Home : Replacement Windows Reviews : Simonton 5500 Series
Simonton 5500 Windows Reviews And Prices
Read Simonton 5500 windows reviews from consumers, homeowners and our site editors.
Series Information: The 5500 Reflections series is one of the company's better vinyl windows, although it has become a little dated. It is the top-of-the-line Reflections series and offers several addtional features and certainly more options than the 5300 and 5050 Series. The 5500 is nearly identical to the Simonton 6500 series sold at HD. (More on Home Depot Simonton Windows.)
Bottom Line: The 5500 Reflections series is generally regarded as the company's best vinyl window option, along with the Simonton Impressions window. Definitely consider this window series if the company doing the work has good online reviews and the price point seems reasonable.
Dane - Site Editor - Page Last Updated: August 27, 2025
Quick Links
Simonton Windows Prices
Simonton Windows Review
Get Our Recommended Window List
Also please consider filling out the free form on our site for 3 quality window price quotes — it’s how we afford to provide free consumer information. We’re not incentivized by ANY company and will help you with ANY questions you might have, and help you navigate ANY bids you receive. That’s our guarantee to you!
dane@replacementwindowsreviews.co
Simonton 5500 Reviews
The 5500 series is the "premium" Reflections model that may also be referred to the Prism Platinum window. Simonton labels their window series differently in different regions of the country, which doesn't always make for a clear consumer experience. Compared to the 5300 Reflections model, the 5500 window uses a slightly sturdier vinyl frame, and shadow-grooved sash welds.
It comes standard with Super 366 glass, a Super Spacer, and a better sill. Most industry experts that I talk to think the 5500 is a slightly better looking overall window. As with most premium models, the 5500 offers lots of upgrades including triple pane glass, wood-grain interiors, and an optional two-tone finish. It comes in any number of styles, sizes and finishes. I would give the Simonton 5500 Series Window a 4.4 out of 5 stars rating.
Dane - Site Editor
5500 Series vs Mezzo
Hey Dane, I have 2 bids I am considering for my window replacements. I have about 30-34 windows depending on how they count them. 4 present windows are becoming 2 picture windows. 4 other picture windows are like 43x96. Both bids are from companies that
Have high quality installers per a friend in the business.
One is around 29k for the Allside Mezzo mostly single hung.
Then there is the Simonton 5500 reflections which is about $4000 more at 33k.
He quoted the Allside double hung at $30,200. We weren’t sure about the double hung and the Simonton looks nice but a lot of framing and kinda old style (me thinking and reviews). The 26k bid also can add a CWS 8800 series 2 panel sliding door (111x81) for $4500. The 29k bid quoted a PGT slider for the space at $6200. He said the CWS and PGT are very similar doors. I get the sense the Mezzo isn’t your favorite. Would love to get your thoughts on it all. Thank you so much for your time.
Danny - Homeowner - from 2024
[Site Editor's Answer]
Danny, you are correct that I don't love the Mezzo, unless you are planning to be in the home for say 12 years of less. It's not a bad window at all, but it's not quite as good as the Reflections 5500 series in my opinion. I would say that the price upgrade between those two is about what I would expect. I understand about the bulky frame. If this were my project and I was planning to stay in the home more than 12 years, I would get a few more bids to round out these two options.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2024
Simonton Windows Reviews On The 5500
I just found your website & its a wonderful resource. My Mom needs to replace 18 windows in her forever home. She got multiple bids for Simonton 5500 series which came out to be $13,608; however, one bidder said she would be better off with the Great Lakes Comfort Smart series which he could do at $11,250. I’m paying for the windows and I want her home to have the highest quality as well as pretty appearance that will not fade - I’m prepared to pay for the best.. Would love your thoughts - so kind of you to respond, assuming you do :). It would be wonderful if you might also send a copy of your ratings list on various windows (and doors if you do those too).
A big “thank you” from two old gals in Georgia!
Sharon - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Hi Sharon, thanks for the kind words. So the Simonton 5500 series is a nice solid window, as well as the Great Lakes Comfort Smart. Solid price quotes also. These are both what I would say are good mid range windows -- there should be some top tier options in Georgia, but you might have to do a bit of searching -- happy to help out!
Here are my Atlanta recommendations (hopefully some will be available in your neck of the woods):
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Replacement Windows In Orlando
Thanks so much, Tim! This info is immensely helpful. I did use the price quote page on your form, so hope that helps! I don’t think I’ll end up with that company (WindowWall) unfortunately though. Here are the quotes I have so far, would love an opinion (I think it might be the same as mine):
Orlando, Fl for 9 vinyl, double-pane windows, two tempered, three gridded:
Pella single-hung: $13,329
EAS single-hung: $12,249
CWS Aria 610 single-hung: $8880.20
Simonton Reflections 5500 double-hung (but in the 5050 series frame for aesthetics according to the company. I didn’t get the idea that this was a cost-cutting measure, but more of a design choice): $7850
Alside Mezzo single-hung: $8182
I found it hard to get a PGT quote as there seemed to be only one distributor in my area according to their site, and they wouldn’t get back to me. I didn’t find any of the other distributors in my area.
I’m leaning towards the Simonton quote, and that company also had the best reviews for customer service and installation and happened to have the best price also. They were also the only double-hung windows on the list, which might be a benefit even though I don’t think it matters too much to me.
I really appreciate your opinion!
Rick - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Rick, I agree with you that the Simonton 5500 is the best option -- it's the least expensive and the company had the best reviews. That's a good combo right there :) PGT has been weird over the past couple of years -- they make a good window, but their supply chain has been pretty wonky. I think all in all, you have a very solid option. The CWS would be my back up choice.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Simonton 5500 vs. Alside Mezzo
Do you think Simonton 5500 is good enough for a rental property? I haven't get a quote and don't know how much higher it would be compare to 5050. Here is the quote for Alside Mezzo. Sounds like it's not worth to try that route?
Jing - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Jing, Simonton is my much preferred brand over Alside. The 5050 is one of the entry level windows, while the 5500 has some nice upgrades -- I'd stick to Simonton's higher end series myself...
Jing, I didn't realize it was for a rental property -- the 5500 is definitely good enough for a rental property. The Mezzo quote is higher than I would expect, but the reviews on Austin Pro Siding and Windows seem to be excellent. You're usually going to pay for an exceptional company due to their demand. Honestly, the Simonton 5050 is probably good enough for a rental property as long as the install is done well...
I'll send you my list of recommended window brands for Texas.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Simonton Windows vs Wincore
Hi Dane, I have a quota on 19 DH windows
Wincore 7700 and / or Simonton 5500 Reflections both at same price 11,400.00
Which window should I use? This includes install and wrapping
Thanks.
Carlos - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Carlos, these are virtually the same window. I would make my decision here by choosing the installation company with the best reputation and online reviews. This is going to make a bigger difference than these two very close windows. If it's the same installation company, then I would go with the Simonton 5500 over the Wincore 7700.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Simonton 5500 Series vs. Wincore 5400 Series
Dear Sir, what is your opinion on the quality of the Wincore 5400 replacement window vs. the Simonton 5500?
We were disappointed with Vista windows we had installed about 5 years ago. Six shashes went bad in the first two years and we had them replaced. Another seven have failed (gas is leaking from within the panes and they are spotting), but Vista has since gone out of business. So we want to replace them.
The contractor who installed the Vista windows has offered us deal on 17 Wincore 5400 windows (plus a sliding patio door) for approximately $9900. Another contractor offered approximately $13,500 for the Simonton 5500. Is there a big difference in the quality of the windows? Are the Simonton windows worth the extra cost?
We live in northern Virginia in the Washington DC area. We understand Wincore is a relatively newer company (people who left Simonton). We do not want to be left with a situation like we had with Vista.
We would welcome your insight.
Regards.
Kurt - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Kurt, I would probably put the Simonton 5500 series over the Wincore 5400 series. By how much -- probably about what your price difference is. Very good price on the Wincore 5400 for 17 windows and a sliding glass door. I think it would depend how long I plan to stay in my home and the overall quality and workmanship from each of the contractors.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2021
Simonton vs Milgard
Hi Dane, I replaced the west facing windows of my Henderson, NV home with Renewal By Anderson. Approx. 3 years ago.
While the windows perform well, I don’t feel like they are significantly different than the Milgard one that started the whole project. (Baseball thru the window.)
I would like to complete the entire home with replacement windows, but…I do feel gouged by RBA. No matter what incentives they have, it’s the same cost. Expensive. $4000 for a 5’X4’. I had the salesman break down my costs and when I saw the $2000 price for a 35X23 bathroom window, plus the fact that he said any bathroom window needed special glass? it was an easy no thank-you.
Meanwhile, I’m so confused over what to order: fibrex, vinyl, composite.
We have extreme heat during the summer months and I know that we need a great, durable product.
Thank you for your help.
Kerry - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Kerry, RBA is often very pricey and not worth the cost in my estimation. I think a high quality vinyl window or an aluminum window in very hot climates is probably the way to go. However, I'm very specific in the aluminum windows I would recommend and none sell in the Vegas area. Therefore, I would stick with these options myself: a bid from an Amerimax dealer on their Craftsman Portrait series, a Simonton dealer on their Reflections 5500 or Impression 9800 series, a Milgard dealer on their Trinsic or Tuscany series, and a Universal Windows on their Unishield Plus or Premium series.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2021
Simonton 5500 Cost Quotes
Dane, thanks for your recent response on this site to my question about “cellular PVC” windows. I now have the quotes from five local installers here in the Atlanta area. In order to interpret the table of quotes below, understand that I have a total of 31 windows to replace, all of which are included on each row of the table below.
Twenty-nine (29) of these are DH windows. The other 2 are picture windows which are priced roughly the same for each installer. Of the 29 DHs, 22 are on the main floor. Although we are interested primarily in price for these, appearance and long life are also important for them. The remaining 7 of the 29 DH windows are in rooms that are now no longer used, so our sole interest in them is price. All quotes in the table below are for all 29 DH windows, plus the 2 picture windows.
So, for Installer 1, they provided three quotes for the Slocumb 143 windows:
One for “capping” all 29,
One for installing new, complete exterior PVC molding on the 22 main floor windows and capping the remaining 7,
One for installing new, complete exterior PVC molding on all 29 windows.
And, for Installer 4, their quotes reflect:
One quote for doing all 29 DH windows with the Polaris EnergyWall EnergyTech line windows
One quote for doing all 29 DH windows with the Polaris Series 3000 (lower price point) windows
One quote for doing the 22 main floor windows with the EnergyWall EnergyTech windows and the remaining 7 with the Series 3000 windows.
All quoted windows are Energy Star certified for our area of the country. Also, all the windows are in the shade essentially all day, so the SHGC is not particularly critical, but the U-Value and Air Infiltration metrics are. No interest financing is also a plus and I have info on its availability for each vendor.
Can you please provide your thoughts on the estimates in the table, given the factors I’ve described evaluating the quotes? Also, what are some of the installation-related issues that I need to question/”remind” the installers about? The installers all have good online ratings.
Slocomb 143 Cost Quote: $14,825
Vinylmax Franklin Cost Quote: $15,325
Great Lakes ComfortSmart Cost Quote: $16,444
Simonton 5500 Cost Quote: $23,076
Polaris EnergyWall Cost Quote: $22,087
ProVia Endure Cost Quote: $20,500
ProVia Ecolite Cost Quote: $19300
Sandy - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Sandy, I would rate the ProVia Endure at $20,500 the top pick and the ProVia Ecolite at $19300 right below it. The Endure is going to have the best U-value and air infiltration of the bunch. It's quite a good window. The Ecolite is just below it.
The Polaris EnergyWall at $22,087 would be my third option.
If I were staying in the home 10 years or less, my decision would change and I would go with the Great Lakes ComfortSmart $16,444 and save myself $3600.
Of course, the companies doing the work and their online reviews and reputation would have to factor into these choices, so do your due diligence on this point as well.
Great job on getting all of those bids -- a good grouping to be sure!
Dane - Site Editor - from 2021
Simonton 5500 Series vs. Wincore 7700
Hi Tim, I am looking for 19 vinyl double hung windows to replace existing metal windows. I want to spend 300 per window + 100 for installation.
Can you please tell which brand and series of windows are good?
By reading feedback on your website, I want to compare simonton, polaris and okna. Please advise.
When I visited local distribution stores like ABC, Allied Supplies, Universal. They are showing Simonton, Vwinco, MI etc brands.
Thanks for your help.
Srini - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Srini, $400 per window installed probably won't get you a Polaris or Okna. It might get you a decent Simonton. MI and Viwinco are, for the most part, lower end products. A good vinyl window will run more in the $500 to $600 range, but you might get a bargain price if you get a bunch of bids and find one that is exceptional. Here is my "good" list.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
[Srini's Reply]
Hi Dane, so I am calling distribution companies like ABC in my area for material quote. Hoping that I can hire a contractor for installation to save moeny.
I got following windows specification from ABC.
Quote is 250 for 1 window and 525 for double window as mentioned below.
I am not sure about R value, U value SHGC etc. Are above prices good for wincore 7700. Salesperson mentioned the same cost for Simonton 5500 also. I am trying to get other quotes as you mentioned below.
If prices are same for wincore 7700 and simonton 5500, which one is better to choose?
Thanks
Srini - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Srini, both the Wincore 7700 and Simonton 5500 are quite good vinyl windows. I'm actually surprised to hear you can buy those in the bigger box stores. That's great. Prices are good as well.
Windows are very close in quality and craftsmanship, I'm not sure it makes much difference which one you get. Now, if you can find a good installer who charges $150 per window, then you are at your $400 per window.
That's a great price for either one of those windows. Installers often have more experience with one window or another so they might have a preference, which is why I'd find a reputable installer before you buy the window itself. You can try yelp and craigslist or ask ABC to recommend their very best installer.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Simonton 5500 vs. Earthwise Series 7700i
Hello, Dane…
I would appreciate your opinion on the Insulator Series model 700i, installed by WeatherMaster, based in Baltimore, MD. Earth wise Innovative Energy Efficient window model 7700i. The brochure indicates Independent Lab Test Results U-Factor 0.22, SHGC 0.18 and VT .41 We received a quote of $6600 for 11 double hung windows. The other window we were considering is the Simonton 5500, with a quote of the exact same price. What do you think would be the better choice for us? We live in Gaithersburg, Maryland.
Michele - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Michele, I don't know a lot about Earthwise, but they seem like a pretty fair outfit. The 7700i does seem to be one of their better windows, although it's difficult to suss out actual models on their website. Based on the performance data you are citing, I'm assuming that is correct. That's a pretty fair price on the 11 windows.
I have to say I'm much more comfortable with the Simonton 5500 series, which is quite a solid window. $600 is about what I'd expect, right in the middle of the price range. If this were my decision, I would probably take a hard look at the people doing the work and make my judgement based on who I felt would do the better job. Window wise, I would gravitate towards the Simonton over the Earthwise window, but again that's based on the fact that I have much more experience with Simonton.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
Simonton Reflections 5500 vs. Vytex Potomac
We're in Maryland and need to replace fifteen double hung windows. So far, we have three quotes and would love to hear your thoughts.
Vytex Potomac (Window Nation): $11,250
Simonton Reflections 5500 (Home Depot): $10,995
Reliabilt 3900 (Lowes): $6,875
Joseph - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Joseph, I would toss the low quote from Lowes on the Reliabilt. This isn't going to give you the long term value you should be looking for. The Simonton Reflections 5500 is a solid window, but not based on how close it is to the first bid. Have you looked at our page on Simonton windows reviews? That's a good place to start.
The Vytex Potomac-hp for an extra $200 is the best value bid of the bunch. I'd like to see you get that bid down though. I would suggest going back to Window Nation and see if they can sharpen the pencils and get the bid lower. We have an article in the upper right box that talks about how to renegotiate your bids. This might help you through this process. Best of luck!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Simonton Reflections 5500 Price Quote
Hi Tim, what are your thoughts on Window Capping? Is it worth $20/30 extra per window? Looking at the Simonton Reflections 5500. Also, I have a bid for Simonton Reflections 5500 at $468 window including the upgrade sensor glass package. At what price point do you think it would be "worth" it to upgrade to a Sunrise Classic / Standard window. We have lead paint so that complications matters and is included in the Simonton pricing already. Thanks.
Daniel - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Daniel, (window capping is certainly worthwhile if you are worried about your outside wood trim and want to protect it. Some people really like the original look of the trim and others feel strongly about protecting the wood from potential rot down the road. I think it boils down to the condition of the trim, your home maintenance schedule, and the aesthetic considerations. As to cost, the price you were quoted is about the going rate, so that's fair.
The Simonton Reflections 5500 at $468 per window with an upgraded glass is a very fair price as well. So I'd say the Sunrise Classic is the slightly better and slightly nicer looking window of the two. I'd put the under over at maybe $520 per window. If you could get the Sunrise Classic for the $520 I would go for it. Anything over, stick with the Simonton. The Reflections 5500 with an upgraded glass package for $468 is pretty darn good. Assuming the company has a good track record, it's a strong bid.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Simonton vs Great Lakes
Hello. I wanted to say thank you for creating this website. It Is helpful especially when each vendor says their brand is the best! I wanted to get your advice on quotes. All quotes come from reputable local companies and I would use any one, so it comes down to the best value for the price.
I have 20 windows. The quotes were $10,000 for Great Lakes ComfortSmart windows, $11,000 for Simonton Reflections 5500, $13,500 for Soft-lite Classic, and $14,200 for Sunrise Essentials. I know soft-lite and sunrise is the best window on the list, but do you think it is worth the price premium? Thank you
Daniel - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Hi Daniel, thanks for the question and good for you for getting a nice swath of bids. So your most expensive bid, the Sunrise Essentials, is the lowest quality window on your list. The Essentials is actually Sunrise's entry level window and, although good for an entry level window, it is not up to par to the rest on your list. So we can toss that one.
The Great Lakes ComfortSmart window is a decent mid range window and certainly one to consider if the installation company stands out in your estimation over the other companies.
I like the other two bids quite a bit. I would put the Simonton Reflections 5500 (one of Simonton's premium window) close to the Soft-lite Classic (Soft-Lite's mid range offering). So assuming an equal footing in terms of the company doing the install, the Simonton is going to offer the best value between these two.
I think the Simonton bid probably offers the best value of the bunch.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Simonton 5500 Bid
I need to replace 2 picture windows and 15 double hungs. I live near the coast in South Carolina. I have a quote from Simonton 5500 for $8.9K. I also have a quote from Sunrise on their Coastal window option. That bid is 12K.
Walt - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Walt, both the Simonton 5500 quote for $8.9K and the Sunrise Coastal bid for $12K are decent enough sounding bids. I think I would see if there is any movement for price reductions from either one.
My own choice would have to be the Sunrise Coastal series, but the Simonton 5500 window is a strong performer as well.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Simonton 5500 Series Bid
Dane/Tim, good lord… Now that I found your site, it’s now driving me even more crazy with the choices & pricing comparisons maze….
I received several quotes from several different local window replacement companies, that came with several different replacement window manufacturers.
The dwelling is a duplex, ground level rental on a horse farm in NJ. 15 windows need to be replaced. The structure was probably built in 1980.
I was quoted the following vinyl window replacement prices:
Marvin Windows (Integrity) - $20,500
American Craftsman 70 Series - $8,690
Tribuilt Windows (Pro Series) - $17,695
Alside Windows (Mezzo) - $13,920
Simonton 5500 Reflections - $11,500
Okna DH500DX/INSUL-TEC Double hung windows - $11,420
United 4800 series - $9,034
United 8000 Series - $9,728
Simonton 5500 Series - $7,872
North East 1000DS series - $6,665
North East 1000 series - $6,340
Please let me now your thoughts on all of these window manufacturers & the quoted prices.
Kellan - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Wow, way to go get that many quotes, that's impressive. There are two that stand out. The first is the Okna DH500DX/INSUL-TEC Double hung windows for $11,420. This is what I would go with if it was my main house and I planned on being here for a long time.
But you said rental house. If that's the case and you are planning on keeping it a long time but not living there yourself, I might go with the Simonton 5500 Series for $7,872. This is assuming that whoever is doing the install has solid reviews. (How interesting is it that you got two Simonton bids for the EXACT same window and they were almost $4,000 apart!)
I don't know anything about North East Windows so I can't say anything about them. I suppose I might consider this low bid if I were using it as a rental and planned on selling the property soon.
Okna makes great vinyl windows that are really top quality. It's not the cheapest quote, but it's the best quality. The Simonton 5500 series is a solid window as well, but more of a second tier instead of a first tier vinyl window.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
[Kellan's Reply]
The $4,000 Simonton difference really did throw me for a loop...
One thing I do know about the North East brand is that a window retailer who’s been in the business for 23 years says he’s had to battle in court with them I believe on 2 separate occasions. Other than that, I don’t know much else. I have not, but think I’m going to take a look at a sample, as I’ve not yet seen one.
Other than that, every window sample I’ve seen, they all seem not too dissimilar. & I actually found the United brand to be quite likable.
You didn’t comment on that one. Anything?
But what I’ve noticed lately since I’ve been shopping for Windows, is that half of the reviews are usually about how much a window sucks, & the other half are the latter,, in the end a decision has to just has to be made.
I think I’m going to get one more Simonton series quote, just to see what price pops up.
Other than that,. I can’t thank you enough for your reply & feedback.
Kellan - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
I would avoid the United Windows, their products are subpar in my opinion. Problems with lower end manufacturers always start cropping up in year 5, 6, 7, etc. Kind of like buying a car. Plus the Simonton 5500 is less expensive.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Simonton 5500 Complaint
Hi Dane. My husband and I are shopping for new vinyl windows. We have a 2 story colonial with a brick front and vinyl siding on the remaining exterior walls. We had all of our windows replaced 14 years ago with Simonton 5500 vinyl double hung windows. The 2 issues we’ve had with Simonton has been popped seals and the nylon cams and balances (?) breaking. Quite annoying as they are not easy to replace.
Based on the research we have done, there’s not all that much difference in energy savings between Simonton 5500, Harvey Tribute/Classic, and Okna 500. So what it comes down to in making a choice for us is the balance mechanism used by each manufacturer.
Harvey has a pulley balancing system (we have one Harvey classic in the kitchen window box) and the Simonton has a nylon cam with a metal strip balancer. Sorry if my terms are not technically accurate. What I need to know is what balancing system does the Okna 500 double hung vinyl window use? And I would also like to know your opinion on each type and how reliable they are in terms of how long they should last.
Any insight you can provide would be appreciated.
Deb - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Deb, sorry to hear about your issues with the Simonton 5500 series, it's one of their better windows to be sure. Have you reached out to any Simonton dealers near you to see if you can fix what you have? Maybe get a bid from a Simonton dealer under false pretenses to make sure they show up and then grill him on fixes to your windows (don't repeat my somewhat duplicitous advise).
Assuming that doesn't work or you don't want to go down that road, the Okna 500 is the better window than the Harvey Tribute or Simonton 5500. The Okna uses a block and tackle balance or (cord balance system). Honestly, I think there are pros and cons to the two main balance systems and well made windows can use either and should perform equally as well.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Simonton 5500 Series In Denver
Hi Dane and Tim, I thought I’d get in touch with you two as I’m having a really hard time deciding on replacement windows. I have a 1952 house with original metal, single paned, casement windows. I decided to cash out on some of my equity and update the things on my house that need it and windows is (or was) on my list.
I had a quote from someone 3 years ago, when I moved in, for $6,000 for all 10 windows in my house. I figured today it might be a little more expensive, but the quotes I’ve been getting for my 10 windows is $10,000 to $25,000. I’m honestly sick to my stomach over this.
I don’t want cheap windows, but at this point after living with these types of old windows for the past 15 years (I also had them in my apartment prior to buying my house), I’m thinking I should just forego the new windows. I know they would help with efficiency, etc., but every salesman that’s come in has bagged on the other companies products and told me how horrible the other windows are, which just makes me more frustrated.
All of these companies have also given me different information regarding my bedroom windows. They are 35 ¾ x 37” windows and some of the companies said that the only windows they could put in my bedrooms are the large casement windows due to egress specifications.
I was thinking of getting the double hung, but don’t want to have different types of windows throughout my house. I don’t see any other houses in my area that have the large casements on their bedrooms. But then there were other companies said that no, they could put double hung’s in my bedroom. ??? So confusing.
I live in the Denver area and have had about 6 quotes and am more confused and stressed than ever. On your website I input my info for a ballpark range, it says $4,400 for 10 windows.
I do have some different sized windows that could skew that number, but my numbers I’ve been given are so much higher. Do you think the prices are so much more elevated in Denver now due to the large growth we’ve been having?
Are there any suggestions you can give me? HELP!
Clarissa - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Clarissa, the calculator is meant as a guide only. If you have a complicated install the price can be quite a bit higher. The information is all over the place because each window company has different products, sizes, etc. If you do have some odd sizes etc. you just need to be patient and find the right company with the right products. Here is what I would suggest.
Get a bid from the Zen dealer in Denver on the Nirvana model.
Get a bid on the Amerimax Craftsman Portrait Series.
Get a bid from a Simonton dealer who carries the Reflections 5500 series.
Tell each of the companies that you are collecting 3 to 4 bids and that price is certainly a big, but not the only, part of your decision. However, you would appreciate their very best price at the get go.
Collect them and see how these compare to what you have.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Simonton 5500 vs. PGT 5400 Series
Tim, the Simonton 5500 just dropped his price to $11,500 from $13,500 for 20 windows and I received a new PGT quote from another vendor for $11,072.00. However, the PGT person might be a little shady because he gave me another quote for Andersen Silverline for $7,250.00. The windows are Low E and I asked if they had argon gas and he said they didn't but could add for $20 per window.
He said that argon gas is a marketing gimmick which made me have doubts about his credibility. He's an Andersen dealer that is trying to push that line. Simonton might be the best way to go. What are your thoughts between Simonton 5500 and PGT 5400? Thanks in advance and I truly appreciate your insight!
Regards.
Meredith - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Meredith, way to get them to drop $2K off the price, that's fantastic and probably the best price you are going to get from either I would think.
The Andersen Silverline windows are not good quality products. Andersen bought Silverline, which has always been considered a cheaply built product. He is necessarily shady by saying that argon gas is a gimmick -- it might add another 8 to 10% efficiency to the windows but the gas will dissipate over time with any sort of seal leak or failure.
In terms of PGT 5400 and Simonton 5500 -- I'd say it's a wash. I would choose the company who you feel will do the best installation job and will stand behind their work if issues do arise in the future.
Good luck and congrats on whichever one you select.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Simonton Reflections 5500 vs. Okna 500 InsulTec Deluxe
Hi Dane, I've been lurking on your site for a couple of weeks soaking up all the good information. Now I have two quotes from Angie?s list A-rated window contractors that I?d like to run by you. These are for 9 windows installed. I live in Raleigh, NC so USUALLY keeping the heat out is the main need but we are having a tough winter this year.
Okna 500 InsulTec Deluxe - $4703 installed, with grids. This included the foam filled extrusions for added insulation but I wonder if this is a necessity?
Simonton Relections 5500 - $4595 installed, with grids. Metal band lift mechanism vs. block & tackle on the Okna, Simonton rep claimed the band was longer lasting? The installation on this quote includes moving furniture out of the way and reinstalling blinds which is nice but not necessary.
I'd love to get your ideas on these two quotes? From what I've read on your site these windows are comparable but I?d like to know if one has features that make it a better choice for me.
Thank you.
Susan - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Susan, I agree that both of these windows are quite good. For me, the Okna 500 is the clear winner. This is definitely true from a performance standpoint, as well as an overall quality and craftsmanship. Okna is superior to the Simonton, and absolutely worth the extra money (which isn?t much).
The price bids you have are quite impressive $500 installed for the Okna 500 with the upgraded package is very good. I would hold onto the upgrade package, I think it adds structure and strength that will serve you well as the window ages.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Simonton 5500 vs. PGT 5400
Tim, I’m in the process of making a decision and wanted your opinion. I live in Orlando, and I’ve listed my quotes for replacing 15 windows:
$12,687.95 Simonton 6100 Coastal
$9,650.00 Berkshire Elite
$10,950.00 EcoView Slocomb 7700
$12,665.00 PGT 5400
$12,900.00 Simonton 5500
$19,800.00 CWS (Outrageous! They started out at $22,640.00)
Also, I haven’t negotiated price with the other quotes that I received. So, there’s a chance they might be willing to come gown on their original price.
I have the following windows:
2 each 36 x 49 ½ picture window
1 each 82 x 105 Picture Window
1 each 72 x 24 x 12 Eyebrow & Legs Picture
1 each 36 x 24 picture window
1 each 48 x 55 ½ picture window
1 each 96 x 19 picture window
1 each 36 x 61 hung window
3 each 30 x 36 picture window
3 each 52 x 70 hung window
1 each 36 x 24 hung window
Thanks in advance for your help!
Meredith - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Meredith, first of all great job on getting all those bids. It's a pain in the arse, but now you have an amazing array of options, prices, and products to choose from. I agree that the CWS bid is much too high and it should be tossed (especially with the PGT bid in the mix).
The two bids I really like in your set are the PGT 5400 and the Simonton 5500. The Simonton 6100 Coastal is a bit of a question mark in my mind and I think the window is a full step below the 5400 and 5500 models. These models are better in my opinion than the Berkshire Elite and EcoView Slocomb 7700.
I would still use these lower bids to drive and see if you can get the PGT and Simonton dealers to come off their initial bid price. I'll give you a link to an article that goes over how you might approach this:
Negotiate Your Window Bid
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Simonton 5500 Series or Provia Aspect
Hello, I am in process of doing roof windows and gutters and doors. I am ok with all with my contractor but had concerns about windows he selected in bid after reading reviews. He recommended mi 1650 I believe they were. Asked to quote different windows and he did. He came back with Provia Aspect and quoted both of an upgrade on 2500.00 more than original quote of 20k installed.
Roughly 40 windows not really sure when counting transom, half rounds etc. Most are standard size I guess with a few larger ones. Any advice on if contractor is pricing correctly and difference in windows listed above would be great. Thanks for your time.
Chris - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
The move from the MI 1650 series to either the ProVia Aspect or the Simonton 5500 is without question worth the additional $2500. Frankly I'm surprised that the upgrade cost from a builder grade window to these mid range windows isn't more.
I like both the Provia Aspect and the Simonton 5500 window and I'm not sure which one I would recommend. I think they are pretty darn equal in terms of performance and craftsmanship. I would see which one your builder likes or has more experience. Obviously, if you like the look or feel or function of one over the other, then that should tip the scale one way or another.
I'm assuming you are doing new construction installation and paying $560 per window sounds about right to me. It's not cheap, but it certainly doesn't sound unfair either. It's always a little tricky dealing with a single contractor because you are already sort of bought in and can't leverage other window bids to lower his price.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Simonton 5500 or Sunrise Classics
I am looking to replace my windows and sliding glass doors, and after a ton a of quotes I think I have narrowed it down to two:
1) $9,300 - Simonton 5500 series (13 windows) and Profinish Contractor model sliding glass doors (2).
2) $11,300 - Sunrise Standard model (13 windows) and Atrium Series 332 (sliding glass doors (2).
I've done a little research, and I know the Sunrise brand appears to be one of the best for window replacements, however the only information I was able to find was on the Essentials and the Restoration models, which seem to be the two extremes. Is the Standard Sunrise model worth the additional 2K versus the Simonton 5500 series?
Thank you.
Monica - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Monica, that's a good question -- I think that's just about right in terms of the price difference between those two windows. The Sunrise Classic or Sunrise standard is a very good window. If it were me, I would go back to the Sunrise dealer and tell him that you like his windows and really want to use his services, but it's out of your price range. Tell him about the Simonton window pricing / bid and that if he could come close to their bid, then you'd be ready to sign that day. I don't think he's going to drop his price $2K, but i'll be he will drop his price some. Say he goes down to $10.5K, then I'd say it's worth it. Who knows, maybe he'll drop his price even more!
Dane - Site Editor - from 2017
[Monica's Reply]
Thank you Tim. I appreciate your feedback. If we are unable to get him to go down, do you see any major issues with selecting the Simonton 5500 series windows? Off the top of your head, do you know which one is more energy efficient and/or has any noise reduction features?
Monica - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
The 5500 from Simonton is quite a good vinyl window, just not as good as the Sunrise. The Sunrise is a better made window and will have better energy efficiency numbers than the 5500. But again, the Simonton 5500 is a good window. In terms of noise reduction, there won't be a huge difference between the two.
You should be able to get both of these sellers to come off their price at least a little bit.
https://www.replacementwindowsreviews.co/review-topics/negotiating-a-home-window-bid.html
Dane - Site Editor - from 2017
Simonton 5500 vs Midway Alliance Hawthorne
I am getting costs between these two windows, 4 x casements over a picture and a single slider in vinyl basic white. I am guessing that they will be close.
Just want the best window the I can get. The installer will be the same regardless of the quote for the windows. He comes highly recommended from various sources. It will be a complete new construction install ripping out the old windows. complete new install no pocket install.
Any opinions between Simonton 5500 vs Midway Alliance Hawthorne.
I think these choices would be better than the Jeld Wen and Anderson 100 or Pella that I can get from the the Big Box Stores.
Andrzey - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Andrzey, I would probably rate those two windows similarly. I myself would probably go with the Simonton 5500, just because I know what I'm getting more than with the Alliance Hawthorne window. Alliance doesn't have the best reputation with credible industry insiders, but I do know that Midway tends to have a pretty darn solid reputation. Basically, Midway is one of a number of regional manufacturers that uses Alliance windows.
I checked the Alliance website and these were the performance numbers they had listed for the Alliance Hawthorne window using the low-e 270 glass -- U-factor .27, .28 SHGC, .53 VT, and .12 AI (air infiltration). These aren't bad numbers, but certainly nothing amazing.
I think you are right to like the Simonton 5500 over Pella and Jeld Wen vinyl windows from the big box store. It is probably a toss up for with the Andersen 100 window and the Simonton 5500.
I think the bottom line is this -- Simonton makes a good vinyl window that isn't the sexiest product out there, but it gets the job done. With good installation, I would have the 5500 series in my house and feel like a got some pretty good value for my money.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Simonton 5500 Reflections vs Wincore
I bought my home a year ago and currently thinking of replacing my windows but I'm not sure if this is the solution. I have cold air drafts near all my windows. It's a split level home and the ground level feels 7 degrees colder. The sticker on one window reads Atrium series 8300 vinyl 2 lite slider ( u- factor -.31, SHGC- .27, visible transm- .50).
First, what do these numbers mean? Is this window good or were the flippers saving money? Could it be that they were just not installed properly? The sticker says Energy star but they are not performing like the most energy efficient windows. Should I feel coldness when I press my hand to the glass? I had 2 people come to price out the 19 Windows. One contractor suggested Simonton. I've spent the whole day reading way more about Windows than I care to read. Please suggest a fantastic window that will keep my house steadily warm, reduce outside noise and inside visibility? I plan on being in this house for at least 15 years.
Thank you for your website , I've learned a lot reading everyone's questions and answers. They need to include information like this in new homebuyer seminars.
I'm located in Maryland. He said the windows were not good and the installation. I currently have a lot of air escape. One contractor wanted to use Wincore 5400 series, low e, argon gas fill. He said they use aluminum wrap and caulking. The difference is this price was 10K for 19 windows and the Simonton 5500 was at 14K.
Lucy - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Answer]
Lucy, U-factor measures heat loss - .31 is just okay. SHGC is how much heat passes through the glass - .27 is fine (the ideal number is more based on where you live, which direction the window faces etc.), visible transmittance is how much light enters through the window .50 is okay. In general Atrium Windows are just okay. They are often one of the options people use to save money because they can be purchased at the big box stores. Atrium is one of the better brands at the big home improvement stores, but they tend to offer pretty mediocre windows.
So did the contractors say it was the windows that were sub par and not the installation? I'm guessing this is the case. Simonton is a good brand, although I would only have the premium Reflections or the Impressions line in my house. Where are you located, windows are typically sold regionally....
I think the Wincore 5400 window is good — I like the Wincore 7700 series better — if it were me I would go back to him and ask if he has access to the 7700 series and if so, I would tell him that I was willing to sign a contract that day if he could do the job with the 7700 window for the 10K ;)
The Simonton 5500 series is good - but I'm not sure if its worth $4K more — I think the Wincore 7700 and Reflections 5500 are probably equal.
Now see what the best price you can get by playing the two quotes off one another…there is some wiggle room in price, I'm certain of it...
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Simonton 5500 vs Paradigm
Looking to replace two patio sliding doors, I large picture window and one bow window. Looking at Simonton 5500 and Paradigm windows. Which is better? Should I be looking at another company. I live in upstate New York and have a lot of snow and cold.
Terry - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Answer]
Terry, the Simonton 5500 series is a good vinyl window. Paradigm is going to be lower on the food chain in my opinion, although I don't know a ton about them. My notion is that their premium vinyl window would be somewhere close to the Simonton 5500. You might want to get 1 or 2 additional bids.
You should be able to do a quick google search for local companies who carry the following brands; Okna, Sunrise, Soft-Lite, Harvey and Polaris. These are the better window manufacturers that should be available from someone in your zip code. Feel free to send me the bids and project details and I can give you an unbiased opinion on what might be the best bet from your home reno.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2016
[Terry's Answer]
Thanks for your quick reply. I have met with a Sunrise dealer/installer in my area for the 2 patio doors I need. He is quoting about 3,000 for each patio door and 3,360 for replacement picture window and 1 double hung on each side. both are installed price. I'm reading that Sunrise sash panels are welded, however the frame is "knock down" meaning it comes in pieces and assembled via fasteners.
I am unable to locate Okna or Polaris in my area. Still looking. Harvey is about 1 1/2 hours away from me. Looking into Soft-Lite.
Terry - Homeowner - from 2016
Reflections 5500s And Frame Fill Question
Sir, a further question if you don't mind. I have a cousin who works in the industry. He wrote to me: "Just don't get caught up in gas insulated glass. That is more money than it's worth. Look for insulated frames. Vinyl is very cold when not insulated."
I really haven't found any windows available locally that don't have insulated glass and do have insulated frames. I was all set to go w/ the Reflections 5500s. I got refs from two local homeowners who had them installed by a particular contractor and they were happy.
What do you think the insulated frame vs insulated glass issue?
Steve - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Steve, most window manufacturers offer a standard glass that includes a low-e glass with argon fills. The argon is the gas and is pretty common in the industry. You certainly don't have to have the argon, but it does add some energy efficiency to the window, not a ton, but some. Over time, the argon can escape if the seals on the Insulated Glass Unit are weak or leak. I wouldn't spend a lot of time worry about whether you have it or not, but most windows do come with it. The gas is not an expensive add on as far as the overall cost of the window goes.
In terms of foam filled frames, I totally agree that the extra cost to have the foam injected frame is well worth the money. Different manufacturers have different options, some window series come with it standard, others offer this is an upgrade, while some lower end companies may not offer it at all. Make sure to ask the dealer who is selling you the window what the different options are.
At the end of the day however, you will be better served to concentrate on finding a quality window manufacturer who will offer these upgrades, but that builds a quality extrusion and uses quality components, along with professional installation. Get these two pieces of the puzzle right and the little extras and upgrades will be icing on the cake!
Dane - Website Editor - from 2016
Simonton 5500 Reflection Windows
Hi, I had a contractor give me a quote for installing, building out the framing and wrapping 23 Simonton 5500 Reflection windows. He came in just under 13k. A friend had Home Depot do his house w/ Simonton Vantage Point 6100's and he is very happy. HD touts their "lifetime workmanship warranty." They came in $1800 higher and of course this is w/ a "sale" that ends in a few days.
Am I correct that the Reflections 5500 is a better window than the Vantage Point 6100? I read that the 5500 is akin to the better Vantage Point, the 6500, whereas the VP6100 is the same as the lower end 5050. I am wondering if Home Depot is trying to sell me a lesser window (than the other quote) for more money, albeit w/ a better warranty on the labor/installation.
If you could reply it would be great. I appreciate your time and respect your expertise.
Steve - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Steve, the Simonton 5500 Reflections window is definitely the superior window over the VantagePointe 6100. I'm also not a fan of how HD subcontracts out their work and pay per window, I feel like they pay their subs very poorly and this just doesn't strike me as the best way to deliver quality installation. Some people love the HD installers, but I have also heard my share of bad stories of poor HD projects.
The price you got on the 5500s with full installation is very good and as long as you keep in contact with the contractor, you should be able to come back to him if there are any issues with the windows down the road.
Good luck and let me know how the project turns out!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Simonton 5500 vs Milgard and Amerimax Windows
What are your thoughts on these three brands/Windows:
Amerimax Craftsman Portrait Series
Milgard Tuscany and Quiet-Line
Simonton Reflections 5500
I'm looking to drastically improve the comfort level in the upstairs portion of my house. 3 fairly large south east facing Windows and one large north facing window. The rest are in shady portions. I'm going to remove the siding around the Windows in order to add trim and to install new construction type Windows.
Thanks for the advice--I really found your site helpful.
David - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
David, I like each of the windows you mentioned. The Quietline is the outlier of the bunch and will be much more expensive that the others (if for some reason it isn't, you should jump on it!). I might give the advantage to the Reflections 5500 series of the three, but not by much.
I would say that with such close window selections, it might be best to now shift your attention to the installers. This component is obviously very important. Good installation will insure that they don't have to come back out and fix issue and charge you for their "service." If it were me, I would select the company that seems to offer the best installers with lots of experience installing their specific window.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2016
Simonton Reflections 5500 vs Zen Windows
We just tore out a rotten window sill at our home yesterday (not the remodel project.) In our area, in vinyl, the local distributors carry Silverline, Pella, Simonton and the smaller companies (which I agree we should stay away from because the warranties are not great and the companies may not be around later for warranty work.) I have not looked at the home stores and hope not to because that seems to complicate things more. You have confirmed my feeling about the Silver Line. I suspect that the same scenario applies to Pella.
I looked for Sunrise and Soft-Lite, but only found Zen about 40 miles away from the construction site. I will check into the other brands you mentioned, but if they are not available here that really only leaves Simonton reflections 5500 and Platinum Prism as worthy options here. They are expensive, but they seem to have a decent warranty.
Again, I thank you so much for your help.
Nita - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Nita, the Simonton 5500 is a good window. Call up the Zen dealer and have them come out and give you a bid. Tell them you only want a bid on the Nirvana and Lotus, not the Karma model. The Nirvana and Lotus are the Soft-Lite Classic and Soft-Lite Pro (confusing right?)
Both of these models are quite good and are often at a nice price point. Not always so, but often. The more bids you have, the stronger your negotiating position.
Good luck!
Dane - Website Editor - from 2016
Please note - all Simonton Windows reviews prior to 2015 have been archived.
Simonton Windows vs Vinylmax
We live near Atlanta and have 13 double hungs to replace. Love to get your take...
MGM Windows: $6.3K
Vinylmax Radiance: $10.8K
Simonton 5500: $13.7K
John - Homeowner - from 2024
[Site Editor's Answer]
I'd probably go with the Vinylmax Radiance. The 5500 is the best of the bunch, but that price split is tricky. MGM is you're in the home for less than 7 years I would say.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2024
Simonton 5500 Windows Reviews
Hi Dane, we're looking to replace about 25 original windows in our home (mostly double hung, but two picture as well).
We've talked to a few companies and have been quoted 1) Vinylmax Franklin Series with Intelliglass X Low E/Argon glass, 2) Simonton 5050 and 5500 with high efficiency Cardinal 366 glass, and 3) Vytex Omni series.
The Vytex Omni series is apparently a window made specifically by Vytex for the company that proposed them. It's their "premium" vinyl window with thin profiles. (Vinylmax Windows Reviews)
The Simonton windows are what they are.
I like Vinylmax option, but had read (on your website) that the Edison series would be better. I went back to the company that quoted the Franklin series and they said "The Edison series is actually the same window as the Franklin with a different lock design. It is marketed to companies that buy through distribution and not directly from the manufacturer."
For the Vinylmax Franklin series, they quoted me $16,030 for the 26 windows (23 double hung, 2 picture, and 1 small slider), which averages to $616 per window.
The Simonton 5050 was quoted at $559 per window.
The Simonton 5500 was quoted at $669-680 per window.
I also got an option for Sunrise V4500 windows for $759-780 per window.
I'd love your thoughts on all the above! Currently I'm leaning towards the Vinylmax Franklin quote (if in case they are the same as the Edison except the lock design).
Thank you.
Nathan - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Nathan, well, I have to say I'd never heard that about the Franklin and Edison (soooo many window options out there that sometimes even my head spins). If that's true, then I'm on board with the decision. I don't have a contact with Vinylmax so there is no way (right now) that I can confirm. The Sunrise V4500 would be my pick if you can swing the price, which is actually quite good for that model window.
If you do plan to be in the home for 20 years plus, then I think you highly consider the Sunrise. Less than this, then the Vinylmax Franklin option makes a lot of sense. The other one is the Simonton 5500 series, which at $670 installed is a VERY nice deal. I think you have some great options here and a big part of the equation for me would the installation company. Look them up and see how they are rated!
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Simonton Windows Reviews :: Prism Platinum Series
The Prism Platinum Simonton window is the top-of-the-line Prism Series and is virtually indistinguishable from the Reflections 5500 window. Typically, the Prism Series is sold on the East Coast and the Reflections on the West, but this isn't always the case. In general, the Prism Platinum has a nice appearance and clean sightlines, making for a very classic and streamlined appearance.
The window comes standard with the following: interlocking meeting rail, 7/8" insulating glass unit, stepped sill, tilt in sash and integrated lift sash rail. In addition, it uses argon fills, ProSolar Low-e glass, an intercept spacer, and a fiberglass mesh screen. Exterior frame options include cream, chocolate, driftwood, pine, bronze, brick, and tan. In terms of hardware, there are three options: oil-rubbed bronze, brushed nickel, and a polished brass.
The Prism Platinum series, just like the Reflections 5500 series, is a solid vinyl window that is one of the best from this very well known manufacturer. Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews on the Prism Platinum Series.
Dane - Site Editor
Simonton Prism Platinum Vinyl Windows
Hi Dane, I plan to replace 16 out of 27 windows in my 22 year old Central Texas single story, all brick sided house.
Due to the seasonal temperature fluctuations in Central Texas, would you please recommend whether the replacement windows should be aluminum or vinyl frames.
I have obtained 5 estimates from 5 different companies for both aluminum and vinyl frame windows. I would greatly appreciate your recommendation based upon the manufacturer and price provided below.
Thank you for your help.
NT Presidential White Vinyl Windows - 18,500
Simonton Prism Platinum Vinyl White Windows – 13,000
Zen Nirvana Vinyl White Windows – 22,000
NT Twinsulator Thermal Break Aluminum Windows - 20,500
DYC White Aluminum Windows – 14,100
All replacement windows will have Solar LowE and Argon gas
Paul - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Paul, I think you can do either vinyl or aluminum given your location. Don Young aluminum windows are considered very good and the price you have from them looks good -- obviously I know nothing about your project but the DY quote is one of the lowest priced bid.
The Simonton Prism Platinum is also a very decent window and the lowest bid.
I'm not necessarily a fan of going with the lowest bid, but in your case I think there is an argument to be made.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Large Prism Platinum Window
Your blog has been a life saver in making some sense out of window replacement!! I'm a little further in my endeavor & have rec'd my first bid.
The quote is from a Simonton rep showing the Prism Platinum double hung vinyl window. The replacement opening is 70.5"W x 58.5"H. He showed me the sample window & described how two DH windows are attached side by side. I was quite shocked to learn that the "window mull" (frame) between the two windows would be 6-7" wide! That a lot of vinyl to look at & cuts out a HUGE amount of viewing area. I don't seem to be able to find the data I need to determine what other good to very good manufacturer may have a slimmer "mull". In your expert opinion I'm hoping you can guide me. I ruled out Slider windows because of the look of my house & existing window treatments.
One other note Simonton customers might want to be aware of is the notion of egress. The Simonton rep told me that my size windows, which I didn't think were small, would not pass code by about an inch on the DH because the frame takes up so much space - another reason I'm looking for alternatives.
I did not go with the Zen dealer because he wanted me to agree to his quote by phone or email before I could even see his window or meet him. I understand his business model is "get a quote in 5 minutes," but it's my choice NOT to sign anything site-unseen.
Again, Dane, thank you for the valuable service you provide sharing your expertise & honest opinions!!
Jan - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Simonton windows tend to use quite a bit of vinyl in their frames. Is there a reason why you don't do a picture window across the span? Or if you went with a higher end brand like a Sunrise Restorations that uses a thinner frame, you might be able to do an XOX where you have casements on the side and a small picture window in the center.
I think you need to bring more people out and have them toss out ideas for the opening and really explore the options. I tend to think two double hung next to one another is an awkward look. There has got to be something better than that out there.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Simonton Windows vs Sunrise
I'm replacing my windows in my manufactured home and wondering what you can tell me about the Simonton Reflections 5500 and the Sunrise Restoration Series. We have received bids from both and the Simonton bid was higher. We live in North Dakota and I like the fact that the Sunrise windows I can purchase from a local dealer. Thank you.
Cheryl - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Cheryl, the Sunrise Restorations is a top tier vinyl window, really top notch. The Simonton Reflections 5500 is a good window, but I wouldn't put it in the top tier, I might put it in the top tier of mid range vinyl window category. The fact that the Simonton bid was higher makes this even easier, go with the Sunrise! You are getting an excellent window!
Dane - Site Editor - from 2016
Simonton 5500 Windows Reviews
I'm looking to have windows installed in a duplex that I purchased. There are a ton of options out there!
I did get a quote to have Simonton 5500 windows installed for $5,900 (6 double hung and 8 slider). Are these decent, or is there a better option, at a cheaper price? I found a local dealer that gave me a price of $283 per window for the Simonton. Thanks!
Tim - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
The Simonton 5500 is a very decent window. It's not a top tier vinyl window, but it's at the higher end of the mid range vinyl window mark. The $5900 is a good price fully installed. The $283 for the window itself is a good price as well. One recommendation I would suggest is to ask your local dealer if there is any wiggle room on that installed price, any features or options that they can tweak to get the price lower. With the price you were quoted, I doubt whether there is much he can do but it never hurts to ask!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Simonton 5500 vs Milgard Tuscany
I have quotes on both the Milgard Tuscany and the Simonton 5500 with the Milgard coming in at $80 more per window. Really looking for efficiency in reducing heating and cooling bills in Missouri. Any preference?
Jesse - Consumer - from 2015
[Site Editor's Response]
Jesse, I would say that the Milgard Tuscany window is perhaps a shade better than the Simonton 5500 Reflections, although I like the components and features of the 5500 window just fine. The comparison is close enough that I would say it's a non factor - better to compare the installers and how well the companies who are doing the installation compare with one another.
If you want better energy efficiency, you may want to get a bid from Sunrise or Soft-Lite on their mid range window models - I believe these two are available through local dealers in certain parts of Missouri. These companies are going to offer a better overall window than either Milgard or Simonton, although they will also be more expensive. It never hurts to get the full comparison and every once in a while you will find a company that offers these lines at pretty darn competitive pricing.
However, if you are fine with the performance numbers of the Simonton 5500 series and trust the company who gave you this bid, you should be good with this vinyl window in your home. It's quite a solid mid range vinyl window.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2015
Simonton 5500 Windows Reviews And Prices
I'm in North Carolina where it gets hot in the summer and it's time to replace my windows. I have bids for the following; Simonton 5500 with the ETC 366 glass and the Soft-Lite Imperial LS with a comparable glass package, I believe the SB 70 xl. The cost is $60 more per window for the Soft-Lite - any thoughts?
Tom - Homeowner - from 2013
[Contractor Response]
Strictly from a performance standpoint, the 5500 will hold up against the Imperial LS model, although the LS will probably beat it out by a bit in terms of AI and U-value (not noticeably for your purposes). Where the Imperial LS is going to outshine the 5500 is in aesthetics, it is much nicer looking with a thinner frame, whereas the Simonton 5500 has a much bulkier frame. For larger windows this is not as apparent, but for smaller openings, it can be very noticeable. For $60 more per window, I would go with the Imperial LS, but the Simonton model is good. Either way (assuming thorough installation) you should be happy.
Steven - Contractor - from 2013
Read additional Soft-Lite window reviews.
Simonton 5500 Windows Reviews
The 5500 is a better than average window, I actually have them in my home and they have held up well. They have an .07 air infiltration rating, which is quite respectable. As far as pricing for the Simonton 5500 goes, you should be able to get them for $350 to $500 installed, depending on the size, upgrades and how complicated the installation specs are. Of course, pricing will also depend on the distributor and how they do their installs etc.
Billy - Contractor - 2012
Simonton 5500 vs. Top Vinyl Manufacturers
The 5500 model is solid and is better than most windows on the market today. But the window pales in comparison to the top of the line vinyl windows like the Soft-Lite Elements or the Okna 800 model. Is it fair that these would be quite a bit more than the 5500...yes in my opinion. Performance wise the numbers aren't close - 5500 has decent numbers, but nothing spectacular, while the other two have better AI, DP, Thermal, VT numbers by quite a bit. From a design perspective, the 5500 also can't compete, it has a bulky frame, maybe 1/2" on all sides when compared to the Okna and Soft-Lite. These windows are just better looking, better designed and better performing - and that's why you can get the 5500 for around $300 (window itself) and the others are going to run more like $400 to $450 for the window itself.
- Installer - 2012
Simonton Reflections 5500 & Prism Platinum
Simonton has some good windows, especially the Reflections 5500 (Prism Platinum). They are pretty much the same with only some minor cosmetic differences. I like the Prism Platinum best, it has the Super Spacer and double strength glass. If you are in the south, I'd go with the ETC Super 366 for the low solar heat gain. In the north, you want the solar gain so get the ETC Super Solar instead.
John - Contractor - from 2010
Related Topics: Amerimax Windows Reviews