| REVIEWS |  |
BEST WINDOWS | |
WINDOWS PRICES | |
STYLES |
Home : Frame & Material : Casement Windows Reviews
Casement Windows Reviews
Read 12 casement windows reviews on many of the most popular styles from different manufacturers - find out more on casement windows prices here.
Get Our Recommended Window List
Also please consider filling out the free form on our site for 3 quality window price quotes — it’s how we afford to provide free consumer information. We’re not incentivized by ANY company and will help you with ANY questions you might have, and help you navigate ANY bids you receive. That’s our guarantee to you!
dane@replacementwindowsreviews.co
Vytex, Simonton and Andersen Casements
I'm overseeing our non-profit building window replacement project (currently have steel pan windows): I've gotten a number of bids, but value your opinion on the following:
Contractor A recommends: Vytex 3300 series casement, $37,506;
Contractor B recommends: Simonton 5500 series casement, $43,650
Contractor C recommends: Andersen 100 series casement, $49,800.
Of course, there is a lot of custom sizing required. For an idea of size of job, number of windows to be replaced is about 35-58 (depending on how they were counted); number of new windows is about 30-35. I've also received bids for Pella aluminum clad wood (cost higher than above quotes except if the contractor "A" installs instead of Vytex - then less than $40k ). Thanks very much!
Jean-Marie - Site Editor - from 2015
[Site Editor's Response]
Jean-Marie, I like these selections. The Andersen 100 is a nice window, but unless you really like how it looks, I would say you aren't getting much in terms of performance from this window over the other two.
I like the Simonton 5500 casement quite a bit and I would go with this selection on first glance - but of course, I don't know all the details of what you are getting in terms of glass, upgrades, etc.
I like both the Vytex Fortis and Potomac-hp series, but I'm not sure which one you are referring to here. If it is one of these (if I had to guess, I would say this is the Fortis, but I could be wrong...)
I might go with the Simonton only because they are a bigger company and you have a little more assurance that if an issue arises, they will be around and your contractor can deal with them and get the issue resolved.
I have to say that the numbers on the Fortis and Potomac-hp (not the Georgetown Series, which I don't love) are really impressive, I like that .05 AI — I might have to change my mind as I'm writing this.
I don't think the 5500 is going to fare as well - see if you can get some comparable numbers on the 5500 from your contractor. Look at AI and DP rating.
http://www.vytexwindows.com/products/windows/window_comparison_chart/
Tim - Site Editor - from 2015
Casement Windows Reviews
I'm planning on replacing 12 casements in NE Ohio plus a sliding glass door and 2 pictures. We're doing a tear out down to the studs, taking out the Pellas that were installed in '73. There are a lot more to choose from than when we had those put in way back then. I want good windows but I also need a fair price and I was hoping for wood clad in vinyl or fiberglass. I know Inline and Marvin have a fiberglass model, are they good?
Marcia - Homeowner in Ohio - from 2012
[Contractor Response]
The Marvin Infinity is a good casement, and I think the fiberglass is a good choice. I think Inline just came out with a new design for their fiberglass casements, and it's supposed to have great engineering. If it isn't out yet it will be soon. Sunrise has a good one, also, with a lot of different material options. If it were me, I'd look at the Sunrise before making a decision, as they are generally one of the best windows out there. I don't like buying a new line, or at least one that's had major changes, so the Inline makes me nervous. I like to wait until they've had time to work out the kinks.
Billy - Contractor - from 2012
Read additional Sunrise windows reviews.
Semco Casements
In 2003, I purchased 16 casements, a double hung, and 8 fixed windows plus 2 sliding glass doors, all from SEMCO. The interiors are all wood finish and the exteriors are bronze aluminum. So far I like them, I expect to replace a few more with SEMCOs so they all match. We've been mostly happy with them, but our south facing windows have had some seal failures and sometimes fog up. 4 of 16 casements and 2 of 8 fixed have had their glass replaced because the low-e coating was deteriorating. The glass is covered under warranty but we had to pay for labor. Our summers are really hot, we're in SoCal, so I don't know if anyone else's windows could hold up better in our heat. We bought the wood/aluminum clad SEMCOs because they were so well priced. I think even with some minor problems, I'm glad we got them, because we could get the whole house done and we could never have afforded that in any other brand.
Bret - Homeowner - from 2012
American Jewel vs Harvey
I'm considering either American Jewels or Harvey Tributes. I want them to last a long time. The American Jewel dealer says that one size I need, 36 by 45, doesn't come in a casement so I have to use a slider.
Lucas - Homeowner - from 2012
[Contractor Response]
I'd be worried about the design and quality of a window that has to limit the width of their casements like that. American Jewel is low quality, you can do a lot better without even spending more money. Harvey isn't great either, but better than American Jewel. They do make a wider casement but it isn't good quality. If you pay a little more for a good window, you'll find it lasts for many more years with a lot fewer problems, and you're also paying for customer service in case something does break.
Brian - Installer - from 2012
Best Casement Options
For casements, I'd take a look at Okna, Softlite, Sunrise, and Gorell. One of Sunrise's new lines has the thinnest profile I've ever seen on a casement, which gives you more glass and more natural light if that's what you're after. Keep in mind that you can usually order vinyl windows with a wood grain finish, but if you buy a white one and stain it you won't get the same results. If it's in your budget, take a look at Milgard and Marvin fiberglass windows.
Steven - Virginia contractor 2011
Marvin Casement Windows
I love Simonton, but the 5050 isn't available as a casement. If that's what you're looking for you'll have to go with the Simonton Reflections 5500 or Prism Platinum. The Marvin is good if you're worried about smaller glass, they have thinner frames. A vinyl casement is always going to have thicker framing than the same line in a double hung, so I'd make sure to see one in person before buying.
Steven - Contractor - from 2010
Eagle Casements
I have a bunch of casement windows to replace, and I'm considering Marvin Ultimates, Pella Architects, and Eagle Axioms. They are all extruded aluminum clad. I've heard good things about Eagle, and I'm thinking about going with a triple pane instead of double.
Levi - Homeowner - from 2010
[Contractor Response]
Out of those three, the Marvin Ultimate is the best. The Eagle is good, too, just not quite as nice. I would stay away from the Pella, the sash is lower quality.
Anthony - Contractor - from 2010
Milgard Ultra vs Marvin Infinity
I've done a lot of jobs with the Milgard Ultra and the Marvin Infinity. They are both really good, but they have their strengths and weaknesses. They both make a good casement, but the Infinity is a better double hung. Milgard has a better warranty, but I think that a lot of times companies that have a good warranty do it because they need it. You don't need a good warranty if the window doesn't have problems. I think warranties are there to protect the company, not their customers. They keep people from being too upset when there's a problem. Both of them are well made and look good. I think most people would be happy with either option.
Jonathan – Installer – 2009
Hurd Casements
I'm replacing 26 double casements on my home. I first went to Renewal By Andersen, but the price was way out of my reach. I've gotten two other estimates, one contractor will put in Andersens and the other wants to use an aluminum clad Hurd windows. Both are right around $30,000 installed. I'm not sure which to go through. I've heard some bad stuff about Hurd, but I know this contractor and trust him, and he says he really likes them.
Curt - Homeowner - from 2009
Renewal By Andersen Casements
I spent about $1200 each for 10 RBA windows. The weatherstripping came loose the very first time we opened the casement window. One of the double hungs won't lock, and another one won't open. So 3 of my 10 windows don't work, and I paid $12k for them. I'm beyond disappointed. They claim to be the best and they are certainly one of the most expensive, so they should at least be a mediocre window, which in my opinion they aren't.
Debbi – Homeowner in Pennsylvania – from 2009
Simonton Prism Platinum 6500
Over a year ago I got Simonton Prism Platinum 6500s put on my house. The house is less drafty, our energy bills went down. We have mostly casements and the cranking mechanism is very nice, smooth movement and good hardware. They look great, too. The only thing we weren't totally pleased with is that they only come with a white exterior, so at first it didn't look quite right, but now we're used to the white and love it.
Nikki - Homeowner - from 2008