your consideration.
Joyce - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Joyce, that price quote doesn’t look outrageous by any means for the sizes and dimensions. However, when it comes to some of the bigger openings and French doors, you will tend to see some big differences in bids from one company to the other. I would definitely recommend a couple more bids to see what else is out there.
I would get a bid from a well-reviewed Milgard dealer and also a local company who sells Amerimax. Perhaps even a local company who sells higher end Simonton Series such as the Impressions.
Assuming you get two more bids, I think only then will you know how that Anlin bid stacks up in terms of market price. There may be some real differences in door prices that could save you some money, while still maintaining a high level of quality.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Anlin Del Mar Series vs Milgard Tuscany
I live at the beach in Southern CA. I am planning on replacing Ply-Gem 12 year old casements due to continuing significant hardware rust/repair with vinyl sliding windows. I am looking at both Milgard Tuscany Series and Anlin Del Mar Series. In your opinion, which of these manufacturer products will be most durable in the beach and related salt air environment? Thanks.
Paul - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Paul, both of these windows are nice mid range vinyl windows that should serve you well at the beach. I think they are so similar in quality and features that it's a coin toss. Instead I would focus my attention on the companies who will be doing the work and installation. This would be the bigger factor for me. If I had to choose between these two windows, I might give the small nod to Anlin.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Anlin Del Mar vs Milgard Tuscany Prices
I am replacing 4 windows (2 are 71.25 x 46.5 sliders with a SW sunset with full aluminum encasement and 2 are bathroom windows 32 x 48 single hang low sun area) to block construction. I like both the Milgard Tuscany and the Anlin Del Mar but since I am in the Phoenix Metro area I was leaning more to the Del Mar but they are around $700 more expensive. Pleas give me your input. Thank you.
Joanne - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Joanne, I would say the Tuscany and the Anlin Del Mar windows are pretty equivalent, I might give the slight nod to the Del Mar. I like the Tuscany though and assuming good installation on both, I would probably choose the Tuscany and save the $700. The only factors that would tip my choice in the other direction would be colors that the Del Mar comes in over the Tuscany or again the quality of the installation team who will be doing the work.
Bottom line is that I think you've got a couple of very nice windows and with good installation, you should be happy with either.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Anlin Del Mar vs Milgard Styleline
I just found your website and have been reading avidly. I've currently received quotes from 5 different. I'm picking between Anlin Del Mar windows and Milgard Styleline.
It seems like the Anlin Del Mars is a higher quality window and perhaps I should ask the Milgard people to revise their quotes for the Tuscany?
I'm in San Francisco and both Anlin and Milgard seem to be local - is that true? The one thing that really worries me is I wonder how the Anlin warranty affects resale price of a building or perceived quality? For example, limited warranty once you transfer owners.
Also, the Anlin rep made it seem like Anlin is a much higher quality window because their vinyl is made of a composite that doesn't turn yellow, better bearings for the track, etc. Do you have any idea as to the amount of truth in these claims?
Overall, I'm leaning towards the Anlin but wonder if that's just because the guy did a great job selling me on it. He was the only person who actually showed me windows and explained anything to me. All the other people did was take measurements, leave and email me a quote.
Any advice you have would be welcome! Thank you so much for your website! And feel free to publish this question on there if you need more content. Warm regards,
LJ - Consumer - from 2015
[Site Editor's Response]
LJ, you were correct that the Anlin Delmar is perhaps a touch better in quality than the Milgard Styleline window. I would say that the Milgard Tuscany is probably a touch better than the Anlin Delmar and should run 10 to 15% more than the cost of the Styleline. Definitely get a quote for both and see how they compare.
My understanding is that the Anlin warranty would probably be very similar to the Milgard warranty. As far as resell value, I've really never heard of anyone factoring in a window warranty when they go to make an offer on a house, however you are correct that when you transfer owners, typically the warranty only last for 20 years from the original date of purchase.
The claim that the Anlin rep made that their vinyl is a higher quality is dubious in my opinion. Milgard uses much the same vinyl as the Anlin and only poor quality vinyl extrusions are going to yellow overtime. Vinyl holds up well to the effects of sun and the elements overtime.
Anlin is a California-based company, while Milgard has factories up and down the West Coast, including four factories within California. Both the Anlin and the Milgard windows are good quality vinyl windows and you should be well served by either - I prefer the Tuscany to the Styleline.
My advice would be to focus less on the windows, since you have two solid choices, and now turn to really looking at the local companies who are giving you the bids. Installation accounts for about half of the job in terms of how well the windows going to perform, how much air is going to get through, and how durable the windows are in the rough opening. You really want to make sure that whoever you use is going to do a thorough and proper installation and is going to back up their work with the labor warranty.
Let me know what you end up deciding and how it works out!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2015
Anlin Del Mar vs Catalina
I am looking at Anlin Coronado / Catalina - their Del Mar is even 100% more. (The Marvin quote was nearly 50% more) Both are dual pane, may be the people here are rich and can afford, except few old people like us! How can I be sure that when they say they are giving me certain glass options and Ar gas, I am getting that. Do you have any idea to make sure of this? Thx again.
Gobi - Homeowner - from 2015
[Site Editor's Response]
That does not surprise me that the Marvin replacement window is 50% more, it's a much better window. However, you should be just fine with a good vinyl window. The Anlin Catalina is their entry level vinyl window, but it's decent for a project on a strict budget, as long as you get quality installation, you should be just fine with that window. The Anlin Coronado is a better window and would offer better long term value - I would like to see you stretch your budget and get the window that will provide better value in the long term. Tell the rep that you want the Coronado, but explain that it is a bit out of your price range and see what they can do on price. They may suggest some hardware tweaks or features that aren't important to you that can drive the per window cost down.
Take a look at this page for some additional budget recommendations.
As far as the glass goes, there will usually be a small label on the glass, especially if the company sells glass packages with "names" - they often have unique names for their different upgrades. Ask the person selling you the window to point out where on the glass you can confirm that you are getting what you are paying for. No quality manufacturer or dealer is going to pull a bait and switch - I suppose that is where using good contractors - dealer - distributor comes into play. Anlin is a quality manufacturer, you should be in good hands with them.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2015
Anlin Windows Reviews :: Coronado Series
Anlin Windows Reviews vs RBA
Good evening, I was interested in getting a better understanding of what are some quality windows to replace my home with as I'm in search.
I have received bids from approximately $1000 (Anlin) to $3000 (Renewal By Anderson) bids per window for a retrofit installed. I'm unsure what may be a reasonable bid to what may be something to be weary about.
Thank you.
Hector - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Hector, hi there, so it's hard to say what's a fair price, but $1000 for retrofit on a normal sized Anlin Coronado is expensive in my opinion. However, there can be all kinds of reasons for this per window pricing. $3000 for Renewal on retrofit is darn high as well. I would consider to collect some bids in order to find out what the competitors are charging. Make sure you tell each company that comes out that you are collecting multiple bids and that you would really appreciate their most competitive price as this is an important factor among many that you'll be using to make your decision.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Anlin Coronado Windows Reviews
Tim, first, thanks for all of the helpful information on the site. It was this site that turned me onto Zen Windows for a bid.
Anyhow, I live in Denver and have double paned white aluminum framed windows with grids that are 30 years old I am the original home owner. I haven’t noticed any seal failures or condensation, but some windows, particularly in the Family Room, are drafty (and I haven’t been able to isolate the source). All my neighbors have replaced some or all of their windows already. I have 15 single hungs ranging in size from 23x36 up to 44x71 with most being at or near the larger size. I also have 8 single sliders ranging in size from 33x20 up to 59x46 with the majority approaching the larger size. Finally, I have 13 fixed windows ranging in size from 18x12 up to 48x30 with windows in all sizes in between. There are also 10 oriels, 10 tempers, and 4 windows that get joined. So, that’s a total of 36 windows in 32 openings.
I don’t know how long we’ll stay in this home, but a good guess is at least a decade or more with no real plans to move in the immediate future. Mostly, I’m looking for better comfort and ease of maintenance which generally translates to energy savings as well.
I asked all the bids to assume no grids and double hung replacements and most did (along with double sliders).
Here are the bids:
Encore Series (Relabeled Alside Mezzo Triple Pane): $39,992
Champion Comfort 365: $50,201 (possibly $44K with current promotion)
Zen Nirvana (Soft-Lite Classic Plus): $24,230
Zen Lotus (Soft-Lite Pro): $28,000 (Ballpark estimate from Zen)
Pella 250 (Single Hung): $34,719
Renewal By Andersen: $66,987
Anlin Catalina (Single Hung/Single Sliders): $20,439
Anlin Catalina/Coronado (Double Hung/Double Sliders): $22,500 (Ballpark estimate from dealer input)
So, the Anlin bids include the Sound Package Glass (free with a February order) with the Clean Plus coating and 10 large windows get SunMatrix coating to reduce the SHGC. As noted, the lowest cost bid is for Single Hung/Single Slider windows. These have much better raw numbers (U-Factor, SHGC, AI, etc) than the Doubles found in the Coronado series. This Anlin dealer has a pretty good reputation, but a few very bad reviews (some that are recent). Also, while I like the Anlin product (its raw numbers appear to be some of the best), its a very small manufacturer. So, who knows how long it stays in business (to honor its excellent warranty). Meanwhile, Zen has excellent reviews and ratings and has been nothing but a model company here. The lone poor review I could find suggests that the consumer was upset that they couldn’t see the window before making a buy decision. The pricing above does reflect an additional $1K discount if we make a decision by Friday. They really are low key, but they told us about the discount about two weeks after their initial bid - about a week ago. Zen says that manufacturers prices are going up in March, but, of course, they will still honor their original bid for 6 months ($1K more).
Zen also offers the relabeled Soft-Lite Imperial, but I didn’t ask for a bid (they said it was likely overkill). Is the Imperial worth it?
Should I ask for an official bid on either the Lotus or the Imperial?
So, the general impression I get is that a good install on a mediocre window is much better than a mediocre install on a good window. So, that might push me to the safety of Zen. On raw numbers, the Anlin might be a better window. I’m still getting one last bid from one of the best installers in town that also has Anlin windows. Also, not sure whether single vs double hung/sliders is important. My wife says she really doesn’t care. Thoughts? Also, not sure how important foam fill vs no fill is since it should be reflected in the numbers (Zen filled, Anlin not). I don’t know that triple pane is necessary even though it does improve most of the numbers slightly at the general cost of VT (and we like light).
Finally, if you have any thoughts on grids in the windows I’d love to hear them. The homes are not wildly contemporary - built in late 80s early 90s with siding, some brick, normal multi story lines, generally no window shutters, etc. Its your normal mid range tract housing Colorado community. So, maybe they look best with them. Many replacements have gone without in my neighborhood (perhaps just the cost savings), but some have retained them (so no covenants to worry about). Any thoughts here?
Again, thanks for the site. It has been invaluable.
Barry - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Barry, I think I'd have to agree with you on most of your points. The Anlin Catalina/Coronado is comparable or is a bit better than the Zen Nirvana. I'd be leaning towards the Anlin myself, but would put a big emphasis on the head to head match in terms of the installation company. I would not worry about the size of Anlin; they made it through the great recession with flying colors and have been expanding since then. They are here to stay.
So my one and two recommendations would be Anlin and then Zen. But again, it would be based on how I thought the install companies match up. The $6K savings would be a factor for me for sure, but not at the expense of a quality install.
Foam fills are nice for some added structure, but not necessary. A nice upgrade that adds a bit of energy efficiency.
Triple pane is probably not necessary. I recommend it for super cold climates -- Denver is sort of on the bubble. I can't say one way or the other for you. Triple Pane Windows Cost
Grids are mostly decorative, although they add a tiny bit of energy efficiency to the window. I think they are more of a personal taste than anything. Also how they fit the design, style, and aesthetics of your home.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2021
Anlin Coronado Windows
Hello, I am hoping you can give me some advice. I was quoted 8300 for Anlin Coronado windows and install. It included 3-55" sliders, 2-36" sliders, and 1 baywindow. What are your thoughts? Thanks.
Ryan - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Ryan, bay windows can be all over the board. What is the cost quote on the bay? In general, I'd say Anlin windows should run $600 to $700 per window the 55" sliders. Bay Windows Prices
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Anlin Coronado vs. Amerimax Aristocrat
I have been looking at windows/sliding door replacements for over a month now. I really like the Anlin after watching their manufacturing process. My hesitation is due to my altitude. They would have to be shipped with the tubes for pressure and I don’t know how I would verify that the tubes were sealed properly after the pressure equalization. Installers seemed to think that they didn’t need to do anything to them, yet my understanding is that moisture could get in if not sealed (info direct from Anlin).
With the Denver area building boom, quality installers are extremely busy, and I’m sure can work on larger jobs, leaving less-qualified installers to fill in. I was told EVERYONE subs out this type of work. Anlin only sells through one company in the Denver area and one company in Colorado Springs (~80 miles away). The one in Denver seems good- just a couple of complaints, but I don’t know if they will be around in a few years.
Would you recommend replacements from a manufacturer that is already at altitude- Amerimax and Milgard? Have you heard of problems with Anlin due to altitude?
Thank you!
Karen - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Karen, I get this question of altitude about once every year and I always muddle together an answer based on anecdotal evidence as opposed to real live experience. I don't live above 6000 feet (nothing like that) and have never dealt with the issue first hand.
I know that if the tubes are done right, there shouldn't be any issues. I agree with you that Anlin is the better manufacturer than Milgard or Amerimax, although I do like the Amerimax Aristocrat casements that I've seen and the reviews associated with them.
Anlin has only relatively recently expanded their operation, but I would say they are a very solid company. I understand your concern and I'm not sure I have a definitive answer for you.
I would probably rely on the Anlin Denver dealer's opinion on the quality and reliability of the tubes. Or go with the best Amerimax window I could find. I think that would be the two options I'd consider. Perhaps the deciding factor would be the history and reviews on the company doing the actual install.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Coronado Windows vs. Window World
Hi, I got an estimate from a company to replace my windows and got back an estimate for $11,957 to replace 8 windows with ANLIN VIRGIN VINIL DUAL PANE, CASEMENTS, PROPRIETARY “INFINITY” ENERGY EFFICIENT GLASS PACKAGE. They will install the insulation process and when completed will remove and dispose of old windows. They will also provide lifetime warranty upon completion of the project, this warranty is transferable to the next owners should I decide to sell the house.
My concern is the price comparison between this company and the prices I have seen and heard WINDOW WORLD has. Am I overpaying for my windows? How does the quality compare between Anlin windows and the brand Window World has? As a consumer I don’ t really have a way to find the proper information to compare.
I have signed a contract but the windows will not be installed for another couple of weeks and would like to have some peace of mind knowing I chose right before the windows are installed and can cancel my contract.
If the size of the windows makes a difference in the pricing, please, let me know, I can provide the window measurements.
Thanks for your help.
Rosa - Homeowner - from 2017
Editor's Reply
Rosa, at first glance that seems like a very high price quote. $1500 per window is more than double what a standard vinyl window with installation costs. Now, I have no idea what is going on with your project and the price quote might be fine if there is quite a bit of work on the installation side or if the size of the windows are quite large. So yes, the windows are priced out by the lineal foot by the installer when he gives you the bid.
Anlin makes a much better window than Window World, but even Window World's top window with installation will rarely run over $600 per window installed. Still quite a jump from their $189 per window installed...
I wouldn't advise going with WW, but I would advise cancelling the contract with anlin. You need to take some time, get a few more bids from local companies who carry good brands. On the west half of the U.S. I typically recommend Milgard, Amerimax, Marvin, and Simonton. See if there is a rep in your area for these and get a bid from them. You can always go back to the Anlin bid, but you would be smart to ask them to match your lowest bid that you get from one of the others.
https://www.replacementwindowsreviews.co/review-topics/negotiating-a-home-window-bid.html
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Anlin Coronado Windows vs. Milgard Tuscany
Hi Tim. We're looking at windows now for our home in Palm Springs (HOT!). We got a quote already for the Anlin Coronado windows and the Milgard Tuscany. It seems the Coronado is Anlin's high end line, but the Tuscany is the middle quality windows for Milgard. So I'm not really sure we're comparing apples to apples here. Milgard's quote was 1/2 the price of the Anlin. I'd really like to get a quote for Milgard's top of the line vinyl windows so I can get a better comparison with the Coronado windows. Do you know what line that would be?
Our quote for Anlin was about $16,000 for 7 windows (1 really big one) and 2 oversized sliders (taller than normal).
Let me know what you think. Thank you!
Mike - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Mike, the Milgard Tuscany is the higher end vinyl window from Milgard, but they do carry better (and pricier) windows, including the Ultra fiberglass, Essence (wood clad) and two aluminum window options. You may want to get a quote on the aluminum options, which will sacrifice on some of the energy efficiency, but are often used in hot climates such as Palm Springs due to their incredible strength that really stands up to hot climates.
Anlin's Coronado is quite a good window, but not worth 2x the cost of the Tuscany. I would think more like 20% to 25% for the Coronado, but remember that glass options and the various upgrades can have a significant effect on the per window cost of these bids.
I happen to like the Milgard Tuscany and I assume it would be fine for Palm Springs. You may want to discuss other pricing/windows with the Milgard rep and see if he thinks you are fine with the Tuscany or whether he thinks another line is more appropriate for your climate.
You may also want to consider another bid or two to see how these stack up against the Anlin and Milgard. Amerimax should be available in your area and their higher end vinyl model, the Aristocrat or the Craftsman Portrait would be the models to look at.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
[Mike's Reply]
Thank you so much for the quick response! As of now, I do intend to stay in the condo for the unforeseeable future but never know what the future holds.
I do like the Del Mar better.
Right now the offer is for $5,626 (~$300 lower) for Del Mar windows and Malibu patio door. He also offer the BAYVIEW by MONTEVERDE for $4,700 (price match to the Daylight) for Bayview windows and patio door or $4,999 for Bayview windows and Malibu patio door. The warranty on the Del Mar is definitely the best of the 3 options.
The installer for the Anlin and the Monteverde is the same company that my neighbor had her windows installed over 5 years ago and she's happy with them and no problem so far. So that's why I'm leaning towards this installer.
What do you think about the Bayview? Is the price good for them and quality? He said that these are the best prices for them (Del Mar and Bayview). I'm sitting out for a while longer and see if he would come back lower :) I have 30 days to think about it.
Thank you in advance!
Mike - Homeowner - from 2017
Anlin Windows Reviews :: Monte Verde Series
The Monte Verde series is made by Anlin, but is marketed as a "standalone" vinyl window series. It is kind of a drop down or mid range series that is a solid step down from the Del Mar series. A decent option though for homeowners who live in mild climates. I would give the Anlin Monte Verde a out of 5 stars rating.
Dane - Site Editor - Updated In 2024
Monte Verde Windows Reviews
Hi, Dane ~ belated Thank You for your response and guidance. I really appreciate it.
Fyi, before I wrote to you the first time, I did complete the form that you linked -- I should have expected receiving phone cals to set up bids, but I thought I would just get emails with brochures attached. But it worked out and the calls I got were from seemingly reputable companies from what I can tell (which I know very little).
But now, per your recommendations, I have obtained 4 bids, which are attached, as well as summarized below. I knew the prices would be lower than RBA, but am frankly shocked by how much lower, and even a little skeptical(!), but ultimately very annoyed at Past Me for not doing my due diligence.
1. Anlin Del Mar
Northwest Exteriors
$9,986
2. Anlin Monte Verde
Cal Comfort
$7,069.45
I just clarified with them: "No, this is the Monte Verde series. We don't have access to the Del Mar series. Sorry." This is confusing. Is Monte Verde even an Anlin product? I don't see Monte Verde on their website. Cal Comfort is also a Milgard dealer. Obviously, I should have asked more questions while they were here.
3. Milgard Trinsic
Premier Window Supply
$5,839.59
4. Simonton Reflection 5500 Series
Mazzera's, Inc.
$7,550
Wendy - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
So for me this comes down to timeline in the home. If your timeline is say 15 years plus, then I think you go with the very best vinyl window, which is the Anlin Del Mar. If your timeline is under that, I would strongly consider either the Monte Verde and Trinsic series. Premier Window Supply seems to get good reviews and the Trinsic cost is solid.
Certain dealers have access to the Del Mar and others don't. The Monte Verde is an Anlin-made window, but it doesn't show up on their website and Anlin doesn't appear on the Monte Verde site. I find it strange, but the window industry in general is weird -- it's like they're trying to be confusing :)
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Anlin Windows Reviews On The Bay View
Hi Tim, we are looking to replace 9 windows and also a set of french doors with a sliding glass door. We got a quote of $7100 for Monteverde Bay View windows and a quote of $7600 for Catalina from the same company. These quotes include covering the outside wood frames and sills with an aluminum encasement.
We also have a quote of $6650 with another company using Milgard Tuscany, no exterior wood covering. We are leaning toward the first company, but are trying to decide between the Bay View and Catalina.
How much better quality is the Catalina window? We like the ventilation stops provided with the Catalina window, but are worried that we will get less light with the even sightlines feature. There is apparently something called the Catalina Maximum View which may dispense with the even sightlines. Appreciate any input you can give us.
Thanks!
Inge - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Inge, the Anlin Bay View is considered their drop down window line so thee $500 upgrade to go to the Catalina is well worth it. Usually, I would expect to see about $1500 difference here so there is value in this upgrade. I also consider the Anlin price to be a better value over the Milgard Tuscany.
You will get less light with the Catalina, but that is the trade off between light and energy efficiency. I've never heard of the Catalina Maximum View, but perhaps some Anlin dealers carry this option. Again, you will sacrifice a bit of energy efficiency for the thinner frame. Keep in mind that Anlin is a bit odd with their rep/dealers and there can be multiple in your area who all sell different lines or series.
The bottom line is the Catalina is the way to go in my opinion, unless the light is a bit enough factor for the Bay View to win out. Both very good windows though.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Anlin Monte Verde Price Bid
Hello Dane, We are getting bids on window replacements for the Anlin "Monteverde" model. 17 windows in one home and 19 windows in another home (including a 6'0" x 7'0" slider) for a total price of $22,900. Does this seem reasonable for both homes in San Diego, CA? Thank you.
George - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
George, that definitely seems like the price is in the ballpark. If we assume the patio slider is $2000, then that puts your windows at $550 apiece with installation. That's about what I'd expect for the Monteverde model. I'd get a few more bids to make sure myself. I'd get a bid from Newman on their Milgard Trinsic model or Tuscany. I'd also get a bid from BM Windows on the Amerimax (I forget whether they still carry that brand, but that's a good option.) You might even look for a local Simonton dealer and see if they carry a top model like the Reflections 5500 and see how that compares.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Anlin Monte Verde and Simonton Daylight Max
Hello, I am changing out old 1950 windows on my home in San Diego. I have received quotes for 8 windows with two being smaller bathroom windows. The Anlin monte verde was quoted at about 3500, whereas the simonton was quoted around 4500. Just trying to get an idea of the quality difference between the two. One installer did believe the installation would be a little more complicated which is why the cost may be higher as well.
Daniel - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Daniel, I'd rate the Anlin Monte Verde and Simonton Daylight Max pretty close in quality to one another. Both are decent middle of the road vinyl windows. I might even choose the Anlin Monte Verde window over the Daylight Max. So having said that, I think it's a no brainer to go with the Anlin dealer at the lower price point. Let me know how it goes!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Anlin Monte Verde Bayview vs. Amerimax Craftsman
We're in California and need to choose between Amerimax Craftsman and Anlin Monte Verde Bayview. The quotes were very similar in price.
Jamie - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Hi Jamie, I would probably the Anlin is the better company and product. In this case, not by much. The Amerimax Craftsman and Anlin Monte Verde Bayview are pretty comparable to one another. I would switch your focus to look at the company providing the installation -- choose the best one here.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Anlin Windows Reviews vs Milgard
Hello Tim,I hope you are having a good week. I wanted to follow up on my email from last week. I got a quote from Newman and couple other vendors for Milgard. Newman was better priced compared to others.
Newman Quote:
22 Windows: $9643
1 French Door: $1862
Total Material: $11,505 (Material cost is similar to Dixieline)
Labor: $150/ window and $550/Door = $3850.
Total: $15,355
So now pretty much it boils down to:
Anlin Monte Verde Bay View series @ $14.3k
Milgard Tuscany series @15.3k
Now that both are at almost similar price point, what do you think is a better option?
Since, as you mentioned in the previous email, both windows are in the mid-range category and not that different from each other, I am inclining towards Anlin Bay view series, unless you advice otherwise.
Thank you for your time and advice.
Kinza - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Kinza, I think either bid is pretty solid. I must say that, in my experience, Newman is a very good local company that will provide the quality of installation and long term assistance that most consumers would be very fortunate to have.
Having said that, I think if the same could be said about the Anlin installer and you feel more comfortable with them, then certainly go with them. Just make sure to do your due diligence in vetting the anilin installer.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Milgard Tuscany vs. Anlin Monte Verde Bay View
Hello Tim, I live in San Diego and bought a house in 2016. House is built in 1984 with original single pane windows. I am planning to replace 22 windows and a patio door in my house. House is in the fire zone and hence need a tempered glass as well. I got below quotes to replace 22 windows and 1 french patio door.
Anlin Monte Verde Bay View series (from a well reviewed contractor) (got 2 quotes as well – both are similar)
White vinyl, low-e, argon filled, tempered glass
Total $14k à 11k for material and 3k for labor ($125 per window and $300 for patio door).
Milgard Tuscany from Dixieline (I am planning to get couple more quotes).
White vinyl, SuncoatMax (low-e), gray EdgeGard spacer with argon, tempered glass, smart touch lock.
Total $17k à 11k for material and 6k for labor ($250 per window and $700 for patio door).
Anlin Delmar series (another well reviewed contractor):
White vinyl, low-e, argon filled, tempered glass
Total $21k à Contractor didn’t give the breakdown but I got couple of quotes for this series and both were around $21k.
The only breakdown I have is for French door: $4200, Sliding patio door: $2800, material + labor inclusive. (Note: $21k above includes 22 windows and 1 french door)
Why is the price for material same for both manufacturers (Bayview and Milgard) even when Milgard Tuscany is a better window? Is Dixieline selling a watered down version of the Milgard that I would find with a private contractor? Or am I being up charged for the bayview series?
Also, labor is pretty high for Dixieline. Based on my research, $125-$175 is the normal price for retro fit window replacement. $250 seems excessive. I guess I can probably negotiate on this further.
I thought Bayview series quote was fantastic until I got the Milgard Tuscany quote which has essentially same price for the materials. What should I do? Just go with Bayview series or cough up little more an get Milgard Tuscany windows?
Sorry for the long winded question but I would definitely appreciate your insight.
Kinza - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Kinza, I honestly think the Anlin Monte Verde Bay View is a decent enough vinyl window for most places in San Diego. It's a mild climate that doesn't get tons of rain. The Monte Verde isn't the best window out there, but it's pretty solid and the price quote you have sounds very reasonable to me.
I'm not convinced the Tuscany is that much better than the Monte Verde. I would say they are both in the spectrum of mid range vinyl windows.
I think the big issue for me would be the quality of the contractor/installer. It sounds like you have done your homework and found all solid companies with good reviews.
You might want to get a bid from Newman Windows, which also sells the Tuscany. I'd be curious to see how their pricing compares with Dixieline.
The quote on the Del Mar sounds pretty steep to me.
I like the Monte Verde bid so far to be honest.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Anlin Monte Verde vs Premium Windows
Hi Tim, I am a homeowner in Bakersfield, CA that is replacing the original 1946 wooden frame single pane windows on our recently purchased home. We have received three bids from two contractors:
Contractor A: 19 Anlin Del Mar windows for $17,172
Contractor A: 19 Anlin Monte Verde windows for $11,525
Contractor B: 17 Premium Windows for $6,036 (www.premiumwindowsinc.com)
Contractor B does not seem like they would do a good job since they got the number of windows wrong on the bid (we asked for 19) and have generally had poor communication with us. So we want to stay away from them and we have not seen any reviews for Premium Windows.
Anlin get very good reviews, but the $17k price point for the Del Mar seems excessively high versus the Monte Verde. Two questions:
1) Are the Del Mar windows that much better that they would warrant $6k higher price?
2) Is the quote for either the Del Mar or Monte Verde in the range of normal?
Thank you.
Curran - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Curran, the Del Mar is the better window, but I don't think it's worth the $6K more. I like Anlin windows but that price seems quite high for 19 windows.
I agree that you don't want to go with a contractor who you are having reservations about BEFORE the job. I actually think the Monte Verde is a decent vinyl window and the upgraded Bay View option in this model is good.
I checked the premiumwindowsinc website and they look like cheap vinyl windows -- I wouldn't be surprised if they were relabeled Atrium windows. However, I don't know this for a fact so I will try and collect some additional consumer reviews to get a better judge on this company.
I think you need to either find the floor of Contractor A's bid by using the Monte Verde bid to drive his price down.
I think you should get a bid from a local Milgard dealer and a local Amerimax dealer and see what they offer. I think this would bring some clarity to this huge range of bids you have so far.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Anlin Monte Verde Costs
A contractor suggested a Monte Verde window made by Anlin. Ours is an older Viking that was retrofit. Didn't use existing old metal frame. No UV protection, about 15-20 years old.
Want to replace one of 18 windows. Large front window with two sliders. Approx 8 ft wide x 3 1/2 ft high with almond or tan. Contractor said that Viking should not have retrofit, but they are nice, double pane windows for their time.
I am looking to replace only the front window, not because it's bad, but because I want UV protection.
Contractor wants to put in Monte Verde by Anlin. Is this good front window? I will be getting La z boy leather furniture. Sofa is higher back and will sit 3 inches above expanse of the windowsill.
Cost of window and installation: $680.
I live outside of Sacramento, in Roseville, CA.
Bev - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Bev, the Monte Verde is a good vinyl window, it's not the best vinyl window on the market, but it's a solid vinyl window to be sure. I would say it's on par with the Milgard Tuscany, which is also a good solid mid range vinyl
window.
The price quote for a double slider that size is very very fair. All windows are going to allow some UV rays in, that's just the nature of a window. If you do want to limit the amount of light that gets in, talk to your contractor about the glass options available through Anlin. VT or visible transmittance is how much light gets through the window and you may be able to order a glass package with a lower VT.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Anlin Windows Reviews :: Ali'i Extreme Series
The Ali'i Extreme is a vinyl window series that is avaialble to a select group of dealers in Hawaii. It is built strong and durable to hold up to the warm coastal climate of the islands. (See our hurricane window cost calculator for accurate pricing.) This window is on par with their Catalina series, which is just a step down from their premium Del Mar model. All in all, quite a good quality vinyl window. I would give the Anlin Ali'i Extreme a out of 5 stars rating.
Dane - Site Editor - Updated In 2024
Ali'i Windows Cost Bid
Ali'i Vinyl Windows
2 bedroom windows 62" by 36": $2,744
8 windows in total: $8,383.24 TOTAL
Ritch - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Ritch, given what I have seen lately, this is a pretty fair price. It's not cheap, but it's about what I would expect. Very good window. Assuming the company doing the install has a good to great reputation, then I would say you are good to go...
Dane - Site Editor - from 2021
Anlin Ali'i Extreme vs. Amerimax Craftsman Portrait
Hi Dane and Tom. Thank you for the very useful information I've gotten from your site. I live in Hawaii and am replacing 12 windows - a combination of single hung, sliding and awning. I've gotten prices from 2 places as follows:
Anlin Ali'i Extreme - $12,500
Amerimax Craftsman Portrait - $11,000
I could probably negotiate the price of the Anlin down a bit to be closer to the Amerimax. So I would like your opinion as to which is the better window ignoring the price.
Thanks so much in advance for your advice.
Janice - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Hi Janice, I think Anlin tends to make the better window, but not by much. I'd put those two windows as relatively close to one another. If you can get that Anlin price close to the Amerimax, I'd go with the Anlin myself.
However, the windows are close enough that if there is a big difference in the quality, professionalism, and online reputations of the companies doing the work that I'd weight this above the windows themselves.
Good luck to you on your window project!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Anlin Extreme vs Simonton Windows
I was hoping you are able to offer what you know about these:
1 . Win-Dor Windows (and Doors) - made by Win-Dor company themselves . Their main office as well as factory where they manufacture their own windows are located in Anaheim, California . They seem to be a trustworthy company, but very limited window style selection (ie they discontinued their double hungs due to lack of supply demand)
2 . Anlin Extreme - I'm not sure if this is a relabel of one of Anlin's series, or a new series, but was not on your list.
3 . Simonton Vantage Pointe 6500 - Home Depot offers this . Do you know which Simonton series the 6500 is equivalent to?
I think I'd like to interview a couple more companies before I decide, but right now I'm trying to decide between Anlin Extreme/ Amerimax Craftsman (same installer) or Win-Dor . Any thoughts?
Also, going into this I was expecting Low-e2 to be the standard, but seems Low-e3 is what I've been presented with, although one of the companies tried telling me that their Low-e3 is normally an "upgrade" but they are currently "offering" Low-e3 for the price of their Low-e2 (even though they are phasing out the Low-e2 meaning I couldn't even buy it if I wanted to LOL) . I caught on right away that it was a sales tactic from doing much research and familiarizing myself with terms and such .
Samson - Homeowner - from 2015
[Contractor Response]
Are you in Hawaii? I've never seen this Anlin model but it looks to be available for Hawaii only…Simonton tends to be very cryptic in their model names - if you find a distributor who serves your area they should be able to tell you the comparable model. Often times, Simonton relabels their windows and then provides them to certain distributors or resellers to create the idea of exclusivity.
The Anlin looks like the best of the bunch, depending on what price you can get. Amerimax is a good vinyl window as well -- they are both really on par with one another -- Amerimax does have lots of exterior color options for their vinyl windows, although it adds a lot to the cost of the window (up to 30% in some cases!)
Honestly, I know very little about Win-Dor, but I will check them out this week and see what I can find. Let me know how the bids come in against one another!
Dane - Site Editor - from 2015
Anlin Windows Reviews :: Mar Vista Series
The Mar Vista is an "exclusive" series that isn't listed on the Anlin website, but is instead sold through certain dealers. It is essentially more of a budget option from the company, although the Mar Vista is still a quality mid range vinyl window. I would place the Mar Vista just below the Catalina series in terms of overall quality. I would give the Anlin Mar Vista a out of 5 stars rating.
Dane - Website Editor - Updated In 2024
Mar Vista vs Del Mar
Hey Dane, American Vision Windows was at my house tonight and they sell both Anlin Mar Vista and Anlin Del Mar. They are definitely not the same product. The sales rep said Mar Vista is an exclusive made just for their company. The Del Mar series is a "luxury" series and the Mar Vista is not. I told the rep not to bother with a Mar Vista quote as I didn't like the look of them. The site lines were weird. I like the even sight lines of the Del Mar series better.
Your reply mentioned that you'd like to know some performance data. I am attaching a couple of photos from the brochures the sales person left.
All that said, I like the Del Mar series but not the company, American Window Visions. They are too "sale-sy" for me. Unfortunately, the Del Mar series is limited to a few dealers (only two or three in San Diego where I live), so I need to find something comparable to Anlin Del Mar.
Jen - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Jen, thanks so much for reaching out. I checked that page and you are absolutely right, we dropped the ball on the Mar Vista and Del Mar products. Anlin has several of these drop down products that we have been learning about very slowly as you can tell :)
Newman Windows is in San Diego and they have quite a solid reputation. They sell the Milgard Tuscany, which is a lower quality window than the Anlin Del Mar in my opinion, but an overall solid vinyl window for your mild climate.
Also BM Windows now sells Anlin windows and they have a solid track record (check their yelp reviews.) They sell the Coronado and Monte Verde series (which is a more budget friendly product as well). I'd love to get your take on the Monte Verde if you do get a bid from them.
Let us know if either of these companies work -- we get lots of San Diego based consumers so it's nice to get the skinny on quality, pricing, and approach!
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
[Jenn's Reply]
Hi Dane,
It's funny that you mentioned BM Windows because we already had an appointment scheduled with them this evening. The Monte Verde has uneven sight lines so I ruled that one out right away. They also have Anlin Catalina which I liked. These are the three estimates we received:
JWG Windows
Simonton Daylight Max
Low E glass with argon
U-factor: 0.29
$9700
American Vision Windows
Anlin Del Mar Series
Anlin Malibu Sliding Doors
Infinit e Plus with argon
Sound suppression 1/8" and 3/16" glass
U-factor : 0.26
$12,900-ish; rep did not leave written quote
BM Windows
Anlin Catalina Series
Anlin Malibu Sliding Doors
Infinit E Plus with argon
Sound suppression 1/8" and 3/16" glass
U-factor: 0.27
$11,000
I compared the specs between the Del Mar series and the Catalina series(with the options noted) and the only difference I can see is the Del Mar series has "Innergy® Rigid Thermal Reinforcements, ultra-strong fiberglass thermal inserts that provide superior thermal insulation and strength inside key components of the sash and frame" and "Comfort•Core™, low conductance green foam inserted in specific dead air chambers in the window frames for maximum energy efficiency."
We have eight windows and two sliding glass doors. One of our windows is very large and one is a geometric shape.
I liked the Craftsman frame option on the Daylight Max window better than the Contemporary frame on the Anlin windows but I am leaning toward the Catalina series from BM Windows. I want to go visit some houses in my neighborhood where they did work before making my final decision. JWG and BM Windows both have great reviews and I liked the reps that were at my house. I did not like the rep from American Vision Windows.
Thanks!!
Jen - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Jen, thanks so much for the info, its tough to keep up on every manufacturer as there are literally hundreds in the U.S.
If you think about it, let us know what you end up going with and how it works out!
All The Best.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Anlin Doors Reviews :: Malibu Series
Anlin Sliding Doors Prices
Hi Dane, I have enjoyed your website. I recently received an estimate for Anlin Panoramic full replacement windows (29) for a home in North Texas that has original aluminum builder grade windows from 1998. They included a sliding patio door replacement that they priced out at $2,900. Quote still seemed a bit high for white vinyl windows. We actually want to get black trim which would be about 25% more per the window company.
John - Homeowner - from 2023
Anlin Malibu French Doors Cost
I was wonder if you could take a look at this quote and let me know if it seems reasonable. Our home is in Aliso Viejo, CA and the weather is fairly mild summers in the 90’s and winters in the 40’s. We like the Anlin brand and are wanting the Delmar series over the Catalina however and extra $7K seems like a lot. I would appreciate your opinion on the quote seems kind of high. This is for 22 windows and one french door.
$30K (using the Catalina series)
$37000 (using the Del Mar series)
$11,600 for the French Door itself
Larry - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Larry, I agree that roughly $300 per window to bump from the Catalina to the Del Mar is expensive -- $100 to $150 is what I see more often. 9 times out of ten this is because the dealer gets better pricing on the Catalina so they push this series -- which is a good series. Take out the French door and the window price is fair. The Anlin French door cost seems excessive to me at almost $12K.
Is there another Anlin dealer that services your area? I'd try to find another bid or two for comparison sake. Possibly a bid on the Milgard Trinsic -- not quite the same quality but might be worth it just to see what they're charging for that window and their French door.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Malibu Sliding Doors Prices
Hello, my quote was for $12,995 -- details: seven Anlin Catalina windows with one Malibu sliding patio door.
White color inside and out. All Catalina except sliding door is Malibu. Anlin Infinite-e Low E3 glass. Platinum elite spacer; argon gas, easy clean coating, with screens for single hungs, single slider and patio door.
Pictures will have grids in 5/8” flat colonial style. Finish all interior and exterior with retrofit installation.
Please provide any comments for this estimate.
Elizabeth - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Elizabeth, I'd say that's a pretty fair quote for the Anlin Catalina and Malibu sliding door. I'd say you have one good quote and need two or three more in you want to be comprehensive in your approach.
[Email dane@replacementwindowsreviews.co for his recommendations]
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin French Doors
Hi Dane, we just signed a contract to have the following put in and I am wondering if it's a good deal. The window is an Anlin Catalina, the doors are Anlin Malibu French wide panel sliders (replacing old French wooden doors) and an entry door that we would buy and the contractor would pick up and install.
One kitchen window 52"w x 46"h – Catalina Low e366 easy clean glass with argon gas
Two French rail (wide) sliders 70 ½"w x 80"h – Malibu Low e366 easy clean glass with argon gas
One install of entry door 36 ½"w x 80"h
Total cost is $8000 for everything.
Is this in the OK deal ballpark?
P.S. We received another quote from another company for the same replacement items except we asked to be quoted with French swing doors as opposed to sliders and that quote was $12000.
Thank you for your website and any help you can give.
Travis - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Travis, I guess based on the second quote, I would say the Anlin quote is good. $8K for one window and 3 doors is good. Anlin makes a very good window and door and if the company doing the install has a good reputation, then perhaps that is a solid bid. Kinda tough to say definitely unless you had one or two more bids to compare it to...
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Patio Door Cost
Hello Dane, just got a quote for an Anlin patio door
93w x 80 h sun matrix glass upgrade. installation, door and haul away old door
$3800 all in
I'm in Studio City (Los Angeles), CA 91604
Thoughts?
Mike - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Mike, door bids are much trickier than windows because the jobs themselves vary so much. $3800 for a patio door is within the bounds of reasonable, but Anlin can be pretty darn pricey as well. I'd get one or two more bids to compare the cost and quality.
I'll send you my Southern California recommendations:
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Sliding Doors Prices
Hi Dane, I'm in Los Angeles and I was quoted $10,500 total for the equivalent of 9 Catalina Windows and 1 Malibu Sliding Door. They are really 7 windows but two are single hung over picture. So 4 are single hung (1 of which is tempered/obscure), 3 are sliders and 2 are picture (tempered).
Additional info: White with Brass Hardware, Standard Infinit-e glass package with easy clean coating plus the sound reduction package.
Thoughts? And thanks so much for your help.
Edward - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Edward, that sounds like a fair price to me given all that I've seen in the past 12 months. The sliding door, the glass package and the sound reduction options can really add up, but it sounds like the price is fair. Of course, to really know you would need to get two more bids, but I think the bid you have is solid. If you were going to get add'l bids, I would say search for a local company that sells the Milgard Trinsic and the Amerimax Craftsman Portrait series.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
[Edward's Reply]
I did already get a quote on Milgard Tuscany windows which came in at $10,925 and Alpine Low E4 windows at $10,450 but I think I like Anlin windows best. I am meeting with another company who sells Anlin Del Mar windows tomorrow to see what the difference in price is.
Anlin Malibu Doors And Catalina Series
John, we are replacing all the windows in our SFR in Rancho Santa Margarita, CA. We are also replacing the current French Door with a Malibu Slider. The house is located in a Fire Zone and hence, you will notice the tempering of windows. Please find attached the quote from one of the vendors for this project.
I wanted to know if this pricing is reasonable for Anlin Catalina and Malibu Doors. We were also thinking for adding Anlin's SunMatrix coating for some of them. Would you have an opinion on this coating, and if so, also have any idea on the pricing for the same? We have received couple of costs that are far apart $40 - $75 per window to $100 - $300 per window.
Your input will be very helpful while we work through on making a decision.
25 windows and 1 sliding door for $18,913
M.M. - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
M.M., this is actually one of the more fair Anlin quotes I've seen in a while. The recent quotes have been a bit out of control. I would certainly get two more bids to compare it to for my own piece of mind, but this seems like a very fair breakdown on pricing in my estimation. Let me know if you would like some recommendations for additional companies/brands/series.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2021
Anline Malibu Sliding Glass Doors Cost
Hi there, I found your reviews online for other homeowners to be quite informative. I was curious to have your thoughts on the following bid before I order the installation: $27,800
Removal & installation Anlin Catalina Windows and Anline Malibu Sliding Glass doors. Bronze Exterior/White Interior Replacement Frames.
Dual Pain, Low E.3+Argon, InFinit E Title 24 Energy Pack Wild Fire Tempered Glass (I assume I need Wild Fire since I live in Los Angeles).
Living Room
96x80 xo (Sliding Glass Door)
70x58 xo
70x58 xo
Bar
48x36 xo
Bathroom
36x24 xo
Kitchen
60x22 xo
72x22 xo
48x34 xo
Dining Room
72x48 xo
Family Room
72x60 xo
96x80 xo (sliding Glass door)
Entry
30x80 xo (Arch)
Bed 1
72x48 xo
36x48 xo (Arch)
36x48 xo (Arch)
36x48 xo (Arch)
Bath 2
24x36 xo
Bed 2
72x48 xo
32x48 xo
Bath 3
24x36 xo
Bed 3
72x48 xo
Bath 4
48x36 xo
Bed 4
36x48 xo
36x48 xo
96x80 xo (Sliding Glass Door)
I would very much appreciate your thoughts on the following quote. The installer has wonderful YELP reviews, but this is my first window install ever, so I thought I'd get a price check.
Alex - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Alex, 21 windows, 3 sliding glass doors, and all the arch top windows...I'd say that's a pretty darn fair quote. Now, would I suggest you get a couple more bids to do an actual comparison with, yes I would. This is really the only way to know whether your bid is legitimately fair or not.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
[Site Editor's Answer]
Thank you for getting back to me. Your email gives me a sense of relief. We actually did get other quotes that were slightly lower ($2K), but didn't get a good vibe from those companies. But the company we liked, actually had a higher quote, and decided to lower it to the $27,800 to match the other companies. So now you've given me the confidence to move forward. Thank you again!
Alex - Homeowner - from 2020
Anlin Malibu Doors and Del Mar Series
Hello, I wanted to ask for your advice. I recently asked for a quote from CAT exteriors to replace my current 13 windows of various sizes and 1 sliding door. They offer me the Anlin del mar series for the windows and the Malibu series for the sliding door all for 16,980 dollars, do you think that's a good deal?
Thank you in advance for any input
Aidee - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Aidee, that bid is definitely on the high side of what I would expect. If the slider is $4K, which is a lot to pay for a slider, that means you are paying $1K per window, which is a also quite a lot.
Now your project may warrant that cost depending on how complex it is, but you would need some more bids to confirm this. Two more bids should be enough. My gut tells me that it’s just a higher than normal bid from the Anlin dealer in your area.
I’d say get a couple more bids, send them to me, and lets go from there!
Tom - Site Editor - from 2020
Anlin Patio Doors vs Milgard
Hi Tim, I am just starting the process of getting bids on replacements for my home in Southern California. We currently have Milgard Style Line series but want to upgrade to a brand that allows for exterior color, has better energy efficiency and style options. So far, I have met with two companies and felt with both like I was dealing with a car salesman. Both vendors went through the window styles etc. but were adamant that I tell them what grid lines I want, exactly what style window I wanted in each of the 44 windows etc. So they could make their bid.
I know that eventually I will need to be very specific about these items but wanted to know how important it was that I have these details available at this part of the bidding process? Will I be able to change my preferences once I decide what vendor to go with or will it affect the price so significantly that I need to have these elements thought out before I meet with the next salesman? Also, what format is a typical estimate given in?
My Anlin dealer simply sent me one number in an email with no detail broken out? When I pushed him for the breakdown of labor, parts, tax he then gave me three numbers. Is that what I should expect from a quote? Shouldn’t they have a window breakdown with sizes, quantities etc? Lastly, when it comes to sliding glass doors do you feel all of the companies you recommend (Milgard, Anlin etc) have the same quality as they do with their windows?
Thank you for your time. This site is really fantastic and I appreciate your honesty and straightforward explanations. I never knew buying windows could be such a process with so many options and details to consider!
With much appreciation,
Christy - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Christy, they should be able to give you a bid with or without grids. Often, they will simply give you a per window cost to add them in. So it's important to review the final work order before it goes out to the factory if you are making changes/upgrades etc. to your order.
The format of estimates is all over the board. Many companies have slick computer programs where they put in the measurements and particulars for each and every window and send that out for the customer to sign off on. That gives them recourse if the customer comes back and complains that they didn't get what they ordered. Other companies are much more slip shod in their work orders. It really is all over the place, depending on who you go with.
I would probably rank the Anlin patio door over the Milgard, but not by much. Both of these over the Simonton, but again not by much.
Feel free to send me the bids and I'll give you my three cents!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Anlin Malibu Sliding Doors vs. Milgard Tuscany Doors
We are looking to replace a wall of doors/ windows in our 40+yr old sunroom addition, which has a pool view facing south in Roseville, CA. The current frames are black aluminum with dual pane glass: 2 (79 × 78) double sliding patio doors on either end , 2 single hungs (75 ×33) on either side of a (75×59) picture window. We have wood framing on all doors and windows on the interior and white painted cement hardiboard framing on the exterior. Even though the room is vented for heat and a/c, the room is warm on winter days, but too cold at night; way too hot during Sacramento summers.
We're not the original owners, so we're not sure of the current manufacturer; the locks on the single hungs say Western Products, the picture window glass has a Milgard Logo etched in the corner, and the Patio doors have a Guardian logo on the glass. We have replaced some of the glass over the years due to fogging in between the panes, but not on the doors; definitely on the single hung, possibly on the picture, but we can't remember.
We received 5 estimates and learned a lot in the process. We honed it down to two bids:
1. Milgard - 2 white vinyl Tuscany sliding patio doors, with Styleline (to maximize sunroom view) on the 2 single hungs and 1 picture window, Comfort package with low E3 glass plus argon, all tempered. Windows will be retrofit, doors will be full frame. $6000.
2. Anlin - 2 White vinyl Malibu sliding patio doors, with either: Panoramic single hungs (2) and picture (1) $5700 OR Malibu door w/ Delmar windows $6500. Infinit-e glass w argon, all tempered. Window and doors to be retrofit (only track removed on patio door. ) I questioned why not full frame on doors, but the assured me not necessary for our installation. They are also throwing in auto locks on single hugs and deadbolts on Patio doors.
Have read your other comments about thinner frame on Styleline and Panoramic, but it is a sunroom and we are worried about the bigger framing on the Delmar.
What you you think about price and products/styles offered.
Christine - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Christine, the pricing sounds about right to me, although it doesn't mean you can't go back and see if they will come down on price. https://www.replacementwindowsreviews.co/review-topics/negotiating-a-home-window-bid.html
I think the Anlin is the better window and sliding door over the Milgard, especially at the price quotes you have. In terms of the Panoramic or Delmar windows, I think the Panoramic is probably the way to go, considering you want the extra glass area because it is a sunroom. The Panoramic is not going to be quite as energy efficient as the Del Mar -- that's the trade off you make with a thinner framed window. However the low-e tempered glass ought to help counter balance this fact.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
General Anlin Windows Reviews
Anlin Windows Dealer
Hi, I live in Los Angeles . I'm wondering if you can recommend reputable Anlin window companies for 13 replacements. It's a 1957 house with original windows so I am looking for single hung and casements. Thanks.
Sil - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Sil, I don't know these guys personally, but they seem to get quite good reviews. Maybe you start out here. https://www.mhiwindows.com/
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Windows Reviews
Hi Dane, thank you for your email. We started off getting quotes for all aluminum and these are attached. We found them very expensive and that made me look around for materials other than wood, aluminum clad or aluminum. Since we are in a high fire risk zone, wood is not a great option for us. We will be off grid so I am now considering composite for greater efficiency.
Out of curiosity I was wondering if zipcode matters to dealers because it seems prices are higher when the zipcode is say Santa Barbara as compared to Santa Maria or Oxnard. Any comments on this? My husband is convinced that pros charge as per zipcodes of the build.
Protima - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Protima, I think the zip codes matter. When the sales person goes out on the job, he is basically trying to make as much money as the market will bear. So if he goes into a more affluent community his thought process is that they are willing to pay more. Getting a number of bids and going back and negotiating can usually get the prices to where they should be. Have you tried Anlin? I will send you my California based recommendations.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Anlin Windows And Other Recommendations
Hello, we were looking at Anlin windows, but making them two tone (white inside; bronze outside) raises the cost by 45% because of some military grade thermal coating (almost $22k more for 7 windows and 2 patio doors)... I know you talk highly of the Anlin, but is there a high quality/premium window that does not charge a such a premium for two tone windows? This is our forever home so we want something that is quality but $50k is too high.
Arturo - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Arturo, I hear you, the darker exterior colors are super expensive if they are not custom. Most are not custom because the darker colors absorb light and the manufacturers worry that the heat over time will affect the frames. Really the only way to find out who carries the colors, styles, materials, etc. that will fit your project is to call up the local companies and ask.
Here are my recommendations: a bid from an Amerimax dealer on their Craftsman Portrait series, a Milgard dealer on their Trinsic series, and a Simonton dealer on their Impressions 9800 or Reflections 5500 series. Do a google search for "[Milgard windows in [your city and state]". Local companies who rep that brand should come up. You might be able to just call and ask about their custom colors and see what they say.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Selig Construction and Anlin
I have a bid from Selig Construction. My neighbor was happy with them, but I'm not sure how to verify their track record otherwise. I like that they have their own staff do the installation...so if there's a problem they can't just blame someone else. Are you familiar with them? [PS: I feel like I might be taking advantage of your time, so don't feel obligated to respond.]
Cassandra - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Cassandra, no problem, happy to help. I did some checking and Selig Construction, which sells Anlin, gets a 4.2 of 32 Google reviews -- not bad
A 2.5 on yelp for 23 reviews -- not good
A 4.5 on 15 ratings from homeadvisor -- pretty good
Kind of mixed reviews...google "Selig Construction" and read up on what people thought of them. You are kind of in mixed territory here. I would continue my search and keep these guys on the back burner.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2021
Anlin Windows Cost
Hi Dane, I attached the original email you sent me just for clarification. I contacted the only local Anlin dealer here by me for replacing one sliding door, two single casements, two standard sized xo windows, two eight foot xox windows and six small upper fixed transoms. I added sound glass to one of the larger windows, one casement and one standard and their sun matrix coating to the slider, the other standard window and three of the transom windows and their quote is just short of 15K.
Four of the windows and the slider have foam/stucco pop outs around them so the dealer said that to retrofit those they would have to use block frames and foam/caulk them. i am not to crazy about that idea since I feel that they will not be secure even though they are screwed in but I have no option short of removing the entire stucco foam trim around those windows and then putting back all new foam, stucco and of course have to repaint and I am sure the cost would be enormous.
Any thoughts on this will be greatly appreciated. I also asked the dealer if Anlin offers any deals on purchasing options and was told never.
Thank you.
Frank - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Frank, the bids I've been seeing from Anlin have all been pretty high lately, and I would say this one is as well. I would like to see one or two more bids in order to compare how they stack up to one another. You have some different configurations of windows and doors so I would expect there to be a bigger variation in price than with a job that requires say 16 double hungs.
Sounds like you have a pretty high bid right now, not outrageous, but at the top of what I'd expect.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2021
Anlin Windows In Denver
Dane, we are about to replace a bunch of large windows in our house near Denver, CO. One major concern is the transporting of Anlin to Colorado and how that may affect argon "filling"... of course anyone pushing Amerimax harps on this. Anlin reps say it's not a concern. Any thoughts?
Matt - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Matt, this question comes up a few times a year and I’m still not an expert. I know it has been a concern in the past, but Anlin has been making and selling in Denver for quite some time now. How are they getting a 5 star review from 307 people on yelp if their windows are flawed from the elevation change. I’m assuming they would have figured out how to deal with this by now...but I can’t say this for sure.
Go get a bid from the Zen dealer in Denver and ask them the same question. They have a great reputation as well from the reviews I’ve seen. They are getting their windows from Soft-Lite so they should be dealing with the exact same issue as Anlin.
I also think there is a Sunrise dealer in Denver and, again, unless they have a plant in Denver, they would be facing the exact same issue.
This may take a bit of detective work on your part. But it never hurts to have some more options. Both great options by the way so you are well on your way!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2021
Anlin ZoE shield Extreme Glass
We live in the Phoenix metro area. We are looking to replace our 23 year old aluminum windows with a vinyl Anlin brand with ZoE shield extreme glass. What do you think? What is a fair price for 47” x 58” Thank You!
Maryanne - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Maryanne, there are roughly 20 factors that can affect the per window price for a project. For a normal sized window like you mention with normal installation, I'd say you are looking at $550 to $725.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
Anlin Windows vs Milgard
We live in the San Fernando Valley near Los Angeles where it's quite hot in the summer. We have some rather large picture fixed frames that need replacing. We're look at either the Milgard Style Line or the Tuscany for picture windows? It isn't so much price as the glass area.
Eric - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Eric, I do prefer the Tuscany over the Styleline, but in terms of picture windows it doesn't make as much of a difference. You may want to look at the Milgard Trinsic line, which just came out in 2018 and is a more modern and streamlined looking window. This might be a nice option for you.
Also take a look at if there is an Anlin dealer or an Amerimax dealer in your area. Either of these brands should serve you well. Make sure to look at that SHGC of each window. You may want to upgrade to a better glass package to reduce the amount of heat coming through the window glass.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Anlin Windows Reviews
I have been looking at windows/sliding door replacements for over a month now. I really like the Anlin after watching their manufacturing process. My hesitation is due to my altitude. They would have to be shipped with the tubes for pressure and I don’t know how I would verify that the tubes were sealed properly after the pressure equalization. Installers seemed to think that they didn’t need to do anything to them, yet my understanding is that moisture could get in if not sealed (info direct from Anlin).
With the Denver area building boom, quality installers are extremely busy, and I’m sure can work on larger jobs, leaving less-qualified installers to fill in. I was told EVERYONE subs out this type of work. Anlin only sells through one company in the Denver area and one company in Colorado Springs (~80 miles away). The one in Denver seems good- just a couple of complaints, but I don’t know if they will be around in a few years.
Would you recommend replacements from a manufacturer that is already at altitude- Amerimax and Milgard? Have you heard of problems with Anlin due to altitude?
Thank you!
Karen - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Karen, I get this question of altitude about once every year and I always muddle together an answer based on anecdotal evidence as opposed to real live experience. I don't live above 6000 feet (nothing like that) and have never dealt with the issue first hand.
I know that if the tubes are done right, there shouldn't be any issues. I agree with you that Anlin is the better manufacturer than Milgard or Amerimax, although I do like the Amerimax Aristocrat casements that I've seen and the reviews associated with them.
Anlin has only relatively recently expanded their operation, but I would say they are a very solid company. I understand your concern and I'm not sure I have a definitive answer for you.
I would probably rely on the Anlin Denver dealer's opinion on the quality and reliability of the tubes. Or go with the best Amerimax window I could find. I think that would be the two options I'd consider. Perhaps the deciding factor would be the history and reviews on the company doing the actual install.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Anlin Windows Reviews In Phoenix
I came across your site and I found a list of energy efficient windows for the Phoenix, Arizona area that are better with our summer heat. Based on the list from the Efficient Windows Collaborative, is there one company that you would recommend over another?
We have 17 windows to replace and we would prefer the most energy efficient, but still at a manageable cost. Thank you for any assistance you may be able to render.
Kind regards.
Sue - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Sue, I took a look at the website you mentioned, but it seemed to includes lots of brands that I don't think are actually available in your area. I might be wrong about this but it seemed like a big long list of window brands, but not really specific to any area.
For Phoenix, I usually recommend Milgard, Amerimax, Anlin, a high end Simonton, or a Marvin.
Aluminum windows are definitely in play because of the hot climate -- Don Young might be available and they make a great aluminum window and a good vinyl window.
Let me know what you find and feel free to send me your bids when you collect them and I'll give you my two cents!
All The Best.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
[Sue's Response]
Hello Dane, thank you so much for your reply. I looked up all 17 of the manufacturers of the double-glazed, low solar gain, low-E glass, argon non-metal, improved windows listed on that site. We wanted to stay away from Aluminum frames as they conduct a great deal of heat (or so we were told) and as that is what we currently have. I saw reviews for both Alpine and Alside - both by Associated Materials and reviews were negative. Same for American Exteriors,LLC and Atrium Windows.
I found that many companies don't have dealers in our area -- such as NT Windows. I did reach out to them via email as they were listed on all three of the top energy efficient listings. Disappointing. There were at least five other companies that are not in our
area too.
Jeld-Wen does have distributors who order from them and install replacement windows as does Renewal by Anderson. We had an Andersen Renewal cost which was outrageous. Do you have any opinions about either of these companies?
I didn't see any of the companies you listed on the energy efficient manufactures listing. Thoughts? Further suggestions?
We have a local window replacement company who orders for Jeld-Wen coming on Friday to give us an estimate. Will keep you posted.
Thanks so much! Kind Regards.
Sue - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Sue, in all honesty Jeld Wen makes great doors, but not very good vinyl windows. They pale in comparison to the three recommendations I made. I'm really not sure what this energy efficient manufactures listing is, but I wouldn't put much stock in it.
Renewal By Andersen bids are always quite high and honestly not worth the expense. The Anlin Del Mar window with a low e glass is going to be just as energy efficient as the Renewal composite frame.
If there were better and more efficient window manufacturers than Milgard, Anlin, and Amerimax on the West Coast, I don't know what they are. Each of these companies offers several window series. I would suggest going with the mid range or premium models, along with a nice low-e glass. Ask all three of them if they offer foam filled frame upgrades or a reinforced sash rail upgrade on their single or double hungs. This is going to get you the most energy efficient window and I would hope you could get it close to the $700 per window price.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Anlin Replacement Windows Series
We are looking into replacing our windows and we got a quote from an Anlin distributor. My question is which is the series that is at the top , Del Mar series? Coronado series? Or Catalina series?
Ines - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Answer]
Ines, Anlin makes three basic series, the Catalina, Del Mar and Coronado. The Catalina is the entry level, the Del Mar is their mid range and the Coronado is the Premium. The company also sells a Monte Verde window that is roughly equal to the Del Mar.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2016
Anlin Windows vs Crystal
I am in the process of deciding what windows to purchase. I had never heard of Anlin until a friend mentioned them. You seem to have high regard for them and I am comparing them to the Milgard Tuscany Based on what I read, you feel it is a toss-up as to which is better and to judge the installers and price as higher priorities. I am in Long Beach, CA
So, there is a company that I want to get your opinion on. Crystal Pacific Windows. Have you heard of them and what can you tell me about them. They seem to be close to half the cost of the Milgard which alone makes me concerned about the quality of the window.
Also, I am looking for a Kitchen / Side yard door and am considering a door with a glass insert and a blind in the glass. This door gets fairly heavy midday sun and minimal afternoon/evening sun.
John - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Answer]
John, I don't know much about Crystal Pacific windows. I did look them up on the nfrc.org website to look at some of their performance numbers and they appear to be okay. I'm sort of assuming that the company like many smaller manufacturers makes a sort of mid range vinyl window that is marketed towards the price conscious consumer. Since you live in Long Beach where the climate is quite mild, I would say you may be just fine with this option. If this is your forever home, however, I would probably advise to go with the Anlin or Milgard, which are proven companies with good track records.
Crystal Pacific does include an accidental glass breakage and limited lifetime warranty (only 10 years on ownership transfers though). Normally, I look at the warranty not as a benefit for the consumer, but as a gauge of what the company thinks of their own product - they seem to be offering a decent product by this gauge.
I think there may be some value in the Crystal Pacific windows, but I would also say that the window is probably going to be weaker than the Anlin/Milgard option.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2016
Anlin Windows Reviews
Anlin products are supposed to be really good, I haven't heard much bad about them. You should always get at least three estimates, for both the windows and the installation. Prices can be surprisingly different, but don't automatically go for the cheapest. Look at the warranties and the kind of service you'll be getting.
David - Window Contractor - from 2011
Anlin Windows vs Milgard
Anlin has a great reputation on the West coast. I wold get a quote from someone like Milgard to compare your current quote to. Some will argue that Milgard products are better and other people like Anlins, I think they're comparable and each make a good window. Either way you should be satisfied, they are sturdy and they look great.
Randy - Window Contractor - from 2011
Top West Coast Window Producers
If I had to rank the top four West Coast window companies, I'd go with
1. Milgard
2. Anlin
3. Atrium
4. Magic
A lot of people like the Anlin better than Milgard, and the only reason I don't is that Anlin is a small producer and with a bad economy you never know if they'll be around in a few years to take care warranty or other problems.
Barry - Installer - from 2010
2nd Response
My favorite window on the West Coast? I like Simonton windows and Amerimax the best, really don't like Atrium and Magic. My top 4 would probably be
1. Simonton
2. Amerimax
3. Milgard
4. Anlin
Granted, I only deal with windows available in Southern California, so if you're somewhere else you might have more (or less) options. These four all have good features and are good quality manufacturing - even so I would always advise consumers to get a few quotes before buying.
Jordan - Contractor - from 2010
Read additional Milgard windows reviews.
Anlin Windows Reviews On American Vision
I knew I wanted Anlin windows, but I was having trouble finding an installer. The first person I turned to gave me a ridiculous price, so I called Anlin and asked what installer they recommend. They told me to call American Vision Windows, and the quote I got when I called them was less than half of what the first guy wanted. The installation was fast and easy. They installed them the day they were delivered. The only problem I had was that they forgot the deadbolts I'd asked for, and I had to call a 2nd time to get them to come put them in. When they did come out, they were really nice and apologetic about it so I wasn't mad. I think they also install Milgard, but I know that they did a good job on my Anlins.
Brett - Homeowner - from 2010
Anlin And American Vision Windows
I just put 18 Anlin windows plus a sliding door in my house. I'm actually happy with the windows themselves, we had American Vision install them and they did a good job. They talk a big game about their devotion to customer service, but they don't seem to care about fixing problems once they have your money. I'd get Anlin again, but I will definitely use a different installer.
Ron - Homeowner - from 2007
Advise For Window Seller
I'm in Birmingham, Alabama now and most of what I sell is double pane, low-e and argon with triple glazed glass. It doesn't get super cold here but the heat in summers can be brutal. When I lived in Northern California pretty much everything was Anlin, I guess because it was close by. They're a good brand, I never had any customers complain about them. One problem that some people have is with stucco homes. Installers want an easy job so they keep the old frame and just put in new glass. There's nothing wrong with that if your frames are good and the homeowner knows that's what's happening, but I've seen some dishonest installers pull a fast one. Pay attention to what they're doing on your house.
Daryl - Installer - from 2007
Anlin vs Polybau Windows
Polybau and Anlin both make really good windows. I think they're way better than Simonton or anything sold at HD (Home Depot). They offer a slightly larger extrusion and a better spacer too. Their air leakage is way better than Simontons. They are both good windows. I like Anlins a lot, they really are a good window. They can be pricey, but if you're smart you can get a good deal. Salespeople are always talking special offers and phony discounts, but if you find an installer with some good references you can usually get a reasonable price. Make sure to get quotes from several people before signing with anyone.
Barry - Industry Insider - from 2006
Additional Reviews: Reliabilt Windows Reviews