Home : Replacement Windows Reviews : Pella 250 Windows Reviews
Pella Windows 250 Series Review
Pella hasn't always had the best reputation when it comes to vinyl windows. For instance, the Pella Thermastar seems to have locked in the lowest rated vinyl window on the Consumer Reports Replacement Windows list back when it was part of the company's lineup. (It has since been discontinued). Scroll down to read all of our Pella Windows 250 Series reviews.
Get Our Recommended Window List
Also please consider filling out the free form on our site for 3 quality window price quotes — it’s how we afford to provide free consumer information. We’re not incentivized by ANY company and will help you with ANY questions you might have, and help you navigate ANY bids you receive. That’s our guarantee to you!
dane@replacementwindowsreviews.co
Below are Pella 250 series reviews, pricing info, as well as consumer comparison, comments and complainrs. We are happy to answer your questions as well.
Dane, we have a bid on the Heartland 700 series that ended up being $720 per window installed. Our other strong contender was on the Pella 250 at $780 per window installed. What's the better deal?
Braden, I would probably go with the Pella 250 in this instance. I trust the Pella name more than Heartland to be honest. I think it's worth the upgrade cost.
Hi there, I'm in Phoenix Arizona and have a bunch of price quotes for 22 windows in total. Thought I'd share since you were so kind with your list and great advice!
Hi Dane, thanks for sharing your knowledge on your website. We live in a 1950s cape style home with original single pane/storm windows in Massachusetts and are getting estimates for 6 double hung replacement windows. Two manufacturers for windows Pella 250 series and Marvin Elevate offer replacement windows and were in the same ballpark for the each window ($650 to $750 without installation). I like the Marvin better because the grids in the Elevate have are on the outside of the window. Pella only offers this on their higher end model.
Karen, I would agree that you would need to be careful about putting in replacement windows in a home from the 50s with its original windows. Of course, I don't know if you need work to your frames, but you should spend some time figuring out what you need. I usually give this advise in these situations...get as many free bids as you can from local companies until you feel confident that the type of window/installation you are going with is the right one.
Dane, can you help me out with a window quality comparison. We are looking at: Insignia Triple Pane windows v. Pella 250-series.
Steve, the Insignia Triple Pane window is the better window in my opinion over the Pella 250 series. Better made and better performance data, especially with the triple pane.
I’m hoping you can help me decide between the window quotes I’ve received. We did fall victim to the “this price is good for today only” gimmick, but we negotiated a 10-day “get out for any reason” period that is in writing and should extend for another week, so we have a little time, but probably not a lot of time to schedule additional quotes. We live in a suburb of Indianapolis and our house is 20 years old and has 16 fairly standard sized double hungs that are all the originals. Although we eventually want to replace all of them, we are going to start with 4 so the prices below are for 4 double hung windows.
David, presentation aside, the best window of the bunch is the Polaris ThermalWeld, then the Pella 250 series, and lagging behind that is the WW 4000 series. The Universal Windows Direct out of Indianapolis gets decent but not great reviews, which doesn't excite me. Elite Window and Door seems to get good reviews on google, although there are only 17 listed, which is probably not enough to make a firm decision. I think I would be leaning towards the Elite Window and Door at this point.
Hello Dane, I purchased a beautiful home last year in Central PA but discovered the original wooden windows from 1974 need to be replaced. Our heating bills soared during December/January so I resorted to placing plastic on the windows and double patio doors.
Stephanie, I think the Zen Nirvana or Soft-Lite Classic is a very solid choice. Other than this, nothing you mentioned would be something I would consider for a forever home. Here is my list of good and great windows: [list pulled - duplicate content]. Please also check our Pella 250 Series reviews page for more.
Hi Dane and Tim, reaching out to you for some much needed advice. Our house was built in 2011 (there, I said it) and we bought the house from the old owners in the summer of 2016. The first couple of years, there may have been some mild condensation, which we ignored, since we were told that well sealed windows do have some condensation. A year later, we received class action lawsuit, which we didnt participate in since the most we would've got is 2500 and that wouldn't be anything to write home about.
Shanti, hi, thanks for reaching out. My gut tells me that you should replace all of the windows at one time using a very well regarded installation company. That way if something does go wrong, you have one place to go. The best window of the bunch is the Sunrise Restorations, however, it is the same price as the RBA, which gives me real pause. RBA is usually at least 2X as expensive as I think makes sense.
I am glad I found your Pella 250 Series reviews website page and you seem to know your windows and do not push a particular brand. I live in Utah and had several windows replaced a few years ago by Lowe's- they were Pella. After reading some of your reviews I sense they would not have been your first choice for a vinyl window. Anyway we have two more windows to replace 4'x4' sliding windows.
Joe, yes quite pricey. I would ditch the Pella and wouldn't both with theJeld Wen either. Jeld Wen makes quite a good door, but their windows are pretty mediocre in my estimation. If you would like some quality local bids you can always use our Price Quote Form, beginning with your zip code where it says Find Local Five Star Rated Pros.
Hi Tim I found your information on the web and would like to thank you for helping people like me who don't know alot about windows.
Tony, the Pella 250 vinyl window is an okay window, but certainly nothing great. The Thermo-Tech Ultra is a pretty damn good window. Definitely my choice over the Pella 250.
Thanks for your Pella 250 Series reviews. Here is what I got from lowes. I think this is sky high. I am waiting on prices from thermo-tech, hayfield and Minnkota which I will shoot your way as well.
I recently got a quote from a Pella representative to replace 17 windows with 250 Series casement. I also had 2 other windows which were non-standard size for specialized manufacture for a couple of narrow non-opening windows in the front of my house.
Hi Danny, so let's say 20 windows thereabouts for $40K. $2K is about what I'd expect for an architectural series for a end high wood clad window. The Pella 250 series is at best a mid range vinyl window. I'd pay in the $300 to $400 per window for this series, although I wouldn't put this in my home.
We have 6 double-hungs, 3 twin double-hungs, 1 small picture window, and 1 combination picture fixed pane (3 panel window).
Julie, if you assume you have 15 windows (a generous number), then you are paying $890 for the Lindsay Pinnacle or the Pella 250. This is a high price tag even for the very best vinyl windows out there. Neither the Pella 250 more the Lindsay Pinnacle is a top tier vinyl window. My advise is to keeping getting bids until you have three or four to compare.
Tim, we have estimates from local companies on both the Pella 250 series and the Simonton 6500 series. Which do you consider the better choice?
Fred, if the prices are equal, I like the Simonton 6500 over the Pella 250 myself. I think Simonton makes a better vinyl window in general. Check out our Pella 250 Series reviews page for more.
Dane, good Afternoon.I am in the market for replacement windows for my house. (34 if I replace them all.)
Jim, I am not a big fan of the Pella 250 series. The ProVia Aspect is ProVia's mid range vinyl window and is, in my opinion, a good mid range vinyl window. This would be my pick and it's quite a bit less. You could always throw in a nice upgrade on the ProVia -- glass package, sill reinforcement, etc. to make it even stronger/energy efficient.
Dane, we're collecting quotes for 22 windows for our home in the southwest. Our contractor quoted us on the Pella 250 and the Milgard Styleline. Any comments on either of these? Could upgrade to a better window if you thought it was worth it.
Jesse, I'm not the biggest fan of Pella's vinyl windows. They make a great wood window, but their vinyl windows aren't the best in the game. Milgard makes a better vinyl window. I'd prefer you go with the Milgard Trinsic over the Styleline myself. It's their newer slim frame vinyl window that is quite a nice looking vinyl window. This would be my call over the Styleline. The Tuscany is the call if you don't mind the bulkier look for your home.
Hi Dane, I’m overwhelmingly unknowledgeable in regards to replacement windows and have been studying your insight in hopes of finding some clarity in our window replacement journey.
Hi Janel. So your three bids are pretty different in terms of companies, materials and quality of windows. I would recommend a quality vinyl window for a cold winter climate like New Jersey. (I actually recommend quality vinyl windows for most people who aren’t married to the idea of a wood window.)
I live in southern middle Tennessee. I have a bow window facing west getting full afternoon hot summer sun. It is leaking and I want to replace it. Having had two estimates so far and waiting on third, I am unsure which way to go. Opening is 10’ x 55”
Kay, I’m not a huge fan of the 250 Series (check out our Pella 250 Series Reviews page for other opinions) so if it were me I wouldn’t go that route.
Thanks so much for your response. I did sign contract with Home Depot and 25% down before receiving your email. I have researched this morning and found a Zen dealer offering Softlit windows. Waiting on a call from them now.
I have quotes on the Pella 250 Series for $10,025 (which includes installation and tax).
Chris, so I definitely think the Sunrise is worth the extra money. The prices quotes sound about right. I would see if you can't get them to reduce what they are charging you for the custom color option. There may be some wiggle room there.
I live outside of Denver and need to upgrade my old aluminum windows to vinyl. I have two viable quotes and would like to get your take on them. We are replacing nine windows in total.
Micah, the Revere Sovereign window is a pretty solid mid range vinyl window. It's much more price appropriate than the Pella quote. The Pella 250 is not worth $1000 plus per window. I'd stick with the Revere Sovereign quote unless the Pella salesperson is willing to drop his price.
I have a bid on the Simonton Reflections 5500, but I'm worried because it isn't rated on Consumer Reports. The Simonton Pro Finish Contractor window is and has an 83.
Nancy, the Reflections 5500 is the better of the two windows by quite a lot. The Reflections 5500 isn't included in the CR because it isn't available for purchase at a retail shop. It would rank above the ProFinish Contractor if it were rated (or it should be rated higher).
Visited your site and have question about two window manufacturers. We live in Central Florida so the summers are hot and humid.
Brand, so the price of the Pella 250 is about what I'd expect. I don't love the Pella 250, but it's a much better vinyl window over what the company had before. Do they carry the Pella 350 series? The Simonton 6100 is a better window, but that's too expensive what they quoted you out at. The Renewal By Anderson quote is ridiculous as you already indicated.
Hi guys. I'm in the middle of remodeling a 100 year old home in West Virginia and I've been shopping for windows for several weeks now with different suppliers. I'm a carpenter by trade so I'll be doing the installion myself. I've been very informed by your website (especially with your pella windows reviews page) and wanted to thank you for putting this all together for us and your Pella 250 series reviews.
Josh, the Harvey Classic is the better window. Better features and components, better fit and tolerances, better overall craftsmanship -- all translates to better performance data, especially U-factor and Air infiltration. Over time, the window with the less solid materials will tend to breakdown quicker and require little fixes here and there, maybe the seals break, balances get out of whack etc.
We are interested in replacing 21 windows and have gotten 2 estimates. Of the 21, one is a half circle window. Do you think we should get more bids or are 2 enough?
The Zen Nirvana is the better of the windows, hands down. Plus its way less expensive!v How nice is that?
Hi Dane, I am in the process of replacing my front door and a front windows in my home. I have priced the Pella 250 from their store and after research noticed they do receive good reviews. I went to the local Lowe’s in southern Indiana and they also carry the same models at a better price and on sale. The salesman recommended the Atrium 3200 or 3500 series. Is this a better window or should I keep looking. A lot of choices and since I am staying in the home, I want a decent window. He also recommended the MMI entry door with side lights and transom. Any recommendations before I sign the dotted line? Thanks
I would say the Pella 250 is probably right on par with an Atrium 3500. Not the best window, but probably one of the best you are going to get at the big box stores. I would say this -- if you are going to go with a Lowes or Home Depot product, call each store up (as well as perhaps another store like Dixieline etc) and speak with the guys in the window and door department. Ask them what window they carry is the best and what window would they choose for their home. (Hopefully these two answers are the same!) Then get pricing and make sure you get a decent low-e glass.
Do that with all three stores and see what you come up with. The issue is that HD and Lowes carry products regionally so it's difficult for me to say what the best product is in your local store.
Hi Dane, I need to replace 12 of my windows on a 2011 home due to hail damage that my insurance is covering and I have two quotes. My insurance has approved enough to cover both but I just want to know which is the better window. From what I've seen on your website it sounds like the Simonton, but I wanted to ask the question. Also if it is the Simonton is the price too high? Thanks for your help and your Pella 250 series reviews in advance!
Elgie, the Simonton is indeed the better window of the two. As to price, Home Depot tends to be a bit all over the place. The plus side on HD is you can price out the windows themselves and see the breakdown on product versus installation. Right now, you are paying $845 per window. I can't see the Simonton 6200 windows being more than $350 per window to buy them from HD.
Because of our location and non response from most local window replacement vendors, I have narrowed my search to our local Lowes. (which has a great service reputation). I am looking at the Reliabilt 3900 vs Pella 250. Do you recommend one over the other? I am replacing 27 windows and one will have to be custom built. Looked over you pella windows reviews and have learned a lot, so that is great.
JR, in terms of the Reliabilt 3900 window and the Pella 250 series, I would rate those two very similar to another. If I had to choose one, I would probably go with the Pella 250 over the Reliabilt simply because Pella has a better reputation than Reliabilt. Reliabilt Windows Reviews
Good evening!
Justin, I'm not sure I like any of these. The Pella 250 vinyl window is okay, but the idea of paying $1000 per window is absurd. The HD Simonton 6100 series is a middle of the road window, but at $666 per window, you should be able to get something much better. I would imagine that the Renewal quote will be much higher than any of these.
Tim, I found your website to be very informative and love your Pella 250 series reviews. I have a good vibe from a local company and trust their installation. However, I'm not sure on the cost? I have attached the quote and would be curious to get your opinion.
Drew, the bid looks high to me at first glance. $780 per window installed is about at the top end of what I'd expect for vinyl windows. This doesn't mean that the price is unfair, but I would get a couple more bids.
Sunrise Essentials vs Pella 250 vinyl windows. Which is best?
While the Sunrise Essentials isn't the best window out there, it's a decent window with a .30 U-factor and a .10 air infiltration rate. This is going to be better than Pella's entry level window, the 250 model. If it were my house, I would go with the Sunrise Essentials. If at all possible I would try and stretch into the Sunrise window (sometimes called the standard or classic model). Pella has definitely stepped up their game with the 250 and 350, but I still don't think they can hold a candle to the top tier vinyl window manufacturers.
Pella 250 series vinyl windows vs Polaris Ultraweld. Let me know what you think.
The Polaris Ultraweld over the Pella 250 by a mile. Maybe even a mile and a half :)
Received your msg, forget Pella, took a second look, I'll pass. however do give me your opinion of Mercury Excelum. I've attached 2 PDFs with some specs, compare to American Craftsman or window world, OR Pella 250 , but No installs. ME made nearby in Ct, can get at a local Non big box lumberyard, free delivery, and done business with 20 plus years, they recommend ME.
Rick, thanks for your Pella 250 series reviews page and I agree that the Pella 250 vinyl window is probably one you should pass on. It just doesn't offer the quality that you should be looking for in a vinyl window.
Just read most of your Pella 250 Series Reviews and I need some advice with regard to replacing some wood windows. We have received pricing quotes from Lowes and Home Depot for various VINYL brands. Specifically, Vantage Pointe 6500E, Pella Thermastar and Pella 250 Series. We reside on the East Coast and have a limited budget because of having to replace approximately 18 WOOD windows. Since the estimates have been extremely high, we are looking to contract with a local company in the 22407 zip code area. I would appreciate your recommendation on a window brand.
Bernice, none of the windows you mentioned are super high quality, but the Vantage Pointe 6500E option is probably your best bet. The Pella 250 would be next in line, not a bad vinyl window, but perhaps on the lower end of the mid range. The Pella Thermastar is one of my least favorite vinyl windows out there. Check out our replacement windows by Consumer Reports to verify (I actually don't think Consumer Reports gets much right besides their score on the Thermastar.)
My wife and I recently received quotes by a Pella representative and a Home Depot representative. How do the Pella 250 and 350 compare to the Simonton Vantage Point 6500?
Dave, I would have to give the edge to the Pella 250/350, but not by much. Both of these vinyl windows are right in that mid range option (perhaps a bit on the low side of that mid range). The reason that most consumers like the HD Simonton Vantage Point 6500 is the price, while many consumers go with Pella for the name (usually mistakenly). Pella has definitely stepped up their game with the 250 and 350 series, but they are often going to run more than something like the VantagePointe.
Do you have an opinion of Pella 250 series v. Champion replacement windows? I am looking for double hung replacement windows with installation. Also, I have talked with Pella and Champion reps, as well as Renewal by Andersen (very expensive). Additionally, I am trying to compare vinyl double hung replacement windows with installation. I am finding few manufacturers who have installers within the company, or even long-time relationships with installers.
The Pella 250 and their 350 are certainly better than their previous generation ov vinyl windows, but honestly there are much better places to go for vinyl windows than Pella. Champion makes a stronger vinyl window in my opinion and they do their own installation, which means they know the window well and are well versed in the little tricks that often go into installing a specific model of vinyl window.
I'm replacing 30 year old aluminum windows and am definitely looking at vinyl as my go to selection. We currently have a bid for the Pella 250 window (installed at $575 per window), the Vista Platinum window (installed at $590 per window). I'm expecting a bid on the Wincore 700 window and I may get a bid from Soft-Lite.
Robbie, here is my two cents. First off, you should definitely get the bids from Wincore and Soft-lite. Soft-Lite is going to be the best of the bunch, although they have lots of models so this has to be taken with a grain of salt. Their top end vinyl windows - the Elements, Imperial LS and Pro are all good windows, especially the first two. The Vista Platinum series is decent and I like the 7700 window from Wincore.
I'm in the process of getting some quotes to replace all (21) windows on my house. I've been doing a deep dive on your Pella windows reviews page. The original windows are aluminum frame, single pane. So far I got a quote from Gulf Coast Windows (extremely high), Pella (for their 250 series) and Renewal by Andersen, which was $34,000. To me it seems quite expensive but I really do not know what would be a fair price. Pella quote around $14,000 for the same project using the 250 series. The Pella 250 is a vinyl window and the few reviews that I found weren't good. Any advice on price range and good mid-level windows frames and companies would be really appreciate. BTH, I live in Houston.
Pella definitely is not known for their high quality vinyl windows, although they have made some definite strides in the past several years to improve the overall quality in the 250 and 350 series windows. Both of these windows use the pocket sill however, which I think most installers would agree is not a very good design feature.
Related Topics: Thermo Tech Windows Reviews
However, the 250 series is a good improvement from the company's previous vinyl window offerings. And while the 250 series still uses a poor sill design, the overall build and construction are quite solid. The problem I have with the 250 vinyl window is the overall price point. Because it carries the Pella label, consumers recognize the name and assume that the windows are super high quality. And while this is the case with Pella's wood windows, it's not so much with their vinyl windows.
Overall Rating: Pella 250 Window Series gets a out of 5 stars based on 42 Pella 250 Series reviews below.
My Take On This Window: I would say the Pella 250 window series is a solid mid range vinyl window. If I were in the market for vinyl windows, I think there are better brands and options in many parts of the country. However, if you feel more comfortable with the Pella name, the 250 series is a quality product overall.
(Always Get 3 to 4 Local Price Quotes)
Dane - Site Editor - Original Publish Date - April 16, 2016
Page Last Update: November 11, 2025
Related Topic: Pella Series Reviews
Homeowner Review Section
Dane - Site Editor
Pella 250 Series Cost
Braden - Homeowner - from 2024
[Site Editor's Answer]
Dane - Site Editor - from 2024
Pella 250 Series Windows Cost
Simonton 6200: $19K
Milgard Styline: $20K
Anlin Del Mar: $26.2K
Apex Insignia: $32.5K
Pella 250 Series Reviews Cost: $38K
Milgard Ultra: $44K
Pella Impervia: $57K
Marvin Infinity: $57K
Renewal BY Anderson: $68.5K
Tamas - Homeowner - from 2023
Pella 250 Series
Then we called a local company that sells and installs Sunrise Restoration and their own version of Harvey. The sales person said that no way she would recommend replacement windows for a 1950s house with original windows because of the possibility of rot, etc. Their installers would put in construction windows, which means all new trim and $$. What is your opinion on this advice?
Karen - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
The problem is that it can be difficult to determine whether you can get away with replacement windows when you can't see the potential water damage. But that's where the "lots of bids" comes in -- it's kind of like getting a bunch of free opinions on your best option.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Pella 250 Series Reviews
Steve - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Indianapolis Window Questions
First up was Universal Windows Direct, which had the “today only” pricing. Although it doesn’t play into the decision, I’ve heard they have a reputation for long sales presentation and that’s true. They were here for about 3 hours, probably as long as the other 2 combined. They priced us their windows, which they say are Polaris ThermalWeld with what they claim is a Super Spacer unique to them. Their price came in at $4,529 for the 4 windows. Their price would lock in for 2 years, so if we later got the other windows installed, they would have the same per unit price.
Next was Window World which priced their Series 4000 windows, with the “SolarZone w/ Argon Gas” for $2,798.00. They have a Limited Lifetime Warranty and claim that we’d never have to spend another dime on our windows.
Last was which is just a window contractor and not tied to a specific brand of windows. They provided a quote on Pella 250 series windows with the Low-E coating and Argon gas at $4,655.15. Pella also offers a lifetime warranty and has an office in Indianapolis, so they can send someone out to repair any issues, but do charge a service fee. According to your Pella 250 Series reviews page the ThermalWeld is probably the better bet, yes?
David - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
You might want to gather another bid or two just to be thorough...
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Replacing Original Wood Windows
Is this our forever home??? Well maybe not if I can't seal the house against the harsh winter months. My plan is to replace 20 rather large windows and possibly replace the cedar siding. My first three quotes were received from Andersen Renewal, Marvin and James Hardie who sell composite siding and windows. Each company quoted an excess of $2,000 per window; ranging from $42,000 to $47,000.
I decided to go to Lowe's. The Pella 250 series without installation was $8,472. I have a contractor who will install them for $200 per window. He recommended a Viwinco. Their windows were similar to Pella 250 but the frame and sash were heavier. After doing more research, I discovered Zen Windows and was able to get a quote without installation for $10,420 for the Nirvana - Soft-Lite's Classic Plus Line; about $2,000 more than Pella from Lowe's.
I'm looking for the best value for the money and to be able to use my sub-contractor for the install. I feel comfortable spending $600 for a good window. I've spent numerous hours researching, still not ready to make a decision. Any advice you can provide is greatly appreciated. Thank you.
Stephanie - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Pella Windows Reviews vs Renewal By Andersen
In 2018, we did file a warranty ticket. We did that when we came back home after a vacation to frozen, almost dripping windows. Someone came, checked the windows out and we just needed a new seal. He replaced some and left the rest. The windows have always been drafty and the trim etc shows wear. Fast forward to now, when we opened one of the windows to replace the weather stripping, the sash and sides literally fell out and a lot more of the windows are close to that point.
The windows are nothing but crap, Windsor Windows based out of Des Moines. I did reach out to the current President, who seems to be approachable, if nothing else but will see what transpires. In the meantime, I realize that we may need to replace the windows and have gotten quotes, maybe too many. We are not very handy people and purchased the house we did, just for that reason.
Lowes - $24,376
2 windows (68x64), living room (113x84), 7 sunroom windows (38x68)
Renewal by Andersen - $39,648
18 windows and they are running a buy 1 get 1 40% off
Window World - $27,000
1 slider, 8 pic windows, 12 casements
Pella - Pella 250 Series - $27385
Limited lifetime warranty, 10 year on installation
Hometown Restyling - $37,658
Sunrise/Restoration Windows
Suburban Construction - Davenport IA
Waiting on a quote from them. But also trying to research their windows and coming up short. AMI windows?
I am so confused. I know that most if not all our windows are on its way out. I'm trying to figure out if I should be just replacing the windows that need it immediately or all. If I replace just the ones that need it immediately, current ones have country style grinds and the new ones will be without grids, so they won't match but we also aren't looking to move (oh heavens no) anytime soon if we can help it.
Maybe I overdid the free consultation? But there are just too many options and too little money :( I am thinking that Lowes is out since their install warranty is 1 year. Hometown and Suburban are well reputable companies in the area I live in (Coralville IA). Pella is local to Iowa, and I do have extended friends that are using them to replace the windows but they are limited warranty on the windows vs AMI, which is a lifetime warranty.
Appreciate any insight you can provide.
Shanthi - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
I don’t love WW and would never have an AMI window in my home. Pella makes a decent window, and that’s good that they are local. If the installation company had an amazing reputation I would consider them. I know you’ve already collected a bunch of bids, but here is my list of good and great windows in case you want to continue your search: [list pulled]
Dane - Site Editor - from 2021
Lots Of Replacement Window Questions
Quote was $2600 for the 250 series including the install- that seemed a little pricey to me. Home Depot is coming tomorrow and I think they push their own brand- not sure what it is Jen Weld maybe. Could use your advise on if this is a good direction to go or should I shop around some more. Thank you in advance.
Joe - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
In addition, I would search for a Sunrise dealer who services your area. The Apex Insignia is a viable option in Utah. Marvin makes fiberglass windows but worth a quote. A high end Simonton would also be something I would consider. Impressions 9800 or Reflections 5500 are good models to look at. This is where I would start.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2021
Pella 250 Series
I am receiving a quote from lowes for pella 250 windows but I'm not seeing great reviews on them. I also have thermo-tech windows available in my area.
What are your thoughts on thermo-tech vs pella?
Also do you know of any others available in my area I should look into? I'm in crookston, mn. Not far from fargo north dakota or if you know grand forks nd.
Thanks and I look forward to your thoughts.
Tony - Homeowner - from 2021
[Site Editor's Answer]
Here are some additional options you may want to look at. Thermo Tech Windows Reviews
Tim - Site Editor - from 2021
[Tony's Reply]
These quotes are for 250 and 350 windows. There are 2 quotes for each as I had him quote some add-on windows I wasn't sure if I'm doing right away.
He screwed up the quote and has 6 single double hungs instead of 5. When I told him he said to deduct off 973 dollars off the 250 quote.
Total for the 6 windows is $12,664.
That tells me he is charging me 973 dollars for a 36 x 54 double hung installed. That's crazy. He wouldn't break down cost of window and labor separate and now I see why.
I really doubt the other guys come in this high. Even if they come in higher I'm not going with lowes and Pella.
Tony - Homeowner - from 2021
Pella 250 Reviews
The first quote (which included the 2 non-standard windows) was $26K windows and $17K installation totaling $43K. When I didn't respond I got a "reduced" quote of $25.5K and $14K totaling $39.5K. These quotes seem way out of line with the usual range of pricing in your reviews. What should I expect to pay for a replacement double hung vinyl window in the mid-range category from a good manufacturer?
Danny - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
A good mid range vinyl window should run $400 to $500 per window.
However, your project might have extra installation requirements or tearouts that is driving the price up.
I'd suggest getting a few more bids to get a better understanding of price and available brands and windows in your area.
Check out our recommended windows pages to see some solid brands and windows that may be available in your area. Google Sunrise windows in [your city, state] and see what companies come up. Do this for all the recommended brands.
replacementwindowsreviews.co/best-replacement-windows/
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Pella vs Lindsay Pinnacle
One contractor gave us a quote on the Lindsay Pinnacle for $13,400. He also carries the Pella 250 series for roughly the same price. Is this a good deal?
Julie - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Pella 250 Price vs. Simonton 6500 Price
Fred - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Pella Windows vs Provia Aspect
So far I have quotes from Pella (250series), and Provia (aspect series). Curious if in your opinion there is much of a difference in the quality between the two, as the quotes per window are roughly double. (1000 for the pella and 600 for the Provia,)
Any input would be appreciated.
Jim - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Pella 250 Bid vs. Milgard Stlyeline
Jesse - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Pella vs. Reliabilit Windows
We’re looking to replace 13 windows and have received quotes from replacement by Andersen (38k), pella 250 from Lowe’s (10,200), and reliabilit (waiting on final quote, though expected to be less than pella). At this point I’m not comfortable with Andersen due to price & the other two options don’t have impressive reviews, plus I’m doubting the quality of installation Lowe’s will provide.
My next step is to find contractors to provide me with estimates, but I’m hoping you can recommend one or more reliable, mid-grade window brands. We’re in northern NJ where the winters are cold and windy & the summers manageable. Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you in advance for your individualized help and for the incredible knowledge your Pella 250 Series reviews provides.
Janel - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
The Pella 250 vinyl window is not a quality window in my opinion. Reliabilt premium series is a decent mid range window.
Since you are in New Jersey, I’d recommend getting a bid from Ideal, which makes excellent vinyl windows in the Majestic and Platinum 3000 series.
You should also look at Okna, Soft-Lite, Sunrise, and even Zen windows to see if they have dealers in your area. You could consider their entry level windows, but I’d prefer you go with their standard or premium window series. Price wise, these shouldn’t run more than the Pella — they might, but that’s where the multiple bids come in.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
Pella 250 Series Replacement
Pella 250 Series.
Stationary tree windows in the middle. One casement window opening on each end.
$4936 replacing seat-board also
Estimate from Home Depot
6500 5 casement panels same design as Pella $4168
Simonton 6100 same as above $3788
I have a local guy who sells Anderson windows who came and gave rough estimate between $7500 to $10,000. Definitely cannot go this route.
I have read your reviews about installation and now worry about HD although they have the best estimate. I also worry about warranty now.
Thanks for your help!
Kay - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
The Simonton 6500 series sounds like your best bet so far. My point on the HD installation was to be vigilant about who is coming out to do the work. I would insist on seeing reviews on the company. The other route is to buy from HD and then find your own installer using yelp or Angie’s list.
You may want to see if there is a Sunrise dealer in your area or a Zen dealer. Same thing with the Zen dealers, you need to read the specific reviews on them to make sure they have a solid reputation. Let me know how the project goes and good luck.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
[Kay's Reply]
Kay - Homeowner - from 2019
Pella Windows vs Sunrise
I also have a bid on the Sunrise V Series for $11,508 (which includes installation and tax).
Is the Sunrise V Class window worth the extra money? The Sunrise dealer charges $240 per window for custom exterior colors.
They are charging me $1930 for a window (36 X 90) with a circle top, $1820 for a window (36 x 60) with an eyebrow shape at the top. The normal windows are coming in anywhere from $730 to $820.
Chris - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Pella Windows vs Revere Sovereign
Revere Sovereign Window: $5,450
Pella 250 Windows: $9,865
Thank you in advance for any input and your Pella 250 series reviews!
Micah - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Pella vs Simonton
Another bid came in for the Pella 250, but that one only has a 62 Consumer Reports rating.
The bids were equal in price, more or less.
Which is the better window and how much should I rely on Consumer Reports?
Nancy - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
The Pella 250 isn't a great vinyl window as you can probably tell from the Consumer Ratings. Now I don't actually put a ton of stock in Consumer Reports, but they are correct in how these two windows relate to one another.
If the prices are the same, then go with the Reflections series.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
250 Series vs. Simonton 6100
Any input on prices, workmanship, longevity? Is one a better window & craftsmanship? Are these windows comparable to each other or am I comparing apples to oranges? We have been quoted on:
Pella 250 series from Lowes: removing 15 existing windows and replacing (installing) with 11 windows at $10,660.00
Simonton 6100 series from Home Depot: removing 15 existing windows and replacing (installing) 14 windows at $15,238.00
Renewal by Anderson: Removing 15 existing windows and replacing (installing) 13 at $30,000.00 - not in our budget
They both are offering a 15% discount on their above listed prices.
Your input would be greatly appreciated. Hopefully you can get back to us in a couple of days.
Anxiously awaiting your reply.
Brand - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
I think you should get two bids from non big box stores to see how a local dealer's pricing compares. Perhaps a Simonton dealer on the Reflections 5500, the Ply Gem Pro or a dealer with PGT or CWS. I'll bet you can get a better window for roughly that same $10500 price. Your choice whether you want to take that extra step, but the Pella is the best deal of what you have so far. Lower installation can be spotty so make sure they send their A-team to do your project. Insist on it.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Pella 250 Series Reviews
I've narrowed my search to two windows: the Pella 250 (which I can get for a good deal from Lowe's- unfortunately), and Harvey Classic (which is carried by a local supplier who says I'm getting them at their contractor's price because I do business with them). I'm replacing 8 openings altogether but several are very large in size ranging from 32" wide double hung to 72" wide sliders. My plan is to replace them all with double hung and fill the larger openings with twin and triple units (factory mulled together).
My estimate for the Harvey windows came in at about $4,000 and the estimate for the Pella is around $3,300. I was set on buying the Harveys but then I noticed on their spec sheet that their Classic windows come standard with a half-screen and they want an additional $300+ for the full screen upgrade. Pella I believe comes with a full screen. $4,000 is my budget and that puts the Harvey estimate at $1,100 more than Pella.
I've lived with Pella replacement windows in my current home for about 10 years now and they seem adequate to me. They haven't given me any issues and they still function fine while having that standard cheap white vinyl appearance. But all of those are very small windows- mostly 3' x 3' double hung with full screens. I've never seen Harvey's installed and I've only seen a small sample in the store and the salesman there isn't much help. Here are my concerns:
1. I know Harvey is the better window, but what does that actually mean?
2. How rigid will either model be when it comes to the larger ROs? Will they be strong in a 72"w x 48"h opening with triples, or a 60"w x 60"h opening with twins? More on window prices by sizes.
3. Does the pricing sound good for the Harvey's? It seems average to me- not "contractor pricing" but I could be very wrong.
4. Do you think the quality of the Harvey windows is worth the extra $1,100+ ?
5. Are full screens really much more convenient than half screens? Worth the extra $300+? Is that something I can upgrade to in the future?
Thanks a lot for your help guys!
Josh - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
The Harvey Classic is definitely worth the extra money. $45 per window to go from the half to the full screen is not a surprising number. $500 per window sounds about right, but normally that would include installation so I am a bit surprised by the cost. You should have the Harvey dealer come out and give you a bid to see -- ask him to breakdown the bid into material and installation cost!
The windows ought to be plenty strong for those openings. If you want to double check this, get a couple bids from other window dealers in the area and pick their brains. They don't have to know that you're planning on doing the work yourself. You can pick up lots of info, tips, tricks, etc. for local installers at a grand total cost to you of nothing. It's usually a pretty idea-opening experience...
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Pella 250 vs. Zen Nirvana
Pella 250: $15,264.00
Zen Nirvana: $10421.00
I’m not opposed to negotiating to get a lower price.
Thank you.
Dorothy - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Good luck on your project the winner of the two windows ought to be clear...
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Pella vs Atrium
Duff - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Pella 250 vs. Simonton 6200
Lowes
Pella 250
$7,500
Home Depot
Simonton 6200
$10,149
Elgie - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
I'm not a huge fan of HD installers because they are often paid per window, which means they are incentivized to go quickly. If it were me, I would probably buy the windows from HD and then go on yelp, angies list or craigslist and find a highly reputable installer and have him come give me a bid to install the windows. You will often save some money and insure that the installation is solid.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Pella 250 Window or Reliabilit 3900 Series
JR - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Prior to the 350 and 250 series from Pella, the company made relatively bad vinyl windows. This latest iteration has been a big improvement. I guess that would be the driving factor for me, although I have to say I’m not the biggest fan of buying windows from these big box stores because they typically carry the entry-level series from the companies they carry.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Pella 250 Series vs. Simonton 6100 Series
I have been looking at your site for weeks now and going crazy on what windows to get. FYI, I live by the jersey shore. I have had 3 companies come out so far.
18 double hungs
Home Depot Simonton 6100 Series - $12000 Home Depot Windows Reviews
Pella 250 Series - $18,898
Anderson Renewal - Coming out soon to give me pricing.
Can you maybe suggest something else in my area I can look at?
Thank you very much!
Justin - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
It is possible that your project involves some extensive installation work that is driving up the cost, but so far I don't see any of these bids as great.
I would start by getting a bid from the local Okna dealer on their entry-level 400 series. I would also see if there is a Sunrise, Soft-Lite, Polaris, or Zen dealer that could give you a bid. All of their "entry-level" windows are going to be superior to the Simonton 6100 series or the 250 Pella series.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Pella vs Polaris
They are about $1,000 less than a quote I got on Pella 200 series directly from Pella. As you know they are WAY Less than the Andersen Replacement that uses Fibrex? Any input would be appreciated. The original bid was for 12 Polaris ThermalWeld Windows and 1 UltraWeld patio door. The total on the project bid was $15,200. Thanks!
Drew - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Pella is always a high bid, as is Renewal, so I'm not sure you can look at those and feel secure in your Polaris bid.
Google whether Sunrise, Okna, Soft-Lite, Wallside, or Vytex is available in your area. Hopefully you can get two more bids and then make your decision.
You may also want to take a look at this article...the Polaris dealer will probably come down off his price is he thinks you are getting multiple bids from competitors. Wallside Windows reviews
https://www.replacementwindowsreviews.co/review-topics/negotiating-a-home-window-bid.html
Dane - Site Editor - from 2017
Pella 250 vs Sunrise Essentials
Brian - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Dane - Site Editor - from 2017
Pella 250 Window vs Polaris Ultraweld
Robert - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Dane - Site Editor - from 2017
Pella 250 Windows vs Mercury Excelum
I'm installing the 11 windows myself, filling the cavities, caulking well, trimming the interior trim, and leaving the storm windows in place, so as not to change the looks of this huge house of 30 + windows, 3 stories high. You opinion is important to me that I make the correct choice. Thank You in advance.
Rick - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
American Craftsman is probably worse than Pella in terms of overall quality so let's toss that one as well.
I know very little about the Mercury Excelum brand, but I did take a look at the brochure you included.
The 3/4 inch IG low-e double hung (40" by 63" test size) gets .27 u-value, .28 shgc, .52 VT, and a .04 air infiltration. These are good numbers. The company has been around since 1953, so they obviously make a product that contractors and builders have been using for decades. I can't speak to the individual parts because they aren't listed in the brochure.
The numbers for the Mercury Advantage series (I'm not quite sure if this a lower end series, their website is unclear on this point) were decidedly less impressive, particularly the .21 air infiltration. Anything above .15 causes me some concern.
You are obviously limited in what you have access to as a DIYer and I think that the Mercury Excelum looks like a good choice -- I don't know what price you are getting, but if you have access to a vinyl window that is offering a .04 AI I think you should feel comfortable in terms of quality.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Pella 250 Series vs Vantage Pointe 6500E
Bernice - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
I think you should at least get a couple of quotes from local dealers, not HD and Lowes, although with your tight budget it might be tough. The two brands I would recommend are Okna and Sunrise, both of which should be available in Virginia.
Since you are on a budget, I would say look up companies that offer these window brands and call them up and tell them you want a quote on their entry level window window, the Okna 400 series and the Sunrise Bainbridge option. These windows are going to be MUCH better than the windows you have selected. I'm not sure they will be in your budget, but I will say that long term they may be the cheaper alternative, especially if you are going to be staying in your home for a long time.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Pella 250 Windows vs Simonton Vantage Point
Dave - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
The big issue I have with HD is the installation quality with the use of subcontractors who are paid a very low rate for their services. Also, I don't find this to be a recipe for quality (certainly not always the case, but I've heard enough stories to know it can be true).
Additionally, I would be curious to know how these compare to one another in terms of price? I would have to assume that the Pella option was quite a bit more. If it were me, I would get a couple more quotes to before I pulled the trigger. Where are you located, I could make a couple of suggestions if you'd like.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Pella 250 Series vs. Champion Windows
So far, I have found and received estimates from Champion and Pella 250 series) and also for Renewal by Andersen fibrex windows (very expensive). The Champion warranty seems better, but also seems too good to be true – why would they agree to replace a window damaged by a rock thrown by a mower? For a trip fee?
Do you have an opinion on the comparative quality and reliability of the Champion and Pella 250 series windows? Thank you.
Betsy - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
The one criticism of Champion from some consumers is that the company charges a premium price for a good (but not great) product. This will certainly depend on the salesperson you get etc. The window breakage provision is a good one and they can offer it because they are a big company and have lots of window parts and glass on hand.
Assuming you like the price from Champion, I'd say go for it. Check our Pella 250 series reviews page for more. Please let me know how it works for you!
Dane - Site Editor - from 2016
250 Model vs Soft-Lite Windows
I've done lots of research but it's all starting to get a bit muddled, there is a lot of confusing information out there! I'd like to get your opinion(s).
Robbie - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
They are probably on par with the Soft-Lite Pro, which is an older model from Soft-Lite. The Pella 250 is a tier below these other series and therefore not worth the price you were quoted in my opinion. I would suggest getting all of your quotes and then emailing me back and let me know the numbers and we'll go from there! And in the meantime, make sure you read a few of our Pella Windows reviews to get acquainted with the brand!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Pella 250 Series Reviews
Damian - Homeowner - from 2014
[Contractor Response]
Most of the bigger players in the industry have seen the market share of vinyl windows grow over the last decade and obviously want to part of it. I'd still be hesitant to tell my customers to go with Pella vinyl windows, not because I think they are poor in quality, but instead that there are so many good vinyl options out there. Finally, my recommendation is to look for more Pella 250 Series reviews to check prices and options.
Barry - Contractor - from 2014
* Victory Home Remodeling Reviews