Home : Replacement Windows Comparisons : Anlin Windows vs Milgard
Anlin vs Milgard Windows
Anlin Windows vs Milgard - how do these two brands stack up against one another. Let's take a closer look and compare on company structure, what they sell, how they market, and their overall window price point.
Bottom Line: The big difference between what these two companies sell is that Anlin is only in the vinyl window market, while Milgard also makes an aluminum and fiberglass windows. (They used to make a wood-clad, but eventually they got out of that market - probably because their consumer reviews were pretty poor for the wood clad.)
Dane - Site Editor - Original Publish Date - February 21, 2024
Page Last Updated In 2025
Please note, our website is not affiliated with either of these companies.
Anlin Window Prices: $$$/$$$$
(3/4 out of 5)
(Amongst All Vinyl Windows)
Page Sections
- Head To Head Introduction
- Company Information
- What They Sell
- Marketing Approaches
- Anlin vs Milgard Cost
- Homeowner Reviews
Get Our Recommended Window List
Also please consider filling out the free form on our site for 3 quality window price quotes — it’s how we afford to provide free consumer information. We’re not incentivized by ANY company and will help you with ANY questions you might have, and help you navigate ANY bids you receive. That’s our guarantee to you!
Company Information
Anlin Windows And Doors is a west coast company that, up until 2021, was a family owned business out of Clovis, California. They have always had a good reputation for making quality vinyl window and doors. In fact, I still contend that they are the best brand in the western half of the country In 2021, the company sold to PGT Innovations (PGT Windows And Doors), which along with companies like MI (or MITER), have been gobbling up smaller window companies with some consistency. Anlin’s quality has not been affected or changed in any way since their acquisition, so consumers can be happy about that.
Milgard Windows And Doors has been around since the late 1950 and has manufacturing facilities in Temecula, Sacramento, Simi Valley (all California locations), as well as Tacoma Washington and Prescott Arizona. This west coast based company was acquired by MI Windows (MITER) back in 2018 (I believe this was the year, but I might be a bit off.) In this way they are like Anlin in the consolidation that has occurred in the industry.
Similar to Anlin, Milgard’s production and manufacturing does not seem to be affected by their new ownership. However, unlike Anlin, the Milgard product lines now carry aslightly different titles. So, for instance, the (Milgard Tuscany series is now known as the V400 Tuscany. This is a branding redo and nothing else - plus they kept the series name.
"Anlin has always had a good reputation for making quality vinyl window and doors. In fact, I still contend that they are the best brand in the western half of the country."
Anlin Windows vs Milgard Lineup
Anlin is an interesting example for what they sell. The company has their standard vinyl windows — the Catalina, the Coronado, the Del Mar and the Panoramic series. All quite good options that are small offshoots of one another. The Del Mar is their premium series fyi. They also sell a quality sliding patio door with their Malibu series.
Here’s where Anlin’s product line gets interesting. They sell a series of “independent labeled windows”. By this, I mean they aren’t listed on their website, but the series have their own websites and distributors (local window companies that actually sell the windows.) The funny thing is that even on the window series’ websites, it’s difficult to suss out that Anlin manufactures the product.
The vinyl window series names are as follows: the Mar Vista, the Monte Verde window, and the Ali’I Extreme. The first two are sold as more budget alternatives to Anlin’s primary window series. The last one is sold in Hawaii - and I believ it’s a quality series in general, although I don’t hear about it as often as I’d like in order to form a better opinion.
Like Anlin, Milgard sells quite a number of different series of windows and doors. These include their vinyl series (notice the V in front of the series name) — V250 Styleline, the V300 Trinsic, the V400 Tuscany, and the V450 Homemaker. They also sell the C650 Ultra fiberglass windows (C apparently stands for composite, although I’m rather certain that the Ultra is a fiberglass window), and the A250 Aluminum series. All of these series are available in patio sliding doors.
Anlin Windows Reviews
How They Market
Anlin follows a pretty traditional sales and marketing approach, which is to use a network of local window companies to sell their products. This is the way most companies sell their products, as opposed to using a direct-to-consumer apporach as do companies like Universal Windows Direct or Apex Energy Solutions. The other approach, which Anlin doe not use, is to sell through retail stores such as Home Depot, Lowes, and Menards.
By using a distribution network, Anlin can reach a ton of consumers, without having to have “boots on the grounds” - as is the case with a direct to consumer approach. So, for instance, a company might sell the Milgard Tuscany series, Anlin Del Mar windows, as well as Marvin fiberglass windows. This provides consumers with different options and price points.
Milgard sells in almost the exact same manner as Anlin, using these dealer networks. In this regard the two companies are nearly identical.
Anlin Windows vs Milgard Costs
Anlin window prices are a 6 to 8 on a scale of 1 to 10 on the vinyl windows cost range. Their more budget minded series - the Mar Vista and Monte Verde should fall in that 6 range. Conversely, their Catalina, Coronado, and Panaramic should fall into that 7 range, and their premium Del Mar series will be in that 8 price range.
Of course, these are simply price estimates and can vary by your location and project specifics. My advice is to collect a few bids from local companies in order to better understand the fair market price of your project.
Milgard windows prices for vinyl are 5 to 8 on a scale of 1 to 10. Their Styleline is a 5, while their Homemaker is an 8. Their Ultra is probably a 7 on a scale of 1 to 10 for the fiberglass windows cost range. To be honest, I’m sure how they price out their aluminum series. If I were to guess, I’d put it at a 7 as well.
Anlin Windows vs Milgard Reviews
Explore our homeowner question and answer session regarding these two window and patio door companies
Dane - Site Editor
Have a question on Anlin Windows vs Milgard? Hit me up. dane@replacementwindowsreviews.co
Aluminum vs Vinyl Windows
Hi Dane, I've had two similar bids from 2 companies. Unfortunately, I'm restricted to an anodized bronze frame color by my HOA. Specifically, I need 4 sliding doors, 72 x 80 for condo. The Anlin would have to be painted to satisfy the HOA. Also, how well does that hold up? Lastly, is the Anlin product worth $4000 difference? Thanks for your help.
Milgard A250 - $13800.00
Anlin Malibu- $17800.00
Cathy - Homeowner - from 2025
[Site Editor's Answer]
Cathy, my own personal opinion is that the Milgard is the better overall value compared to the Anlin Malibu. $1000 per patio door more for the Anlin seems excessive to me. As long as you don't live in an extreme climate, I would say that the Milgard product will perform well.
However, if this is your forever home, then I think it makes sense to consider the Anlin as I do think it will hold up better in year 20 to 30 and beyond. Also, I wouldn't mind seeing a couple more bids as comparison, but I do think you have two good options so far. I have a list of options if you do want to continue your search.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2025
American Vision Windows Bid
Can you please provide a list of dealers for Anlin Dealers? I went to American Vision Windows and Approved Contractor. I really like Anlin Windows. One company recommended Catalina and the other is for Del Mar. Which is a better windows? I am ordering 8 windows (4 windows are extra heat protection). The price is about $10K. I live on the border of Los Angeles and Ventura County. I am trying to find the best price and service for my money. Also do you know the lead time for the windows?
What can I expect regarding payment. Do I need to give a deposit, pay the windows upfront? Also I got a quote for about 6K for Milgard. Thank you for your time and all of your great info!
Melanie - Homeowner - from 2024
[Site Editor's Answer]
Melanie, the only other Anlin dealer I can think of in that same area would by California Deluxe. If that doesn't pan out I would go directly to the Anlin website and see if you can't get them to give you a list of dealers in your area. The Del Mar is the better window over the Catalina - here is my write up on the Catalina from the site --
The Anlin Catalina is the company mid range vinyl windows. It uses a 2 and 7/8 inch frame depth, .80 inch frame thickness, equal sightlines, the Elite spacer, double strength glass and a single vent latch. The Catalina can be ordered in 14 exterior color options, 2 glass package options, 5 hardware options, 3 grid patters and 2 casing configurations. This window is available in a single slider, single hung
The Catalina series differs from the Del Mar series in the following ways: the Del Mar series has the Innergy thermal reinforcement, ultra-strong fiberglass thermal inserts to strengthen the sash and frame, and Comfort•Core—green foam injections into the window frames to maximize energy efficiency. I would give the Anlin Catalina a 4.4 out of 5 stars rating.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2024
Anlin v Milgard
Hey guys, was wondering if you could kind of do a brand breakdown for me. I have bids from Anlin on their Panoramic and Coronado series. I also have a bid on the Milgard Tuscany. The prices are roughly the same although the Anlin is about $1500 more, but it is for 25 windows, so the price isn’t that big a concern for me unless it just doesn’t make sense in your opinion. I live in Dana Point California. I would love to get your two cents.
Trina - Homeowner - from 2024
[Site Editor's Answer]
Trina, while Milgard is definitely a reputable brand when coupled with professional installation, it isn’t quite up to par with Anlin. I would say that the Coronado and Panoramic window series the superior options over the Tuscany. Not to say that I don’t like the Tuscany, it is a decent performer, but it isn’t quite what the Anlin is in terms of overall craftsmanship and quality. I would definitely pay the additional $1500, and guess the better window, specially if your timeline in the home is anything over 5 to 7 years.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2024
Del Mar SEries vs Trinsic
Hi Dane, we live just outside of Tucson Arizona in a received several quotes that I’d love to get your take on. This is for new construction and it includes two horizontal sliders and three picture windows. The quote on the Anlin Delmar series was $4700 and that included everything, we also had a quote from Milgard on their Trinzic series and that was $4200.
By the way, I’m rounding everything to the nearest hundred dollars. I’m sure that you understand. Finally, we got a Renewal by Andersen cost quote and that was $7900. Since this is out of our budget, my question was how do compare the Anlin Windows vs Milgard?
Betsy - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Betsy, I would say that the Renewal bid is probably high, but they do make a very pretty window. If that's something that you want to pursue, I would say that for that product, and for the bids that I see from that company, that’s probably a decent deal. I would say the best long-term value in those three options is probably the Anlin Delmar option.
It’s a pretty fair price, depending on how large the windows are, but for full frame or new construction installation, that’s not a bad price at all. I would consider the Milgard option if and only if the company doing the installation has really really good reviews. I hope that helps!
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Denver Replacement Windows
Hi Dane, I have read a lot of information on the website and it has been really great. I've also read a lot of the question/reply streams, which have also been great. I am planning to replace some windows in my house here i nthe Denver metro area. I have quotes from an Installer I trust. Here is the information of both estimates:
For some reason I couldn't paste the screenshot for the Milgard Tuscany estimate, but at least you can see the specifics of what i'm ordering. The Milgard estimate for the same products came in at $10,162. I am very noise-sensitive and am tired of listening to every little thing that goes on outside my house, so I have opted for the sound reduction glass in both brands estimates.
I believe this will be the double pane "dissimilar thickness" style glass for both Anlin Windows vs Milgard. So, the Milgard quote is about $680 more total, but I don't consider that enough of a difference to be a major factor in deciding between the two. My Installer has more experience installing Milgard, but has a better "working relation" with his Anlin contact. My installer has done a nice job of being unbiased and is probably right to say that I'd probably be happy with either brand.
I am trying to find that key piece of data or item of consideration that could tip me over to make the decision to go with one brand over the other. I did read your information about negotiating the estimate and I will certainly do that shortly. My sense is that negotiating through Anlin may be easier for my Installer since as I alluded to earlier, he has a better working relationship with him, but i don't want to incorrectly assume anything. Thanks in advance for your advice!
Eric - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Eric, for me, when it comes to Anlin Windows vs Milgard. I think Anlin is better made and tend to have less batch issues over Milgard. I also happen to like the look of the Anlin Catalina over the Tuscany. If this were project, I'd go for the Anlin Catalina and you get to save $700 :). That's my take for what it's worth!
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Related Topics: Window Replacement Costs
Milgard Trinsic vs Tuscany